3. (Continuation) From the Ahadith, such as 'Had a prophet been raised after me, it would have been you, O Umar' and 'La nabiyya ba'di', it appears that every kind of prophethood has ended.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 31 August 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Continuation) From the Ahadith, such as 'Had a prophet been raised after me, it would have been you, O Umar' and 'La nabiyya ba'di', it appears that every kind of prophethood has ended.
Now we come to the Ahadith. You cited one hadith; there is another. He said: had a prophet been destined to be raised, 'la-bu'ithta ya 'Umar' — O Umar, you would have been raised, if any prophet were to be raised after me. Fine. Let us settle one thing before going further: righteousness demands that one accept everything the Holy Prophet (saw) said on this subject — not accept half and leave half. Then the issue will be solved. If you hold on to half the Ahadith and I hold on to the other half, the issue can never be solved. Therefore I accept this one too.
I draw your attention to another hadith: he appointed Hazrat Ali (ra) as Imam, as Amir, after him when he set out northward for a campaign, and said, addressing Hazrat Ali: Ali is to me in the position of Aaron; just as Aaron was after Moses, so he must be obeyed — except that 'la nabiyya ba'di', there is no prophet after me. He said this too. You have mentioned the 'after' Ahadith, and there are many more. Now hear the Ahadith about the one to come too. In a hadith of Muslim he said that the Messiah will descend and he will be Nabiyyullah (Prophet of Allah) — the coming Messiah; and in a single hadith he called him Nabiyyullah four times. In another hadith, at the death of Hazrat Ibrahim (as), his son, he said … And this death occurred after the revelation of the Khatam-un-Nabiyyin verse; all scholars agree on this. I say Hazrat Ibrahim (as) because in one hadith it was also said that he was a prophet; that is why for his son Hazrat Ibrahim 'alaihis salam' comes automatically from my lips. He was born in 5 or … AH, and at the beginning of 9, probably, he was about four years old when he passed away. The Khatam-un-Nabiyyin verse was revealed in year 5, a little later, (at the time of) the Ahzab; it is in Surah Al-Ahzab, from the time of the Ahzab. In any case it is before the death; that is certain. Right?
Listen: when he was lowering Hazrat Ibrahim (as) into the grave — perhaps I should not say 'alaihis salam', 'Hazrat Ibrahim' might otherwise cause confusion — Hazrat Ibrahim, whatever his station with God: when he was being laid in the grave, according to a hadith he said: 'Lau 'asha la-kana siddiqan nabiyyan' — had he lived, he would surely have become a truthful, pure prophet of God. Two Ahadith have come together on the side of negation, and two Ahadith on the side of this (affirmation). And contradiction is impossible in the words of Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Therefore we must necessarily reconcile these Ahadith, i.e., present a meaning that creates no contradiction but brings harmony between both. Only that can be acceptable; no other meaning is acceptable.
Earlier scholars also reflected on this issue and in this connection also considered another hadith, the hadith of Hazrat Aishah Siddiqah (ra): when she heard someone saying 'la nabiyya ba'dahu', she called him, warned him and said: do not say 'la nabiyya ba'dahu', 'wa lakin qulu: innahu khatam-an-nabiyyin' — say this; it will cause no misunderstanding; do not say 'la nabiyya ba'dahu'. Now what was the reason? There was a clash between them: 'la nabiyya ba'dahu' has a meaning that clashes with the meaning of the Khatam-un-Nabiyyin verse. That is why she forbade it, so that no misunderstanding should arise. Hazrat Mulla Ali Qari discussed this, as did some other scholars. They concluded that there is no clash between the Ahadith, nor between the Khatam-un-Nabiyyin verse and the 'la nabiyya ba'di' hadith. The reason is that the Holy Prophet (saw) meant that after him no law-bearing prophet (Sahib-e-Shariat) can arise, and here 'ba'di' means 'contrary to me', not 'after me' in terms of time. This meaning Mulla Ali Qari has already given, against whom today's scholars dare not issue a fatwa. He says this meaning must necessarily be accepted, and as proof he cites that 'ba'd' has been used in exactly this sense in a verse of the Holy Qur’an. He said: … 'In what discourse then, after Allah and His Signs, will they believe?' — after God and His Signs. Is there an 'after' of God? What is meant is that the Arabs also took 'ba'd' in the sense of 'contrary'. So the meaning is that the Holy Prophet (saw) says: I am the last prophet in terms of Shariah; after my law, i.e., the law of Shariah, no one can arise to whom a verse is revealed that abrogates any part of my Shariah. No one can come who cancels my Sunnah and annuls my word. 'Ba'd' in any sense means: no one will ever arise contrary to me. If prophets in conformity with me arise, there is no harm. They say: that is why he also said 'Lau 'asha la-kana siddiqan nabiyyan', that this son of mine would have become so obedient — God told me, as it were — that had he lived he would surely have become a prophet. This is not contrary to those Ahadith.
