13. Hudhur, at weddings in Pakistan the bride's side sometimes gives a dowry. Among the Arabs it is the custom to set a price on the girl; the bride's family says beforehand we will take two lakh rupees, or one or three lakh, and the money is sent beforehand. There is also a condition regarding virginity: if it is not met when she goes to the husband, they return the girl, the money is refunded, and she is afterwards free to marry or not. Is this permissible?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: Hudhur, at weddings in Pakistan the bride's side sometimes gives a dowry. Among the Arabs it is the custom to set a price on the girl; the bride's family says beforehand we will take two lakh rupees, or one or three lakh, and the money is sent beforehand. There is also a condition regarding virginity: if it is not met when she goes to the husband, they return the girl, the money is refunded, and she is afterwards free to marry or not. Is this permissible?

(First remark: this is impermissible in Islam.) Haq Mahr can be given before marriage, and they take it so. What matters is how they treat her after paying – as Mahr, or like a bargain and sale. Until the details are known, no fatwa can be given. (Interjection on general Arab practice.) If you ask a general question, the answer is: in general this can be justified. But if you put it as you did, that among the Arabs a price is set, then it is impermissible; in Islam there is no setting of a price. A price is set for the woman, whereas Mahr is about the worth of the man. The philosophy of Mahr is fundamentally different from that of a price: the man gives according to his means, regardless of what the woman's family is like or her own status. What they do is a price of the woman; by contrast Mahr is measured by the man. In practice the forms change completely: if a king who is a millionaire marries a poor woman, under this Arab philosophy, if the poor woman's price is four hundred dirhams, he gives only four hundred – which is impermissible from the Islamic viewpoint. From the Islamic viewpoint, whether he marries a poor, a rich or a beautiful woman, he must fix Mahr according to his own status. The philosophy of Mahr is to take the man's means into account, not the woman's. (Interjection: they go to India because it is cheaper.) I am giving you the answer, not whether they do it or not. You asked an Islamic issue, I answered, that is enough. (Further reports from the audience: girls are brought from India; at two or three weddings someone attended Mahr was not even mentioned, only the sum was fixed. Customs differ by region; in Libya there is neither Mahr nor a price; it is a custom to fix an amount not as a price but as a gift to the bride's family for her trousseau; the girl is free after marriage; there 40-50% of cases are divorce cases.)

10 of 10 left today