1. How should one convince someone that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) is the same Imam Mahdi and Promised Messiah (as) as prophecied by Muhammad (saw)?

Question-and-answer session, 19 December 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What is the best method to explain before non-Ahmadis that Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani (as) is the same Imam Mahdi and Promised Messiah who was prophesied by Hazrat Muhammad (saw)?

Well, the best method would be first to find out the expectations of the person you are addressing, because you must speak the same language and you must stand on the same platform, otherwise no meaningful dialogue can be held at all.

So instead of giving you one answer which should work as a sort of panacea for everybody, I tell you the principal approach that you should adopt.

You know, each man has his own concept about the coming of the promised one, be he the Messiah or be he the Mahdi. So because, in fact, the whole Muslim world has not one uniform, standard concept. The concepts vary from sect to sect and, because of ignorance of the people about their own religion, also from person to person. Some people have heard a part of a tradition, some another part of a tradition, some have heard a full tradition, and so on and so forth. So generally when they ask questions, they are themselves confused and they are not sure.

So I don't know what sort of person as he is going to address. It all depends on his own first expectations, how he expects the promised one to be judged.

He is to be satisfied, so we can only satisfy him either first by finding out from him what are his expectations and try try to and trying to satisfy him on his own ground, or alternatively we can find fault with his expectations and analyze the case before him and tell him that these expectations are just imaginary, they have no foundation, no roots, and if you are expecting someone to come as you expect, then nobody would ever come—that sort of approach.

Or later on, then you can prepare the ground for a discussion on fundamentals, which is the most important thing in such discussions. Forget about the Mahdi, forget about the title of Messiah, etc. Just first find out from the Holy Qur’an; and then that is where you should ultimately bring such a person to. You must bring it to your own ground, that is the ground of the Holy Qur’an.

So you should gradually try to convince him that whoever it is, if he is from God, he must have some common, similar proofs, if not exactly the same type. And the holy book being a perfect and a complete book, it must give us a guideline as to how we should judge a person who claims to be from God.

That is the most positive way of determining the truth of a claimant.

If you leave that alone and start addressing the problem from the hearsay angle, of "we have heard that the imam would be like this" and "we have heard that the imam would be like that", then the matter will never be resolved.

Because the expectations are so different and the authorities to which they are related are in most cases so unreliable and there is so much internal contradiction in the prophecies—not the prophecies, but the prophecies as related to us, as they have reached us—that it is impossible to decide the issue. For instance, the Shia expectations of the Imam Mahdi are completely different from the Sunni expectations in general. And the Sunnis' expectations then begin to differ within and the Shia expectations also begin to differ within them.

The concept of the Imam Mahdi as held by the Barelvi sect for instance among the Sunnis is very different from the concept as held by the Wahhabis. The concept of Imam Mahdi there is completely without, you know, fantastic miracles and things. They just go and stress the names, the name of the father, the name of the parents and this and that. His the mother would be Amna, the father would be Muhammad, called Muhammad, you know, that sort of thing. And he would be buried there and do this and that. That sort of limited, materialistic, earthly concept belongs mostly to the Wahhabis and the similar sects. And the expectations of an Imam Mahdi held by the Barelvis are bordering upon supernatural, completely miraculous things. I mean, miraculous is all right, but supernatural, and they live mostly in the world of fantasy.

So this is why it is difficult to suggest one single answer. You can point out, of course, to the differences and then say, "First tell us a criterion, how we should judge between these expectations and be of some certainty, reach a measure of certainty about which expectation is right and which is wrong."

So it is a problem like that. The other day I was reading a book on the concept of Imam Mahdi in Shiaism. And the book is one of the most authentic books produced by any Indian scholar on this subject. He was not an Iranian scholar, but anyway, Shiaism is not a monopoly of Iran. The Indian subcontinent scholars of Shiaism were, you know, in many things, even more devout and more staunch in their belief than Shias of other countries.

So this book goes on building the case for Imam Al- Imam Qaim Al-e-Muhammad Mahdi—Imam Qaim Muhammad Mahdi, Qaim Al-e-Muhammad. No, no, Muhammad Mahdi was the name, I know that. He was supposed to be the son of Imam, Hazrat Imam Hasan Askari. Why supposed to be? Because many other Shias differ with that. They believe that he left no son at all.

