5. A second question: a strong objection is raised against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat (…reference to Hazrat Syed Ahmad Barelvi Shaheed and another statement, including one of a 'Chaudhry Sahib'…) that the Holy Land (Palestine) will not be conquered by the sword. What does that mean?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: A second question: a strong objection is raised against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat (…reference to Hazrat Syed Ahmad Barelvi Shaheed and another statement, including one of a 'Chaudhry Sahib'…) that the Holy Land (Palestine) will not be conquered by the sword. What does that mean?

You have taken one thing, mixed it with a second and a third, and instead of opening up the subject you have made it obscure. (Gap) What Hazrat Masih-e-Mau'ud (as) meant was that sometimes, before the start of a new era, its signs begin, as with the Messiah (…), whose lineage (on the father's side) is not seen and who was born without a father. The purpose was to show — and the Messiah (as) has expounded this — that an era is ending, that the Isaaci era is coming to its close and now the Ismaili era is about to begin; this line is now ended, and God provided an outward sign for it. Hazrat Masih-e-Mau'ud (as) meant that the message was that the era of jihad with the sword is now ending and jihad will now show its colour in another way. That much is the purpose of Hazrat Masih-e-Mau'ud (as). As for the contest over the Holy Land, that subject (is dealt with by) the Holy Qur’an (…). The commentators of the Holy Qur’an have also taken 'al-Ard' (the land) to mean the land of Palestine. And the other example, that you will twice create disorder in the land, and all those verses — if you put them together with this meaning and reflect (…) that (the righteous servants) are made its heirs. Eras come when such a period begins in which wickedness has taken over, and then (…) God (…) without reason (…) no distinction. Another decree becomes manifest, a decree of punishment or of shaking awake. Thus when Baghdad was attacked, the king of that time had a saint from Delhi called to pray, because there was great danger to the Islamic world (…). (Gap) (He related:) I kept praying, and at night (I saw) that (a father) had his son beaten by a servant. That does not mean the servant is dearer to him than the son; at that moment it means he wants to show the son: you have gone so far in this matter, I want to teach you a lesson; this one is not my relative, there is no blood tie, yet I am having you punished by him. That is one aspect of it, but it is not permanent. Therefore, Chaudhry Sahib, your reference is completely unrelated and meaningless. Chaudhry Sahib (the person quoted) had a great status of his own, but this is a political opinion; bringing it into the religious sphere and saying that his statement will surely be fulfilled and the prophecy of the Holy Qur’an, God forbid, will not — this is totally wrong. Nor did he mean that; he held the Holy Qur’an (in esteem). You have taken his words out of context (…). (Gap) (The Holy Qur’an) said (…) from this it follows that they will in any case have to leave it, but God is waiting for the time when a community, as righteous servants, becomes heir to the land. Whether today or tomorrow, that remains to be seen, when that time is; but from these two things it becomes clear. As far as the subject of jihad is concerned, it has only this much connection: let me tell you an incident. (Gap) (A visitor said:) I want to meet your Khalifa. (I was told) he wanted to ask questions; I sensed a certain sharpness and felt he would argue and behave rudely. I said: I will not introduce you; first ask me questions and then I will talk further. He (raised) the question of jihad: what are we doing then? You say we deny jihad and that this is not jihad (…). (Gap) (I said:) What does the Holy Qur’an say? I will show you where. In Surah al-Hajj, where permission for jihad was first given, it says: 'Udhina lilladhina yuqataluna bi-annahum zulimu, wa innallaha 'ala nasrihim laqadir … ukhriju min diyarihim bi-ghairi haqq'. This is its detail. Right at the start of the statement Allah added this, and what the reason was: it means that God is giving permission to those who have been wronged to raise the sword against those by whom, out of injustice, they are being cut down with the sword — without any legitimate reason, out of injustice, the sword has been raised against them. This is the statement of the Holy Qur’an, the opening: permission is given to them. I explained this to him. I said: this statement shows that certain poor people are so weak, so helpless and defenceless that any Tom, Dick and Harry can get up and start oppressing them, and although they provide no reason, they are beaten one-sidedly. If God gave these poor people permission, they would be killed even more. If a strong man is beating a weak man and he silently takes the beating, there is some chance of his survival; but if you incite him: hit back, don't care about him — then his bones will be broken and nothing will remain of the poor man. I said: do you consider God to be like that? He Himself says: you are so weak that oppression upon oppression has been coming upon you, and describes the details: you were driven out of your homes and deprived of your rights — and at the same time He says: I now give you permission to fight them. Before proceeding further, He placed this sentence in between: 'Innallaha 'ala nasrihim laqadir' — the One who gives permission is powerful, so powerful that He guarantees you: fight, and We will grant you victory. Guaranteeing your help, God gives permission, not without it. I said: apply this verse. If this was jihad, at how many places did you achieve victories there? Which war did you fight such that afterwards your land expanded and Israel's shrank, (Israel) came out weakened and you emerged strong? Did you ultimately obtain anything you did not have before, and of which part have you deprived Israel? Tell me this first, then we can go further. He did not say a single word. So tell me — or say that, God forbid, God is lying. He tells you: fight them, this is jihad, and then has you beaten from the other side so that you are punished tenfold. If you say this, I will say you are lying; God does not lie. When He made a promise to the Holy Prophet (saw), it was fulfilled every time. (Gap) And they define jihad as that in which the sword is raised for the sake of God; in it there is no question of defeat; the guarantee of victory goes with it. So this is the subject in relation to Israel: if the conditions of jihad were fulfilled and they waged jihad according to its taqwa, the question of any defeat would not arise. Temporary small steps the Holy Qur’an itself describes: sometimes one withdraws as a tactic, sometimes a small setback occurs after which a great success follows. These are incidental small things, but the general direction always goes towards victory.

10 of 10 left today