14. … and another narration, in which Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi (rh) is also mentioned: that in the jihad he began he was outwardly not successful. It is a strange thing: at the same time that Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi began his work of reform and renewal, Hazrat Usman dan Fodio also began reform work in the region of Nigeria and in that connection also had to take up the sword. But the strange thing is that the jihad of Usman dan Fodio, the outward jihad by the sword, was very successful, so that from the region of Sokoto, where he arose, … (rest unintelligible)
Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 August 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: … and another narration, in which Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi (rh) is also mentioned: that in the jihad he began he was outwardly not successful. It is a strange thing: at the same time that Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi began his work of reform and renewal, Hazrat Usman dan Fodio also began reform work in the region of Nigeria and in that connection also had to take up the sword. But the strange thing is that the jihad of Usman dan Fodio, the outward jihad by the sword, was very successful, so that from the region of Sokoto, where he arose, … (rest unintelligible)
… [He is] mentioned as a Mujaddid, but that does not mean that everything he did was one hundred percent correct. I have met many educated Africans who say that he extended the concept of jihad far beyond the limits of jihad and also waged aggressive wars of a political and expansionist nature which in reality have nothing to do with Islam. For [some] states … the justification which we present [for jihad] does not exist in their case. Therefore it is not right to give him so much importance as if each of his acts became Sunnah or we were bound to defend his actions. I even say that in the campaigns carried out after the era of the Companions by Muslims in the name of Islam, we must be very careful. In many places where orientalists raise objections, people start defending with closed eyes because the person was a Muslim or held the title of Caliph, thinking he must be defended. This is not right. He may have made a mistake. So you must be careful: if you defend at the wrong place, the blow will fall on Islam. Reason therefore demands saying: Islam did not err, he erred – Islam made no mistake. That is how you protect Islam. Where you defend [wrong], the accusation will be levelled at Islam; since you cannot prove his action was right, they will say: yes, you defended it in the name of Islam. Hence our position is correct that it was not Islam that erred. In the new world, where everyone has the right to criticise and we are exposed to criticism from every side, we should give no opportunity for Islam to be attacked from any side. Therefore, however high the station of Imam [Usman dan] Fodio, it is not right to declare each of his actions jihad and consider it justified. We … the criticism levelled by non-Muslims does not appear unjustified in the light of events; we see no justification …