5. The second question concerned the funeral prayer (for non-Ahmadis).
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 August 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: The second question concerned the funeral prayer (for non-Ahmadis).
Regarding the funeral prayer: the Holy Prophet (saw) did not offer the funeral prayer of a debtor who died in debt. And regarding those who called themselves Muslims and died in his time, Allah had forbidden him to offer their funeral prayer; but he permitted other Muslims, while he himself did not offer it. This proves that the funeral prayer is a Fard Kifaya of the Ummah: if part of the Ummah offers it and another part does not due to some wrong, there is no blame on them. Under this principle Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh) gave a fatwa when asked from Scandinavia by phone or telegram: a plane has crashed here, among them are some Muslims, probably not Ahmadis, and there is no one else here to offer their funeral prayer – what is the ruling? Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III replied: certainly offer their funeral prayer, because in the Ummah of Muhammad no one who believes in the Holy Prophet (saw) will be buried without a funeral prayer; it is his basic right. Where others offer it, it is not necessary for everyone. Therefore denial [of the Mahdi] is graver – denying the Mahdi is graver than a debtor dying in debt. Do you not see the clear difference? If this is the right of the Holy Prophet (saw), and they themselves prove that for a sinner (fasiq) you have the right not to offer it as long as others do, then denial of the Imam Mahdi is a far greater offence. Therefore the Promised Messiah (as) forbade it, and there is no cause for concern, since others offer it, that suffices. But that was not the only reason; it was also done to avoid strife. And it was not a matter initiated by the Promised Messiah (as). For years he continuously admonished the ulama: do not issue fatwas of disbelief against me, otherwise, in light of the guidance of the Holy Prophet (saw), I will be compelled to declare you disbelievers. He quoted hadith and held to this position. When they did not desist, he finally gave the fatwa. After that the question of the funeral prayer no longer arose. But at the same time he set a condition: if a person neither declares him a disbeliever nor calls him a liar, and is clearly asked and does not deny the Promised Messiah (as) nor call him a liar, his funeral prayer can be offered; there is no restriction on it. If someone says the ulama are wrong and the Promised Messiah (as) told no lie in his claim, then his funeral prayer can be offered. If he says, I cannot say this before people, then he is a hypocrite and we will not accept his word; for one who declares it openly, it is permissible. That is a clear difference. Lastly, something he may not know: all other sects have issued fatwas against offering the funeral prayer of other sects. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is the only one that issued no such fatwa against any sect. Our fatwa does not have the same basis as theirs. The Promised Messiah (as) nowhere said that the funeral prayer of a Wahhabi, Barelvi or Shia cannot be offered. He said: you have accepted me as Imam; whoever calls me a liar and says I lie against God, do not offer his funeral prayer. This is so reasonable: whoever believes the Promised Messiah (as) – God forbid – is a liar, or whose relatives or guardians believe so, their heartfelt wish should be that we not offer their funeral prayer. For on one hand they call him a liar, a fabricator against God, a mischief-maker in religion, and on the other wish that we offer their funeral prayer or they find no peace – this is a contradiction. For them it is a favour that this fatwa was given, so that we do not hurt them by offering it. Show me one place where the Promised Messiah (as) said not to offer the funeral prayer of a Sunni, Wahhabi or Shia. He treated all equally, with only the condition: whoever does not declare me a fabricator against God, by all means offer his funeral prayer; for one who declares me a disbeliever and a liar, do not; do not pray behind him and do not offer his funeral prayer.