In what he said to Hazrat Umar (ra) and to Hazrat Ali there is clear wisdom. There is another aspect worth considering: in the immediate time after the Holy Prophet (saw), or in the foreseeable future, the coming of anyone was not destined. For the Holy Prophet gave this explanation in the Bukhari hadith: 'Lau kana-l-imanu 'inda-th-thurayya'. This too shows that the one who is to come in his servitude will come later. And there could have been the danger that the Companions would think that, since Umar had been praised so much, he would later set himself up as a prophet, or that Hazrat Ali, whom he had left behind, would afterwards set himself up as a prophet. So that statement is time-bound. And some statements are time-bound, i.e., they apply up to a certain time and not to another.
This is further explained by another hadith which has the status of the final word on this subject. On one hand he said: there is no prophet after me; on the other he says: the Messiah will be a prophet. How then can the contradiction between the two be removed? He himself has removed the contradiction. The time of 'after' can be limited or unlimited; what he meant, he knows best. On one occasion he says: 'Laisa baini wa bainahu nabiyy' — there is no prophet between me and him. When I say there is no prophet after me, it means there is no prophet until the coming of the Messiah. Whoever claims in between will be a liar. But whoever claims to be the Messiah must be a prophet, because for him he himself uses the word prophet four times. Because his being a prophet is not contrary to the Ummah of the Holy Prophet (saw).
Therefore today's scholars, on reaching this point, fall into great perplexity and make strange attempts to wriggle out of their position. When Ahmadis ask them: you said 'la nabiyya ba'di', and 'la' is a negation of the genus (Nafi-e-Jins) — this is a grammatical term, meaning that no one of any kind whatsoever can come — then it also means that neither one of the old kind nor of the new kind can come. And in the next breath you bring in the Messiah, who was an old prophet — then the negation of the genus is broken. Here they raise questions. To this some scholars have answered — it is printed in their books — that the real point is that when Jesus (as) comes he will become an Ummati, will not run his own Shariah, but standing on the Shariah of Muhammad will enforce that very one; therefore there is no harm. We say: that is exactly what we say too. The only dispute is whether an old one comes and becomes an Ummati, or an Ummati becomes a prophet. In terms of the actual substance no difference remains at all; i.e., our disagreement on this point ends forever.
And they are compelled to say this because they face two obstacles in taking away Hazrat Jesus's prophethood. First, there are categorical fatwas of the scholars that whoever believes in prophethood being taken away from anyone has become a disbeliever. Because God does not take back a gift after giving it. Understood? The gift of prophethood is not acquired; it is bestowed (wahbi). When it is bestowed, how can Allah the Exalted take it back after bestowing it? He tells others: if you give a gift and take it back, you are like one who licks up his vomit. So God Himself cannot take it back. That is why prophethood has never been taken from anyone to this day, because it is not acquired; it is a gift from Allah. Second, they are compelled because the Holy Prophet (saw) clearly stated regarding Jesus (as): when the Messiah descends in the future, he will be a prophet. Now if the one to whom the Khatam-un-Nabiyyin verse was revealed, a prophet of such stature, himself says that he will be a prophet, what standing does a Maulvi have to snatch prophethood from him? They are compelled. For this they look for the excuse that because he will become an Ummati and a one-hundred-percent servant of Muhammad Mustafa (saw), there is no harm. We say: that is exactly what we say too.
Let me try to explain it to you from yet another angle, because I sense that you are asking me very honestly. Very rarely do I meet other questioners who keep talking like this without obstinacy, and who understand the true point … Allah's great grace is upon you. Therefore I am confident that if you have understood these things, you will accept them, God willing.