2. I turn to the common impression that after prophethood Khilafat continued and, as ordinary people have been told, after that Imam Mahdi will come, who will be Imam; there will be Imamat, but Khilafat does not apply alongside it. It is usually assumed that in his lifetime, as is said about the Imam, he will finish all his work, complete Islam and then depart from this world.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 November 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: I turn to the common impression that after prophethood Khilafat continued and, as ordinary people have been told, after that Imam Mahdi will come, who will be Imam; there will be Imamat, but Khilafat does not apply alongside it. It is usually assumed that in his lifetime, as is said about the Imam, he will finish all his work, complete Islam and then depart from this world.

Look at this even superficially: does this idea accord with your nature, or does this event fit into the history of religion you have read, that someone comes, completes such a magnificent work entirely in his lifetime and departs, and thereafter nobody even remains to run the system? Do you know how large the world’s population is? (Interjection: But that contains the concept of the Day of Judgement.) No, I am coming to that. Consider how large the world’s population is at present, what proportion Muslims are of it, and what quality the Muslims themselves currently have. Are they ready that, if an Imam comes from God, all of them immediately accept him? Whereas the Shia–Sunni differences are so great that the Shia concept of the Imam is far removed from the Sunni concept. And if Imam Mahdi appears, the hidden Imam of the Shias will not vanish in any case; if the Imam comes among the Sunnis, he is in any case not the hidden Imam of the Shias. So will they immediately accept him? Would all the Muslim world accept him? And would a sudden transformation take place in their character, the quality of their thinking, their honesty and everything — would they suddenly be reformed to the best, excellent qualities? Can it happen? Has it happened ever before? And consider: there is no conception of purifying spiritual power (Quwwat-e-Qudsiyya) greater than that of the Holy Prophet (saw). (Interjection: No, impossible.) And if Imam Mahdi were granted greater purifying power than the Holy Prophet (saw), that in my view is a satanic notion with no reality at all. The mention of purifying power in the Holy Qur’an in connection with the person of the Prophet (saw) does not occur in this way about any other prophet. Keep in view what his purifying power achieved, and every notion that claims more than that achievement should be considered false; it is a lie. The prophetic life in Mecca and Medina together was twenty-three years, and in the verses of the Holy Qur’an revealed at the end of those twenty-three years, the hypocrites are mentioned, the evil-doers are mentioned, it is mentioned that there were spreaders of false news — all of this existed. So even the one land of Arabia could not become [fully] Islamic in a few years. And the bloodshed you mentioned itself shows that, whether it was the Banu Saqifa or other people, Islam had gone only skin-deep into them, and when the Holy Prophet (saw) passed away, rebellion began. And you tell me that one Imam will come and after him nobody will be needed? This is absurd, unbelievable. Number one: the Holy Prophet (saw) himself speaks against it. He says that when this latter age comes and the condition of the Ummah has deteriorated, then the Messiah will descend: ‘Thumma takunu khilafatun ‘ala minhaj-in-nubuwwah’ — then Khilafat will be established on the precept of prophethood. That is the news given by the Holy Prophet (saw), and the mullahs think the Hour (Qiyamat) comes. If Qiyamat comes, how will Khilafat on the precept of prophethood be established? Qiyamat will come upon those people who are the most wicked since the world was created. This is something they do not tell you in this connection, which is why you never noticed this contradiction. Ask them independently whether the Holy Prophet (saw) gave this news or not: Qiyamat will come when mankind has become the worst. Then the summary of Imam Mahdi’s forty-year life would be that he produces and leaves behind the most wicked of people. What use is such an Imam? Qiyamat is not to come upon good people at all; this is accepted by all the mullahs. Probe it if you like, ask one, ask ten; if you do not ask in this connection, he will answer you without hesitation: yes, that is correct. Then probe what becomes of your Imam Mahdi. No person of common sense can entertain this at all. Further, it clearly clashes with other Ahadith. On one occasion the Holy Prophet (saw) said that when the Messiah descends, there will be two very great nations in the world possessing power. He will intend to fight them. Allah will say: I have brought forth such nations in the world, caused their emergence, such that nobody can overcome them by material power; therefore give up the idea of material Jihad — these are the words of the Hadith, Allah will