But according to those who are called Asna Ashari or Isna Ashari—which is the word, Isna or Asna? Correctly speaking, it should be Isna Ashari, but they are called Asna Ashari; I mean they themselves introduce themselves as Asna Ashari. So anyway, you know what I mean. The Asna Asharis believe that he left a son who was five years old when the father died, and immediately he started doing, as they say, doing Imamat, which was a miracle in itself. He performed all the rites, you know, at the burial ceremony and everything, and suddenly he knew everything, and he start took the leadership in his hands and then disappeared.

So their expectation, in in a cave—first I thought it was 65 years or so, but in this book it says it was for 73 years that he disappeared, and that is Ghaibat-e Sughra for 73 years. Then he disappeared more completely. That is to say, he broke the contact with the intermediary deputies who were representing him and keeping contact with the people, and collecting money from them and handing over to him and spending it as he desired, and so on.

So he disappeared from sight, but he is bodily alive. That is what they stress: he is not gone back to God in spirit, but he is alive bodily, and he is kept out of circulation by God for such time as Allah would deem it proper for him to reappear. Where he is, nobody knows. According to some, he may descend from heaven.

According to some, he may appear from Ghar-e Antakya, and so on and so forth. So their expectations are completely different. And they also quote traditions of the Holy Prophet to prove their point. And they say even to the extent that the Pharaoh, who was the Pharaoh at the time of Hazrat Yusuf (as), he also predicted about Imam Muhammad Mahdi, and very clearly he stated that he would appear in such and such days, and this would happen and that would happen.

Now, the authenticity of that book can be measured by some examples which I am going to give, illustrations which I am going to give to you. He raises the question of longevity himself. Acha zara Bashir Asad zara ek taraf hat jayein thoda sa, aap theek thay. Bashir aap come this way, because you cover a lot of space and you know between you and between me and some others, you know, there is a complete break of view.

Now he says that some stupid so-called modernists express wonder and even disbelief that Imam Muhammad Mahdi could live for so long. You know, he disappeared in the third end of third century, no, I think in the fourth century, 365 or thereabout. So they say that that means about he is still alive for about—when he wrote the book, it was about 100 years ago, that's a very authentic book according to Shias—he said about 900 years he has lived, and people are wondering that this is something unnatural and it could not happen.

So he says that to discuss religiously would be, you know, below dignity with these people, "So I am going to use a language which is going to, which is their own language, and it is going to convince them from the material evidence which I am going to produce to them, which no sane man can deny."

And then the evidence he produces is this: that according to the authentic historical documents, there was one person whom somebody met in in Iraq or somewhere, and at that time he was 800 years old. And he remembered everything. He belonged to the age of Jahiliyyah. And it was his elder brother who took him to Rasul-e-Karim (saw), and he accepted Islam at his hand. And then he remembered all this, and he was a very very very very, you know, pakka Sahabi, companion of the Holy Prophet. And when this gentleman approached him and met him, he was so old that the hair on the eyebrow had covered his eyes, so he had to lift the eyebrows, and then start, you know, seeing him eye to eye, and then started telling him that the Rasul-e-Karim (saw) did this, and then did that, and then did that.

And so he said, "What other proof do you require? You see, such a strong evidence from history I am producing." And then he goes on, you know, quoting, one after the other, such incidents where many Sahaba, many companions of the Holy Prophet of Islam seem to be roaming the streets of Basra or Kufa or in this place and that place, or meeting people during the Hajj, and from all parts of the world, even from Tunisia. And they were either, you know, at different times, they were either 300 years old or 900 years old and this and that. So after finishing the list of such people, the maximum age he gives to a Muslim is about 900-some years.

Then he says, "But previously, people lived much longer." And he says the Pharaoh, whose you know whom he has quoted that he prophesied about the coming of Imam Muhammad Mahdi, he says he lived for 3,000 years. "And you are surprised that Imam Muhammad Mahdi is 900 years old?" He said, "And this is authentic." He quotes some books—I don't know where he you know he got hold of such books as he was quoting, I don't know the names either, but he gives the full list.

