11. Assalamu alaikum. With the blessed persons of Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya we witness the acceptance of prayer in hundreds of thousands [of instances]. But in contrast people say, we made such-and-such offering at such-and-such grave and our wish was fulfilled. And Shias and Barelwis, Hanafis, relate even more miracles. Hazrat, what is the difference?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Assalamu alaikum. With the blessed persons of Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya we witness the acceptance of prayer in hundreds of thousands [of instances]. But in contrast people say, we made such-and-such offering at such-and-such grave and our wish was fulfilled. And Shias and Barelwis, Hanafis, relate even more miracles. Hazrat, what is the difference?

Investigate it. Those to whom you present your claim have the right to investigate you, and you have the right to investigate them. Once there was an Ahmadi friend of ours from Sindh who at one time was very notorious there – a robber, a thief, all the 'five vices of the Shari'ah' were present in him. He was not an Ahmadi at that time, and he was so well known in the area that a particular name is given to such a person: all five basic vices forbidden by the Shari'ah are present in him, the five signs of sin and debauchery. It is said of such a person that if he goes into a mosque his eyes begin to ache; therefore such a vice-ridden person does not even go to the mosque. When this gentleman became an Ahmadi, someone asked him whether this was true. He said: for me it was true; when I went to the mosque my eyes started to ache. When he became an Ahmadi, by the grace of Allah a great visible change came about in him; from the state of a thief he came close to being a saint (?), in every respect. [He related:] Outside people were sitting talking with the Khalifa (deputy) of a Pir; all were inside. I went in and preached Ahmadiyyat. [They asked:] Does Mirza Sahib have any miracle? Did Mirza Sahib ever bring a dead person to life? I said no, he never did that. [Then I asked:] Does your Pir bring the dead to life? They said yes. [I said:] If your great Pir brings the dead to life, then what have you to worry about. I sat down and the talk went on. After that, when the Khalifa was there making such claims, I asked him, playing innocent: your mother has passed away? Good, then one day your Pir will bring your mother out of the grave? … [Here the recording is rendered in the wrong script and is mostly unintelligible; a verse about miracles is recited, roughly: mere talk, without anyone of ours having attested it in writing.] The opponent whom one wants to convince by a miracle – someone from his side should also have attested it; what will mere talk achieve? As for the miracles of the Founder (as), an opponent of his time, a fierce opponent, was compelled to admit that the matter is true. [English, unintelligible passage concerning a Shaikh Abdul Haq (?).] This movement became popular; one reason was its Founder's claim: I can show miracles, I have a connection with God. And the things that became well known, about which research says they actually happened, influenced the Punjab; among them this incident too was related, and some other things were written. So the miracle is acknowledged even by an opponent, not that murids are talking about their Pir. It is well known: 'Piran nami-parand, muridan mi-parananand' (Pirs do not fly, their disciples make them fly).

10 of 10 left today