9. [Partly unintelligible] We believe that Hazrat Muhammad (saw) is the Prophet of God and call him the last prophet; of the 124,000 prophets … If Hazrat Masih Mau’ud (as) is also a prophet, why can we not call him the last prophet? [Later:] Allah says: 'Between me and him there is no prophet' – between the Promised Messiah and me there is no other prophet; the Holy Prophet (saw) called the Messiah a prophet four times in the hadith. We say the prophet of the latter days is Hazrat Muhammad (saw), and the Promised Messiah (as) is also a prophet – why do we not call him the last prophet?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 August 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: [Partly unintelligible] We believe that Hazrat Muhammad (saw) is the Prophet of God and call him the last prophet; of the 124,000 prophets … If Hazrat Masih Mau’ud (as) is also a prophet, why can we not call him the last prophet? [Later:] Allah says: 'Between me and him there is no prophet' – between the Promised Messiah and me there is no other prophet; the Holy Prophet (saw) called the Messiah a prophet four times in the hadith. We say the prophet of the latter days is Hazrat Muhammad (saw), and the Promised Messiah (as) is also a prophet – why do we not call him the last prophet?
Mistakenly 'last' – we cannot say it, because how do you know what will happen later? Have you guaranteed the future? So far he cannot be the last. 'The last' is an inappropriate term … We regard the Holy Prophet (saw) as the last possessor of command and the last bearer of Shariah; that is clear, God has said that no other can come whose command and Shariah continue until the Day of Judgement. Subordinate to him came the Promised Messiah (as). If God sends someone in future, can you stand in the way? At most we can say – and this is the position we should take – whoever comes, we are bound to 'bima unzila ilaika'; we are servants of what was revealed to the Holy Prophet (saw), nothing beyond. If what was revealed to him mentions someone to come and belief in him is required, we will certainly believe in him, because he is included. Hence it is our duty and position regarding the Promised Messiah (as) to prove that he came according to the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (saw). We hold that we know of no other prophecy from which we could say with certainty that another will come who will likewise be titled Messiah and Mahdi, or Ummati Prophet. The general grace 'The scholars of my Ummah are like the prophets of the Children of Israel' will continue, but beyond that we have no knowledge. Yet God may send someone in future and give him proof and knowledge Himself. Therefore it is not right to close the way of those to come entirely by fatwa. [To the second question:] We too believe he is a prophet. First: whoever enters under the shadow of a prophet who is bearer of Shariah and command, entering his Ummah, his independent claim ends. To clarify this the Promised Messiah (as) had to write again and again, from which the Paighamis (Lahore group) wrongly took advantage. This is what he was explaining: in one sense I am a prophet and in another I am not, because I have been merged into the Holy Prophet (saw); not a particle of me goes beyond his Shariah, not beyond his command; all I received, I received through him. If you separate me, his finality is attacked and a separate line begins. Because he wanted to explain this, such passages came about which the Paighamis exploit. Why do you want to drag the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat into that cycle again? It is enough that the Holy Prophet (saw) is the last bearer of Shariah and the last possessor of command. I distinguish these two, as I explained before, and try again: bearer of Shariah in the sense that God is the Lawgiver; the Holy Prophet (saw) himself is not the lawgiver – today's ulama wrongly call him so, against the earlier agreed position. All four schools of fiqh and other leading jurists agreed that God is the Lawgiver, not the prophet; Shariah springs from God. So with regard to Shariah he is the last. The second aspect is command: the Shariah revealed said of him that his command must be obeyed and one may not deviate. Besides, it declared him the excellent model. If 'Obey Allah', that is the Book, sufficed, why would God need to say 'and His Messenger'? And repeatedly this theme was set out: not only regarding Shariah, but within its bounds, whatever this prophet commands must be obeyed. After this clarification his command too continues until the Day of Judgement, and no non-law-bearing prophet can set aside his command by saying: I am within the Shariah, the Shariah continues, but I abolish this command or that principle. Therefore we should state clearly that the Holy Prophet (saw) is the last bearer of Shariah and the last possessor of command. The Promised Messiah (as) was so meticulous in this that when someone asked why he did not forbid smoking tobacco, he said: what the Holy Prophet (saw) did not forbid, I cannot forbid. He was one hundred percent careful never to go beyond the instruction of the Holy Prophet (saw) at any cost. The meaning was: if the Holy Prophet (saw) did not include such a thing in the definition of 'khamr' (intoxicant) in the Holy Qur’an, I cannot include it either; I am not authorised. In this sense the Holy Prophet (saw) is the last prophet. And since a prophet also has command, the Promised Messiah (as) is subordinate to the Holy Prophet (saw) with regard to command too and confined within its bounds; hence we cannot call him a separate prophet. Understood? The second reason: we cannot call him the last prophet even so, not even with these conditions. For if you say it, you decide conclusively, as if we knew the unseen, and claim that after the Promised Messiah (as) God cannot raise anyone. Then where does that verse of the Holy Qur’an go? Must one first remove it? It is a continuing verse; under it, it is God's will to send or not; we cannot impose a bar. Another point: we used to say with great enthusiasm in preaching – and still do – proving that at the head of every century such and such [reformers] came. Now the opponent says: who is your reformer at the head of this century? We say: our Khalifa Sahib. Fine. But they say: it is said that God will raise him. Who makes the Khilafat? 'Allah has promised those among you who believe and do good works that He will surely make them successors.' Who is the doer? Allah. So tell them that.