reveal it — and withdraw towards the mountain and pray. And through prayer God will destroy these nations. After that the Holy Prophet (saw) says: then the Messiah will prevail. Then a long period will come in which cool breezes and breezes of peace will blow, after his victory. Then gradually the direction of the winds will change, then filth will begin, until that filth again overwhelms the whole world. Then, when people have become the most wicked, when goodness has departed from them, then Qiyamat will come. How can you remove the contradiction between these two Ahadith? There is no option except to accept one and derive some general meaning from the other, or consider that its narration is not correct. In the case of a contradiction one must necessarily adopt this, because this second Hadith is far more reasonable; it has internal logic, and ever since the world was made, this is what always happens in religion: gradually victory comes, then gradually they deteriorate, and God’s punishment always comes upon bad people, not upon good people. In light of all these factors, the idea that the Mahdi came and then Qiyamat came is an utterly meaningless belief. (Interjection: But then what happens? In all the literature, in any sect — there are countless sects in Pakistan — the same idea is repeated in all of them: when the Imam comes his age will be about forty, not beyond forty, and then Qiyamat will come immediately.) I will explain the reason to you right now; it is very simple. First, all this literature is not positive but negative. Their eye is on Ahmadiyyat, and by repeating these things again and again they want to turn Muslims against it: that this Mahdi is false, because the Mahdi should have this characteristic which is not found in him; more than ninety years have now passed since his passing, and still Qiyamat has not come; therefore it is completely false — had he been the true Mahdi he would have completed the work in forty years, made the whole world Muslim, then the purpose would have been fulfilled and the world would have ended. If this belief is hammered into people’s minds again and again, they will not even be ready to consider Ahmadiyyat. So there is a logic in it; in their own way they have adopted a rather clever method of opposing us. The second point to note is: if this is their conception of Imam Mahdi, that he comes for a few years, changes people and then ends, then they should also present the other concomitant conceptions about Imam Mahdi. For instance, on the subject of Imam Mahdi it is said that the scholars of the time will oppose him, and that he will appear when the verdict of the Holy Prophet (saw) about the scholars is: ‘Sharrun man taht adim as-sama’ — beneath the sky the scholars of the Muslims of that age will be the worst of creation. These are not my words; they are the words of the Holy Prophet (saw). These scholars conceal them. If they have righteousness, they should present all the sayings of the Holy Prophet (saw). They present what suits them and put their hand over what does not — this is not permissible. If they present to you the complete picture of the Mahdi, every reasonable person will then draw his own conclusions. First: an Imam Mahdi who is to be treated such that all the scholars of the time become his opponents — when you now ask these scholars about his truthfulness, will they bear witness in his favour? Strange! The Holy Prophet (saw) says the Imam will appear when not only the people but their leaders too have become corrupt. And this is entirely reasonable: God takes the leadership into His own hand when the leadership of the world has failed. This is logical, understandable. And at that time these very scholars whom you are now asking — if Hadhrat Mirza Sahib (as) is not truthful, the scholars at the time of a future Imam Mahdi will be the same, won’t they? When a simple person goes and asks them: you are a scholar, tell me — will he support the Imam Mahdi? He will deny him. That is exactly what they are doing. There is no other option. As for the explanation of why, where they got the basis from: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that when the Messiah descends, he and the Hour will be joined like this — he showed two fingers joined together. And a Hadith about the Mahdi: when he comes, the Hour will come after him. From these two Ahadith they derived the meaning that Imam Mahdi and the Messiah are contemporaries and as soon as their lives pass, the world will suddenly be destroyed. But the word Qiyamat is not there at all; the word ‘Sa’ah’ is used. And about himself the Holy Prophet (saw) used exactly the same idiom. He said: ‘Ana was-sa’atu kahatain’ — I and the Hour — they translate Sa’ah in Urdu as Qiyamat — I and Qiyamat are like these two fingers joined together. Whatever meaning applies there must apply here. Fourteen hundred years have passed since this statement that I and Qiyamat are joined like this — has Qiyamat come? I will explain: Qiyamat signifies a spiritual revolution. Prophets do not come for worldly kingdoms; prophets come for spiritual revolution. Accordingly this