3. The third question concerns predestination. On one hand the Holy Qur’an says that whatever befalls a person is from God. On the other hand, the subject matter of another verse is that whatever befalls you is from your own hand. How do these fit together, and what of the opinion of the opponents of Islam?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: The third question concerns predestination. On one hand the Holy Qur’an says that whatever befalls a person is from God. On the other hand, the subject matter of another verse is that whatever befalls you is from your own hand. How do these fit together, and what of the opinion of the opponents of Islam?

Where does it say that? Who is addressed? It is the Prophet (saw). So you should understand this verse in that context. The fact is that during jihad between the believers and the non-believers, sometimes the Muslims suffered and the non-believers began to jeer and mock at them, saying: look here, you are going to be destroyed, you are also suffering. In answer to that, the Holy Prophet (saw) is told by Allah: tell them that as far as we are concerned we are in safe hands. Whatever befalls us according to Allah is a trial which will be rewarded, and our destiny is made. 'Kataba' here refers to another verse in which Allah says 'Kataballahu la-aghlibanna ana wa rusuli' (Allah has decreed: I and My messengers shall surely prevail). The Holy Prophet (saw) is told that your destiny is already made and decided: you are going to come out victorious. Whatever small calamities befall you in that process are meaningless. So tell them: we know what is befalling us and it is destined even beforehand. This is why in Surah Al-Ahzab the believers, according to the Holy Qur’an, are recorded as saying that what is befalling us we knew beforehand, because Allah had told us, predicted, that this was going to happen. That is the 'kitabat' mentioned. The calamities which befall during the course of jihad, of holy war, are not only predestined in the sense that Allah knows them, but Allah also foretells them to the people. For instance, what happened in 1974 was predicted word for word by Hazrat [...], basing that prediction on some verses of the Holy Qur’an. He said such things are going to happen to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, and he described it as if he was seeing what was going to happen. That is the type of destiny mentioned in this verse. In the other verse the subject matter is that whatever befalls you is from your own hand. This is why I explained this verse. In the light of this explanation it does not stand in contradiction anymore. As for the opponents of Islam, I have already explained: when the first verse you quoted is explained as I did, no sane opponent can call it contradictory to the other words you quoted, meaning that Allah wants good to happen to you. In fact it is a limited translation which creates all this confusion. The second verse you quoted should be taken on its merit alone, and once you understand its import, no question or contradiction would ever arise in your mind with that verse or any other. That verse describes a general phenomenon, a plan of things in Allah's creation. That plan is that if you follow the laws of Allah completely and perfectly — they are so perfect, there is no contradiction whatsoever in them — there are no dangers from any side; you live a perfect, well-oiled and well-lubricated life, there is no friction, nothing wrong would happen to you. But because life as such — whether animal life prior to man's stage or man's life — life in general cannot perfectly attune itself to the laws of nature, you begin to see contradictions, and disease and accidents and such things happen. So Allah tells us that whatever befalls you by way of calamities is your own doing; it is not as Allah would desire it. Allah desires good for you. So whatever good comes to you is Allah's doing. Despite your 'best efforts' you do receive some good. If it were left to you, you would always suffer. If you were left to do things of your own choice, you would be completely deprived of goodness; then the whole world would become wicked and evil. Because in some things you simply can't help changing things, the benefit of goodness flows from Allah to you. For instance there are laws of nature you can't change, you can't interfere with — the time of sowing wheat and the time of reaping the harvest and so on and so forth. There are general laws of nature which you can't change. So when the seed is thrown, even if you do not care, even if you commit mistakes, still the laws of nature are so perfect that you do get some reward. The rain comes without your effort; the water is carried from the seas to the mountains through a system in which you have nothing to do. All your follies cannot stand in the way of these mountains and monsoons or other winds laden with moisture. All this is going on in nature for your benefit. This is a very small example of what is happening quietly without anyone ever noticing it. That is the general import of this verse: the things that keep the balance are kept out of your reach; you can't interfere. But when things are left to you, you destroy things: you break the laws, distort the laws, change the laws selfishly to your advantage and to the disadvantage of other human beings, and so the trouble starts. So if you pursue the source of troubles, it will always be determined to lie with you, not with God or with the laws of nature.

10 of 10 left today