2. What should a Muslim man do in the case of divorce if the man has already paid the wife her dowry but the law entitles her to more assets?
Question-and-answer session, 20 December 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What should a Muslim man do in the case of divorce if the man has already paid the wife her dowry but the law entitles her to more assets?
The first one is, as you know, in this country the rate of divorce is so high that it can really be called a runaway sort of thing. So there was no protection for women in this country in the past. But about two years ago, the government of British government has passed legislation giving women a sort of Haq Mehr, but that is to a certain type of women only. Government has passed legislation that if a couple get married, the very time that registration takes place, if the husband is owner of a house—not business, matrimonial house—the woman automatically becomes half owner of that house.
Now, in view of this, what would be the position of we people who have already sort of promised a certain amount of Haq Mehr to ladies? Well, in that case, Haq Mehr is no longer necessary, and that legal obligation, which each couple has to meet, can be considered a replacement of Haq Mehr. But it should be understood in so many words.
We have got a similar case reported in the Ahmadiyya history, where Hazrat Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan Sahib, the son-in-law of Hazrat Masih Maud (as), fixed the Haq Mehr, that is the dowry, to, you know, an exorbitant size. I mean, nobody could imagine that normally such Haq Mehrs could be appointed, could be fixed. So, normally it is discouraged to inflate out of proportion any Haq Mehr; it should be a normal, moderate sum of money.
The reason which he gave was very understandable. He said, "According to the laws of our state, Malerkotla state, my wife cannot inherit me. So, to offset that, I have proposed the Haq Mehr to be equal to the value of what my wife might have inherited in case of Islamic practice of, you know, giving one-eighth or one-fourth to the wife." So, he compensated for that, and Hazrat Masih Maud (as) approved of it.
Now, that was made clear. So, if after the death no legacy was left for Hazrat Nawab Mubarika Begum Sahiba, nobody had a right to raise a finger that Islamic laws of inheritance have not been followed, because they were already met with in a different way, and the provision was provided.
So if that, if it can be provided there, why not in this country? So, you know, it is an opposite case: there, law prevented the implementation of an Islamic right given to ladies; here, they give more than the right that Islam gives. So whatever is the right Islam gives should be considered as a part of that, provided that the house is of a value which fulfills the requirement. So no blind universal decision can be applied to each case. Each case has to be decided on its merit.
Suppose somebody is so wealthy that he owns property abroad, not only in this country, but abroad in so many places, and also liquid assets, which are to a value that even if half of the house is given, handed over to the wife, yet the wife would have inherited much more after his death, then that cannot compensate—if, I mean, I'm considering inheritance now, that would not compensate for that.
Similarly, if a man's income is so much that the dowry money he should pay normally—that is, according to our calculation, roughly according to the general formula, it should be one year's income or six months' income—so if his income is so big that the price of the house falls short of that dowry which he should have fixed, then he should fix some dowry over and above that half the house price and compensate for that.
So, this is why I say no thumb rule can be given, but there is a general principle involved that compensation can be made. So, but still, let me revise my first sentence, first statement: I don't like the Haq Mehr to be totally absent because the wife would get half the house, but instead of that we can say that in such cases a nominal Haq Mehr can be fixed with a view that already she has got half the house, so it's not...