saying of the Holy Prophet (saw), that I and the Hour are joined, is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an: ‘Iqtarabatis-sa’atu wanshaqqal-qamar’ — see, the moon has split into two; this is the proof of that time that the Hour has drawn very near. Now how near has it come? If one takes Qiyamat according to the mullahs’ conception, more than fourteen hundred years have passed and it has not yet come — a fine nearness! And if nearness is like this, why do you change the meaning of ‘near’ after the Imam Mahdi? His nearness too should then last at least fourteen hundred years. Therefore Sa’ah means something else. If Sa’ah is viewed in the spiritual world, the raising of the dead is used in a spiritual sense, and the announcement of the death of a nation is used in a spiritual sense. Qiyamat has two aspects: on one hand it announces death, and on the other it also announces new life. On one side mourning is going on, on the other side new life is being granted. So the Holy Qur’an mentioned both these Qiyamats with regard to the Holy Prophet (saw), both aspects of Qiyamat. On one hand it said: ‘Zahara al-fasadu fil-barri wal-bahr’ — the whole world has fallen prey to corruption, nothing remains, nothing righteous is left; it is complete spiritual death. On the other hand it said: ‘Yad’ukum lima yuhyikum’ — Muhammad Mustafa (saw) is calling you so that he may give you life again. This is the complete picture of Qiyamat: on one hand the announcement of a general death, on the other a message of life, of new life. So the Holy Prophet’s (saw) saying about himself that the Hour is joined with me, and the Holy Qur’an’s announcing this, strengthens this Hadith, that it is not a false Hadith; Qiyamat was indeed to come. And the non-arrival of an outward Qiyamat is the greatest proof that the mullah is misunderstanding it. What is meant by Qiyamat is a spiritual Qiyamat: when a nation reaches the verge of death, falls prey to worldly ailments, the message of new life it receives is called Qiyamat; this is called the trumpet of Israfil. The possibility of a new life arises, then the dead begin to stir, gradually they receive new messages of life, then their spreading in the world begins. Hashr and Nashr — these two words occur together in religious idiom: Hashr means gathering and Nushur means spreading out. First the world gathers around one voice, then after that its spreading begins, they convey the message to the rest of the world. This is the picture of prophethood. Qiyamat is in reality the picture of prophethood: calling in the name of God, then training them and spreading them out into the world: go and give the world the message. This is how we understand it. And as I said, the arguments in my view are so weighty, from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith and in accordance with reason, that there is agreement among these three. The conception that you have been taught is self-contradictory and against reason. Tell me: if virtues could enter people’s hearts so quickly, why did it never happen before? Why did God need to make the Holy Prophet (saw) go through Badr, through Uhud, endure suffering at Ta’if, and his followers be dragged through the streets? If the Imam Mahdi prescription were to work or could ever work, then his purifying power should have been thousands of times greater than Imam Mahdi’s. He should have, with the very breath with which Imam Mahdi is to make the Arabs Muslims, righteous, within a few years, made the Arabs so. Therefore such a clear contradiction between the personality of the Holy Prophet (saw) and the conception of Imam Mahdi is not acceptable. There is only one prescription for reform; if you do not understand this you will remain in a misconception and the reform of Muslims will never happen. It is: sacrificing for the sake of truth. Until nations use this prescription, they can never come alive. Even in politics we did not use it. There, the Congress made sacrifices for a long period, and they learned how to govern. We got Pakistan ready-made on a silver plate; we began eating it, even sold the silver and ate it. It is such a simple matter, as clear as two and two make four: the Holy Qur’an has [shown] this prescription used from Adam up to the Holy Prophet (saw), that He sets one on the path of sacrifice; by enduring beatings, having homes burnt, and one’s own blood flowing in the streets, then one attains virtue. It does not come cheap. Otherwise, how can nations change? Not even one city of Pakistan can change. Take any city and tell all the scholars of Pakistan to jointly instil virtue into it — nobody will pay heed. They will knock on their doors, and they will come out to beat them: enough, the prayers that were to be said have been said, that is sufficient. Call them towards mischief, then see how they run to set fires; they will be ready at once. This is the nature of man: he comes quickly towards evil and with difficulty towards good. This is no trick; it is against nature, against the law of nature, against the history of religion, that one man comes and makes everyone righteous.

10 of 10 left today