8. Someone asked: Hazrat Mirza Sahib received an education and also held employment. He says no prophet or messiah who ever came was employed, and none acquired education from a human being.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 August 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Someone asked: Hazrat Mirza Sahib received an education and also held employment. He says no prophet or messiah who ever came was employed, and none acquired education from a human being.
Did you ask him what proof he has, from the Holy Qur’an or the divine scriptures? Until someone provides proof for his claim, one should not accept his objection. First understand this basic principle and you will be spared many difficulties forever. The Holy Qur’an itself taught this method: 'Bring your proof.' If you start answering every objection anyone raises, you will never be done with difficulties. The Holy Qur’an teaches the principle: whoever makes a claim, let him bring his proof. [Questioner: He said, if you prove …] No, whoever claims and objects must first prove his statement. That is one thing; I am first telling you the principle. He made two claims: first, that no prophet can learn worldly knowledge; second, that no prophet can serve anyone. Did you ask for proof? [No.] Then ask when you meet him, and in future ask for proof whenever an objection is raised. For what you yourself accept, do not ask for proof; but this goes against your belief, so first ask for his proof. Now the counter-evidence: does he accept Hazrat Joseph as a prophet? Was he not in Pharaoh's service? Do you not know that he himself asked for the post: 'Set me over the treasuries'? Hazrat Joseph (as) asked for the office of the treasury and was appointed in charge. It is even said that under the king's law he had no right to detain his brother. He had limited powers and was bound by his law. Allah says: We devised a plan for Joseph; had We not, he was so bound by the laws that he could do nothing on his own. So his claim is false. Second: for the Holy Prophet (saw) the word 'Ummi' occurs in the Holy Qur’an. Does it occur anywhere for other prophets? Have you ever heard 'Nabi Ummi' for any other prophet? Ask him: on one hand you take pride that only Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) is the Nabi Ummi, on the other you include all prophets in this distinction without proof. If all were Ummi, what then is the distinction of the Holy Prophet (saw)? So both objections are wrong. Not only does he have no proof, we have proof to the contrary. Then Moses (as): did he not bring the tablets? He brought them written, and there was no one else writing; Hazrat Moses wrote on the tablets himself. Likewise Allah says in the Holy Qur’an about other prophets that they judged by the Torah, read the Torah, recited it to people and learned from it; they learned reading and writing. The prophets of the Children of Israel were educated. [Interjection] That is not in the Holy Qur’an. What he means – he lacks full knowledge – is that knowledge of religion and its deep understanding the prophet receives from God, not from the world. There is no prohibition on ordinary, everyday knowledge like reading and writing. That is why Allah used the word 'al-Mahdi' for the Promised Messiah (as), so that when the mullahs object one can say: he receives knowledge of religion from God and guidance from God. If he learned it from you, would he be the guided one? What is excluded is receiving guidance; the prophet receives guidance only from God. That is why elsewhere, mentioning the prophets, it says 'yahduna bi-amrina': as far as guidance is concerned, they give it by Our command, not without it. So the prophet receives guidance from God; worldly knowledge he of course learns. Did the Holy Prophet (saw) not learn to speak and walk? Is oral knowledge not knowledge too, or only written? If a blind man passes the Maulvi Fazil exam without writing or reading, will he not be called a student? Every child learns oral knowledge from parents and people, and prophets are included in this. Learning worldly knowledge, colloquial speech, everyday conversation and language, whether written or oral, makes no difference. Nowhere has the Holy Qur’an, even by implication, said a prophet can do this and not that.