1. People are very much interested in the question of interest. In the Holy Qur’an it is said that it is forbidden. Concerning bank money, however, some think that the interest that accrues is not actually interest, but, as some call it, profit. They also think it is a matter of trade according to the banking system. I don't have much knowledge about this, but they claim that the interest on banked money is not really interest; it is a kind of exchange, like barter. Or that when money is banked, the bank lends it on to others. So my question is: what is our view on this matter? Especially since the Promised Messiah (as) said that whatever comes from interest can be given to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat and the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat can make use of it.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: People are very much interested in the question of interest. In the Holy Qur’an it is said that it is forbidden. Concerning bank money, however, some think that the interest that accrues is not actually interest, but, as some call it, profit. They also think it is a matter of trade according to the banking system. I don't have much knowledge about this, but they claim that the interest on banked money is not really interest; it is a kind of exchange, like barter. Or that when money is banked, the bank lends it on to others. So my question is: what is our view on this matter? Especially since the Promised Messiah (as) said that whatever comes from interest can be given to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat and the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat can make use of it.

When the Holy Qur’an was being revealed it dealt with this question and recorded the objection of the non-believers that this is strange: interest is the same as trade (tijara), there is no difference, yet one is prohibited and the other permitted. The same trend of mind generates the same questions again and again. So the difference should be understood. The simplest way to differentiate between trade and interest in Islamic terms is to define both. Without definition you cannot distinguish one from the other. So how would you define usury or interest as against trade? Give me a definition that makes it distinctly different from trade. (Questioner: trade is lawful, an agreement between buyer and seller; trade is when one wants profit from what one trades.) No, no, give me a definition which makes it distinct from what you call interest, so that no confusion can remain, and by the definition one can immediately say: this applies to trade, so this is trade; this applies to interest, so this is interest. (Questioner: as far as interest in our area is concerned...) No, the definition should be universal, not only for your area. Give me a universal definition. (Questioner: when someone borrows, say, two pounds, and the lender says when you return it, it should be four pounds — that is what they consider interest. He says he is not aware of the banking system; he has been told, but is not convinced, that bank staff borrow the deposited money to trade.) We are not concerned with what the banks do. What concerns me is what depositing money with the banks is. When you speak of one contract, you should remain limited to that particular contract. If I enter into a contract with you, whatever you do with that money afterwards is not my concern at all — whether you throw it away, spend it on yourself, put it in some bank or trade with it. My contract will not be affected in the least by what you do with your money. When I lend you money there has to be some contract between us, and whether that transaction was legal or illegal, whether its conditions are permissible in Islam or not, will be decided entirely within the limits of that contract. So remain limited to the contract one enters into when depositing money in the bank, and forget what the bankers do with it. The matter has now come very close to a solution. The simplest way to answer this question is to ask the questioner to define what, according to him, interest is or should be. If he makes a defective definition he will be caught in it; it will not apply to what he considers usury. If he makes a correct definition, then the banking system falls into the classification of usury. The definition of the contract is this: if you lend money to somebody, your money is guaranteed to increase during the time the borrower possesses it, regardless of what he does with it, regardless of whether that money is actually increasing or decreasing. The lender is automatically guaranteed that his money will increase; there is no question of any loss whatsoever. And the time factor determines the rate of increase. That is the simplest and surest definition of usury as it was in vogue at the time of the Holy Prophet of Islam (saw). Some usury was of the compound-interest type, some simple interest. But when the verses of the Holy Qur’an were revealed, both types were totally banished from the Islamic financial system. Applying this definition to the contract — not a regular written one, but an understood contract — between the depositor and the bank, does it not apply? It applies, one hundred percent, so clearly. So why should you not call it usury or interest? The second part of your question was that the Promised Messiah (as) permitted some type of interest which, according to the questioner, was not the banking system. That is totally wrong. If the questioner is an Ahmadi, he should realise that the conditions of the contract between the depositor and the bank were exactly the same at the time of the Promised Messiah (as) as they are today. And he declared it a forbidden contract under the Islamic ban on usury. He left no doubt about it. In fact he advised one of his companions even to suffer loss, to leave all he had earned so far, forget about it and break that contract — a contract in which there was usury, and not only usury; it was a contract of some sort of insurance. Discussing that contract, the Promised Messiah (as) said it contains elements forbidden in Islam, one of which is usury, interest. And he said: although you will suffer a loss, even if you have to forgo all the money you have deposited so far in the name of that insurance, go ahead and get clear of it. So there is no doubt about it. Now what is trade? Trade is distinctly different from this system. In trade your money always gets something in exchange, and the other party is relieved of all responsibility after that. It gets the money, gives you a commodity in exchange, and after that the commodity is yours and the money is the other party's. How can you call it similar to interest? If the commodity gains value, that is your profit; if it loses value, that is your loss. Both possibilities remain open. So, in short, we define trade as a contract in which the possibility of your money losing value is as much there as the possibility of its gaining value. In essence this definition is derived from the fact that when I buy something, from the moment I buy it — because it is not money — when I try to exchange it for money again I will not get the same price. After a lapse of time I will get either more or less. I am not talking of depreciation; I am talking of keeping it intact. Still it will either lose or gain money. That is trade. In the contract of interest or usury it is only one-sided: your money must gain and should never lose. If it loses value, the other party suffers; for you it is always gain. So modern-day bank interest is based entirely on this definition, which is as valid today as it was at the time of the Holy Prophet (saw). (Questioner: is there not sometimes liquidation in banking?) No, the liquidation of a bank has nothing to do with your contract. It is like depositing your money with a friend and someone steals it. Even then there is a possibility of loss, but it is not in the contract; it is not understood. It is just a chance occurrence nobody can avoid. I am talking of the contract. It is the contract which makes a thing legal or illegal according to Islam. If you concentrate on the essence of the contract it is impossible to remain confused any longer; the thing becomes very clear. In the contract of depositing money with the bank, whether written or understood — that makes no difference — there is no mention of a possibility of loss, nor do you ever expect it. If the entire platform is pulled from under the feet of the bankers or from under your feet, that is a different thing. That is called calamities.

10 of 10 left today