7. (Question by Mian Ishtiaq(?) Sahib, not audible; apparently whether women may go to the graveyard or with the funeral procession.)

Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Question by Mian Ishtiaq(?) Sahib, not audible; apparently whether women may go to the graveyard or with the funeral procession.)

What kind of question is this? … Yes, yes, I understand. This is the same question you have already written to me, and the one I have already answered — both the question about the mosque and this one. So you are asking it again. Writing will not be accepted, verbal statement will be accepted — that is the reverse. People otherwise say about verbal things: bring it in writing! Your verbal word too is taken (thus); they say: we will not listen to verbal statements, show us something in writing; and here: we will not accept writing, say it verbally. The point is that the Holy Prophet (saw) forbade women from going along with funeral processions, but he did not forbid going to the graveyard. So keep these two matters separate. He forbade going at the time of burial so that they would not wail, and because the religion revealed to the Holy Prophet (saw) is a real religion, not a fictitious thing. He knew that this deceased person, whom they regard as dead, has a soul which for some time still keeps a link with this world; some things reach it, and if lamentation and wailing are done over him, it causes him pain — he informed about this too. Since a woman cannot control her emotions as a man can — obviously she is comparatively more sentimental — the Holy Prophet (saw) forbade it, because to expect women to control themselves when the deceased has only just been brought, and not to utter ungrateful, impatient words, is certainly a burden beyond their capacity. And secondly also so that, due to the weakness of their temperament, they do not suffer some physical ailment or become psychologically ill. When daughters, widows, sisters, or a mother watch their child being lowered into the grave before their eyes, it is such a moment that people who are comparatively weak sometimes become emotionally ill. Someone had to go for the burial; men are comparatively stronger in this matter, so God gave them permission and stopped women from it. But when these events have passed and the fresh shock is over, after that there is permission; they may certainly go. So explain it to them; tell them this is the wisdom: you are not to go with the funeral; later you may certainly go to pray.

10 of 10 left today