After making this introduction, then he begins to quote traditions of the Holy Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him. So what would be the reliability of those traditions which are presented after this introduction? If this is historical evidence, if this is irrefutable evidence, what would be the value of those traditions which are related to An-Hazrat (saw) after this absolutely, you know, hocus-pocus and total falsehood and audacity of attributing things to Rasul-e-Karim (saw) by a person 900 years after, and considering it an authentic hadith? So what would be the authenticity of the other traditions which he relates? That is what I mean.

You may come across people who would be believing in this myth, and they would expect you to prove that Hazrat Masih Maud (as) fulfilled all these expectations. You can't.

Like once, you know, as a child, I visited a Sikh village along with a few friends. I was about, you know, I think it was in, I was studying in 8th class at that time in school, and we held a very interesting debate with some Sikhs in their own village, Dhapai.

So people seemed to be influenced, you know, they started—first of all, they were very, very hostile, but gradually they softened down and ultimately they became sympathetic. So one gentleman present didn't like all this. So he, to, you know, break to destroy the impression, he got up and said, "Look here, tell me, did Mirza Sahib have bones in his body?"

I said, "Yes, he had."

He said, "All the bones complete?"

I said, "Yes, yes."

He says, "How could he be a guru then? Our gurus did not have bones."

I said, "None of them?"

He said, "No, none. No bone whatsoever. So you say he's a guru. How could a guru have bones?"

I said, "How could they walk straight, you know, how could they keep the human shape without bones?"

He said, "That is the trick. He did they did not have bones, but they appeared as if they had bones."

So I said, "All that we know of Mirza Sahib is the same. He always appeared as if he had the bones, but nobody knows. So I rectify my statement: I don't know."

That is the sort of things you will come across when you probe into the minds of the people whom you address, and they would be so many. I have a long experience of discussing things with non-Ahmadi inquirers, and every time I was surprised to find that he had built his own concept of some imam, having learned his Islam from some mullah who, according to his own taste, you know, built a fantastic imagination.

So anyway, ultimately, you have ultimately to draw him to the most dependable ground, that is the ground of the Holy Qur’an, and convince him and prove to him that if it is a complete book, it must have a positive, dependable system in it, described in this, as to the, you know, verification of claims by anybody who says that he has been sent by God. So there must be some authentic system described, and generally people listen to this, and they respond well, because the Holy Qur’an, of course, is the Holy Qur’an. Everybody is overawed by the mention of the Holy Qur’an. So then you begin to tell him, "These are the verses of the Holy Qur’an, and they are verses of universal application.

They are not limited in time. They are not limited in space. These verses speak, speak of claimants who make people believe that they are from God. They are commissioned. They have to deliver a message. They may be law-bringers or they may not be law-bringers, but whoever says that he is from God and you must listen to me on the authority of my being from God, he should be judged, and the Holy Qur’an gives you the criterion for that.

So then take one criterion after the other and then start applying it to Hazrat Masih Maud (as), and it will fit in just as if it were made to measure. That is the only way of deciding this issue.

But occasionally, there would be some, of course, who would agree to your proposal that if you must judge the issue according to the traditions, why not the tradition of, you know, tradition concerning the eclipse of the sun and the moon in certain particular dates, in a particular month, and so on?

So there are, because in the Punjab in particular, this tradition is so well known that almost everybody has heard of this. So on that issue, you can convince many, and I know many who just became Ahmadis later on with the grace of Allah, because of the force of this argument.

In the Gujarat, I think I think, this tradition is very well known, because that verse by Maulvi Muhammad Lakhoke wale, that was, that he was a Gujarati, wasn't he? You would know better, Asif Sahib. Maulvi Muhammad Lakhoke—have you heard of Lakhoke? No.

