8. Huzur, according to a Hadith — probably in Tirmidhi, Kitab ad-Da'awat, Bab Jami' ad-Da'awat — ninety-nine attributes of Allah the Exalted are mentioned. And among Muslims, especially in my country, it has become well known that the attributes or names of Allah are ninety-nine. But according to 'Wa lillahil-asma’ul-husna' it appears that if one begins to count the beautiful names, they go far beyond ninety-nine. Furthermore, it has also been spread among Muslims that the attributes of the Holy Prophet (saw) are ninety-nine as well. This is well known in my country. I request Huzur to give some explanation.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Huzur, according to a Hadith — probably in Tirmidhi, Kitab ad-Da'awat, Bab Jami' ad-Da'awat — ninety-nine attributes of Allah the Exalted are mentioned. And among Muslims, especially in my country, it has become well known that the attributes or names of Allah are ninety-nine. But according to 'Wa lillahil-asma’ul-husna' it appears that if one begins to count the beautiful names, they go far beyond ninety-nine. Furthermore, it has also been spread among Muslims that the attributes of the Holy Prophet (saw) are ninety-nine as well. This is well known in my country. I request Huzur to give some explanation.

The point is that on this issue there has already been sectarian division among Muslims before. Some sects came into being separately on this basis, saying that the attributes of God are unlimited, and some conservative sects opposed them very vehemently, contradicted them and even declared them non-Muslims, saying that God's attributes cannot go beyond ninety-nine; only ninety-nine are established from Hadith. The fact is that if God is unlimited, His attributes too must be unlimited. Knowledge of them can be limited. Therefore the attributes revealed to the Holy Prophet (saw), told by God, were revealed not because God described all His attributes, but because in man there existed the possibility of connection with at most so many attributes of God, and all those attributes were made manifest to the Holy Prophet (saw). There is a hemistich of Ghalib: 'They give according to the capacity of the cup.' God manifests Himself in His servant to the extent the servant has the strength to receive that manifestation. When God designed man and he reached his perfection in the person of the Holy Prophet (saw), then God, to the extent He could be reflected in this man, was entirely reflected. But to say that God was only this much and not more is wrong. Therefore you can take the position that we have no knowledge of more attributes than those given to the Holy Prophet (saw), because the Holy Prophet (saw) is that perfect Adam and perfect Khalifa upon whom the names were revealed. Therefore if anyone claims to have more knowledge of the divine names than the Holy Prophet (saw), he is a liar in his claim. But if he claims that the possibility exists that there are more names, but beyond the limit of our human capacity, that claim is not wrong. Understood? If you tell someone who believes in 99 attributes that there are other attributes besides the 99, you will have to tell him which attributes they are. Which ones will you name? He will say: then produce them. Those who held that there are more attributes began the device of taking the actions of Allah mentioned by the Holy Qur’an — God does this, does that, does this, for instance sends down wrath — and saying that 'the Wrathful' would be an attribute; God does such-and-such a thing... There are many such things which are not attributes of God; in the manifestation of certain attributes of God certain decisions are issued, they are commands. These people turned all of them into attributes and made a long list. That was in reality merely a mockery of the divine attributes, because everything the Holy Qur’an has stated about God is subordinate to the attributes mentioned in the Holy Qur’an. And the subject of attributes is such that if you reflect further you will discover another astonishing thing: the ninety-nine attributes themselves contain unlimited possibilities, because under attributes there are further attributes, and from the combination of attributes further attributes are formed. If you want to understand this subject scientifically, then look at how many colours you see in the world...

10 of 10 left today