10. Assalamu alaikum. A question about the appearance of the Imam Mahdi (as), a Hadith I would like to know about. The Hadith is: 'Man kadhdhaba bil-Mahdi faqad kafara' (Whoever belies the Mahdi has committed disbelief). It concerns the kafir; what does it mean? (Hazrat (rh): Where did you take this Hadith from? Tell me that first.) Our missionary in Indonesia wrote a book called 'Glad Tidings'. (Hazrat (rh): No, that is not a book of Hadith. Tell me first the reference he gave.) Al-Burhan fi Alamat al-Mahdi Akhir az-Zaman. … In Al-Fatawa al-Hadithiyya, and its chain of narrators is also connected (muttasil).

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Assalamu alaikum. A question about the appearance of the Imam Mahdi (as), a Hadith I would like to know about. The Hadith is: 'Man kadhdhaba bil-Mahdi faqad kafara' (Whoever belies the Mahdi has committed disbelief). It concerns the kafir; what does it mean? (Hazrat (rh): Where did you take this Hadith from? Tell me that first.) Our missionary in Indonesia wrote a book called 'Glad Tidings'. (Hazrat (rh): No, that is not a book of Hadith. Tell me first the reference he gave.) Al-Burhan fi Alamat al-Mahdi Akhir az-Zaman. … In Al-Fatawa al-Hadithiyya, and its chain of narrators is also connected (muttasil).

This needs to be investigated. This Hadith has not been presented in our earlier recognised books. It seems that it has some weakness. Do you know what the status of this Hadith is, what its strength is? You have heard it for the first time. Check this. There are countless such Hadiths about which, after investigation, you will say they were not recognised, that there is doubt about their authenticity and other issues come in. Therefore it is necessary to find out about this Hadith what its status is according to the scholars: whether it is sahih or not sahih, whether it is weak, whether it is ahad or mutawatir, whatever form it has, whether muttasil or not muttasil. Define it from this point of view, and above all in which century it first emerged. This is a very important part which some scholars overlook. Mirza (?) Shams Sahib once presented a Hadith in a Dars, and from its content I felt it was not correct. I looked into it and found that this Hadith first surfaced after six hundred years, and it came out in Spain. When Hadiths had begun to become doubtful and narrations had become mixed – to wait four hundred years after that period for a Hadith and then for it to surface is highly suspicious. Therefore one must also see when the Hadith first came to public view. If it first comes to light near the time of the Holy Prophet (saw), then other apparent weaknesses can be overlooked; such a Hadith one will then not be able to set aside. In contrast, there are the Hadiths found in our [literature], which the Promised Messiah (as) also quoted and which other scholars use, about the Imam Mahdi: when you find the time of the Imam Mahdi – there are two narrations: one is that even if you have to go on your knees over slabs of ice, go and convey my salaam to him; the other version is: [take] his Bai'at. So when the Holy Prophet (saw) commands the Bai'at, the one who does not take the Bai'at becomes an opponent of the Holy Prophet (saw) and is left without an Imam. Call him kafir, call him fasiq, whatever you call him – that Hadith is sufficient. This Hadith [you mentioned] deserves investigation; I cannot say anything definite about it right now.

10 of 10 left today