He was, you know, a great aalim who was before the time of Hazrat Masih Maud (as), the founder of the Ahmadiyya Community, and he wrote Ahwal-e Akhirat, a book under the title of Ahwal-e Akhirat, in which he describes this particular prophecy about the sun and the moon, that they would be eclipsed when the claimant, the true claimant to Mahdi would appear. And to stand witness to his claim, they would be eclipsed according to the tradition. His words, which I remember, are:

Tervi chand, satevi suraj, grahan lagsi os saale,
Andar maah Ramzane likhiya ik riwayat waale.

Tervi chand, satevi suraj, grahan lagsi os saale,
Andar maah Ramzane likhiya ik riwayat waale.

He says that it would be the 13th of the moon nights and 27th day of the sun, when both of them would be eclipsed on in the month of Ramadan at the time of Mahdi, as it is reported by one reporter of traditions.

These are his words, the literal translation of this this verse. And this is a very important book for from the Ahmadiyya point of view, because he refers to the tradition exactly in the same way as an Ahmadi interprets it.

The tradition never mentions the 13th of moon at all, or any date of the sun. The tradition simply says, the words of the Huzoor of Rasul-e-Akram (saw) are, that: sa-yankasiful-qamaru fi awwali laylatin min Ramadana wa tankasifush-shamsu fin- wa tankasifush-shamsu fin-nisfi minho minha minho, fin-nisfi minho, wa lam takuna mundha mundhu khalqis-samawati wal-ard. That when, li-Mahdiyyina ayatayni, it begins with this. You know, it lam takuna appears in some traditions in the beginning and some at some at the end, so both ways it is correct. I mean there is no harm. According to some traditions: Inna li-Mahdiyyina ayatayni lam takuna mundhu khalqis-samawati wal-ard: awwaluha an yankasifal-qamaru fi awwali laylatin min Ramadana wa tankasifash-shamsu fin-nisfi minho. And some say at the end: wa lam takuna mundhu khalqis-samawati wal-ard.

The meaning is that for our Mahdi, there would be signs. The first one would be that the moon would be eclipsed on the first night, not the 13th night, and the sun would be eclipsed in the middle, not the 27th.

So how could Maulvi Muhammad Lakhoke wale Sahib refer to the same tradition and quote wrong dates? That is the most important question. Because he was a holy man. Because he was a righteous person, and who knew the meaning of the tradition.

You know, the first of night is a night when moon can never be eclipsed. It is impossible scientifically for for anybody even to expect, because those who know the phenomenon of eclipse, they know also know that the moon eclipse is always caused when the earth is between the moon and between and the sun, and partially or completely obstructs the passage of light from the sun to to the moon. On the first of the moon night, they are at, you know, sharp angles making a triangle, and it is impossible for the shadow to travel that way, you know, and fall upon the moon. So, but Maulvi Lakhoke wale Sahib did not know this geography, yet he knew the meaning was not first, but something else. Because at least by common observation, he knew moon had never eclipsed on the first night, and he also knew that moon could not eclipse for reasons other than this, because moon is so thin, such a flake, that in itself it is doubtful. While the people are raising fingers, "There the moon the the the moon is", the moon disappears. So how could that be a sign? If it had eclipsed, it would disappear totally and completely, and nobody would believe that there was any moon. So how could Imam Mahdi, poor Imam Mahdi, convince the opposing mullahs that there was a moon, but it got eclipsed so you couldn't see? So the debate would start on and on, and there would be no conclusion.

But even apart from that, I guess Maulvi Muhammad Lakhoke wale Sahib judged what Rasul-e-Karim (saw) meant was from the fact that he used the word Qamar and not Hilal. And Maulvi Sahib knew Arabic very well. Whether he knew geography or science or not, that is debatable, but one thing is beyond doubt, that he knew Arabic very well. And according to him, as as he must have understood, the Arabs never referred to the first three moons, the moons of the first three nights, as other than Hilal. When they have a definite concept of the first or second or third moon, then they always refer to such a moon as Hilal, never as Badr or Qamar or any other name.

So how could Rasul-e-Karim (saw), who knew Arabic better than any man on earth, according to even the the the Western scholars—the quality of his language was next only to the Holy Qur’an—how could he commit such a blunder as to refer to the first-night moon and refer to it not as Hilal, but as Qamar? No Arab could do that.

