6. The question is: the Prophetic Hadith were compiled a long time after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw) and the rightly guided Khulafa (ra). What certainty do we have regarding the Sihah Sitta that they are truly authentic? We do believe in them, but...

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: The question is: the Prophetic Hadith were compiled a long time after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw) and the rightly guided Khulafa (ra). What certainty do we have regarding the Sihah Sitta that they are truly authentic? We do believe in them, but...

Tell me: was the entire history of the world written down in its own time? No. And some histories were recorded only after thousands of years and were not recorded as history before that. So have they no value? (Reply: they do have.) The question is: if in a nation a chain of oral narration has continued for centuries and its history has also been preserved that way, then when those narrations are recorded, should they not be relied upon? Among the Arabs this oral record had continued for centuries, indeed thousands of years, and they relied on it. The Arabs were so firm in their memory and had acquired such practice generation after generation that some Arab poets claimed to recite a hundred thousand verses from memory, and said: hear them backward and hear them forward. And some minds were so trained that once, when someone recited a long poem, a child said, I'll recite it to you now, and recited it starting from the other end. There are also accounts that in the time of the Abbasid Caliphs such [people] proved that their memory was like that. So firstly we have to look at the history of the Arab nation and its narrators. And if Arab history has any authority, any reality, then the Hadith narrations must have greater authority and greater reality. Why? Because before the Islamic society the Arabs did not lay so much stress on truthfulness; they were also debauched, worldly, also liars and deceivers, and there was no moral system there at all. If the word of the Arab of that time is reliable, why is the word of that Arab not reliable whom the Holy Prophet (saw) passed through a moral workshop, indeed polished, and among whom the standard of truthfulness and of testimony became so high that if it became known about someone that, sitting in public, facing the wall, towards the people — facing the wall, as happens in our country — he had urinated, the Hadith scholars said of him that he lacks modesty, so his narration is not reliable. If someone said the matter was thus but did not state the chain in between by which it reached him, he was not considered reliable. If someone had the habit of speaking in a veiled way, he too was counted among those accused of tadlis. So the standard of testimony was raised so high that no room for doubt remains after that. And when the Hadith were preserved with this high standard of testimony, another remarkable thing happened: some things were not in writing at that time and were not known to the people compiling the Hadith, for instance certain letters to kings. When the Hadith had been preserved and those letters were later discovered, the wording was exactly the same as had been narrated. Through this means and others too, if anything can be deemed reliable, then the Ahadith are the most reliable thing in the world concerning the past. And if the Orientalists attack the Ahadith, then all the divine scriptures of the world slip from their hands. Because for all the sacred scriptures in the world, their written recording took place long after the time they are believed to have been revealed, and there those conditions did not exist which the Muslim Hadith scholars laid down for narrations and narrators, and the chain there is not preserved like this. So the New Testament will slip out of hand, the Old Testament will slip out of hand, and all the other sacred scriptures will retain no authority at all. The standard of preservation of Hadith is stricter than that of every other divine scripture. Therefore before the Holy Qur’an stands the Hadith first. And this too is one of the promises of the preservation of the Holy Qur’an being fulfilled in this form: they cannot reach the Holy Qur’an until they attack the Hadith, and they cannot attack the Hadith until they first abandon their own books, abolish these principles, eliminate their own books — only then can they attack the Hadith. So the Holy Qur’an, by the grace of God, is enclosed in very secure fortresses; its turn comes later.

10 of 10 left today