You know, you can you know, you you even find similar incidents nowadays in the form of Ruet-e-Hilal committees. Have you ever heard Ruet-e-Qamar committee? Anyone ever heard? It's impossible. The moment you say, they would mock at you, they'll say, "What do you mean? Have you come from a small village where people have no concept of Arabic? What do you mean by Ruet-e-Qamar? It is Ruet-e-Hilal and always Ruet-e-Hilal, because Hilal is the first-night moon and it is always referred to as Hilal and as nothing else, even the second-night moon, third-night moon."

So Maulvi Lakhoke wale Sahib knew it well, that Rasul-e-Karim (saw) did not mean the first three nights of moon. So how what what what is left to us? The nights of the eclipse. The only thing which he could he could be referring to would be the first night of the eclipse of moon. When you first observe when when the moon is eclipsed, they are definite nights, everybody knows. There are just three nights in a month when the moon is eclipsed. And they are three nights, nobody on earth can change that.

Not even all the might of America and Russia together can change this universal phenomenon that moon can be eclipsed only in the 13th, 14th, and 15th of a month. And what is the first night of the night of eclipses of moon? 13th. That is what Maulvi Muhammad Lakhoke wale Sahib said.

Tervi chand, satevi suraj. Now in satevi he made a mistake, because he didn't know geography much, he didn't say it was 15th, which he should have said if it was the middle of the month, he should have said 15th, but he deviated by a large margin and said it would be 27th. Then what he should have said was 28th of sun, because the sun also eclipses only in three days and no other days. See, for three days in a month, and those three days are positive, determined days. They are 27th, 28th, and 29th.

So Maulvi Lakhoke Sahib, because he was referring to Hadith, what he meant was the middle night of the eclipse, which happens to be 28th and not 27th. So anyway, but we are not to follow Maulvi Muhammad Sahib, we have to follow the Muhammad, peace be upon him, himself (saw). What he said was not 27th, he said middle of the sun's eclipse day as sun's eclipse and the first of the moon's eclipse.

So when Hazrat Masih Maud (as) made the claim to Mahdi-hood, and even he started accepting, that was quite early, even he started accepting people's hand in bai'at, that was in 1889, everybody knows, that is when Jama'at-e-Ahmadiyya was founded, officially declared. And there was no moon eclipse, no sun eclipse in those days in in in any way, I mean, connected with this phenomenon. He had to wait for four more years, five more years in fact. The first eclipse of moon observed during the month of Ramadan occurred in the Ramadan of 1884, yeah? No, no, no, I'm sorry, 1894. In in 89 Ahmadiyyat came into being, 1894. And now imagine the position of Hazrat Masih Maud (as) as well as that of his opponents. The moon had got eclipsed, the month was that of Ramadan, the date was exactly the first date of eclipse, and nobody knew what was going to happen to the sun. So that was the most tantalizing position for Ahmadis as well as non-Ahmadis.

Because if that happened, then it would be a very great sign. And that is exactly what happened. The sun got eclipsed on the 28th and on no other day. And the month was that of Ramadan. So what better proof one can require? With mathematical certainty, these things happened and happened in the heavens where man, not even the sum total of whole human beings, could exert any influence on these dates. And the claimant had made his claim before this happened. This is a very strong, very positive proof.

These mullahs who were awaiting for their chance to bounce upon Hazrat Masih Maud (as) and begin to mock and laugh laugh that, "All right, the moon eclipsed on the 13th, all right, but the sun changed its date, so it was a, you know, a sort of slap from God to you," they were completely flabbergasted. And they it is noticed and recorded that one mullah of Lahore who had only one hand and a stump hanging from his his arm instead of a hand, he beat his chest with that like this and said, "Oh God, what have you done? Now people will begin to believe in Mirza and start believing, accepting his claims."

He did not want to follow Allah; he wanted Allah to follow him. So that is how that what they did, most of them. They saw the sign and then either refused to believe whatever may have may have happened, or tried to find new excuses, completely new excuses.

Before this sign occurred, these maulvis, as I have quoted, themselves had prophesied that by the first of moon's night, Rasul-e-Karim (saw) did never mean the first of the month, but the first of the eclipse nights. But once it appeared, they they completely changed their position. They said, "He is still a liar, because what Rasul-e-Karim (saw) has said is the first, not of the eclipse dates, but of the month. And the middle of the of the month as well for sun."

Now, this can never happen, because if it happens, then either the Holy Qur’an is wrong or that imam is wrong. You can't believe in the truth of both together now, with this interpretation, I mean. Because the Holy Qur’an categorically mentions that the sun and the moon are moving in orbits and they can never overtake each other, their speeds are fixed for ajalim-musamma, and they can neither lose distance between them nor gain distance between them.

That is to say, the orbit and the circuits the whole system is making, they are not changeable till such time as Allah would ultimately decide, when that is to say, Yawm-e-Qiyamah, when everything would be destroyed. So, when they can't change in their mutual relationship, the eclipse nights can never change and the eclipse days can never change. And because they can never change, their imam can never come. So the best way to get rid of the imam once and for all would be to stick to this explanation which they are offering now.

Or the Holy Qur’an would be proved wrong. The imam may be proved right if this happens, but then the people would leave Islam in mass. They would say, "Well, this imam may be right, but the Holy Qur’an is wrong, because it said these differences, this relationship between them can never be changed, and it has changed. This imam is a better God than the God of the Holy Qur’an." It can never happen. So you see, you can see the absurdity of their position.

Moreover, as I referred to earlier to this argument, I generally ask the maulvis who raise this question and insist on this interpretation, I say, "All right, if this imam is not right, your imam would come one day, and the moon would be eclipsed, according to you, on the first of night. What would happen then? The moon who lives only for a few moments—the crescent, I mean—it is not witnessed by everybody, nobody knows. And when it is eclipsed, the Ramadan moon, when it is eclipsed, it will be completely out of sight. How can that very thin thread of a moon be eclipsed and yet be visible? So the debate between Imam Mahdi and the mullah would start anew. Imam Mahdi would say that, 'Look here, the moon was eclipsed, this is why you didn't see.' They would say, 'No! You are wrong in your dates, the moon appeared next day from the one you you think about, and it was never eclipsed, it was rather bigger, you know, because it was the second day, second night moon.' So they'd say, 'We have seen, all of us have witnessed that moon, it was not eclipsed at all.' So what sort of prophecy that would be?"

So this is a very certain, very positive prophecy, which is the proof of the truth, not only of the Imam Mahdi, but of Hazrat Rasul-e-Karim (saw) himself. Many things are involved. Although moons have got eclipsed on the 13th many a time before, so the sun has also got eclipsed on the 28th. And the months keep rotating, many a time this has fallen in the months of Ramadan. But the prophecy was not this. The prophecy was that a Mahdi would be a claimant at that at that time. Although this is a rare phenomenon, but it would be made further rare by the presence of a claimant who would say, "I am an Imam Mahdi," and after he has made the claim, then Allah would show these signs.

How could Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) even conceive of such a thing, when he had nothing to do with astronomy or, you know, the movements of suns and stars, the heavenly bodies, I mean, and he had no knowledge of these dates and these things? And yet, Allah must have told him.

And this is why he said, "our Mahdi". That is also very significant, because that also shows that there would be many claimants to this office of Mahdi-hood, not one. Otherwise, he should have shouldn't have said for "my Mahdi", for "our Mahdi", and this also is an expression of endearment, closeness, of love. When you say, "the sign for our Mahdi would be this", you know, that means he is very close to him. And also it says that there would be other Mahdis with whom I have no concern. I'm I am only concerned with that Mahdi in whose time Allah shows this sign. The moon gets eclipsed, the sun gets eclipsed in one month, the month is Ramadan, and the dates are exactly this and that. Put these factors into permutation, combination, and then you will know how rare it becomes. It becomes almost impossible.

So the proof is not that of Imam Mahdi in the first place, it is the proof of the truth of the Holy Prophet of Islam. And once it has got exhibited and established beyond doubt, these maulvis, they hate Hazrat Masih Maud (as) so much that they say they would rather leave the whole sign, you know, reject the whole sign, and than to accept you.

10 of 10 left today