5. How is it possible to obtain closeness to God without a belief in the Crucifixion and Atonement of Jesus?

Question-and-answer session, 20 December 1986, Part 2

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Yes, yeah, again the concept is the same, because I go every Tuesday, I go knocking on doors, because I feel that I have the truth and I must present that truth. And that's what you're saying, isn't it? You you know you've got the truth and you go and present it to others so that others can be part of that truth. And in the same way, you teach your people. In church, I teach mine. And we look after the spiritual beings.

No, that's not that's not enough. The fact is that this attitude is based on the fact that because you have got something good and you are good within, you want to share with each other. So if others come to you to share their goodness, they have an equal right to do that. When you go to others, you also give the right, the same right to the others to come to you and try to convince you that the goodness with which you feel yourself satisfied is not enough; there is a much better goodness, much larger goodness, much more lasting quality of goodness which we have to offer you. So when you expect the the inmates of a house at whose doors you knock to respond favorably and to give you time to listen to you, the same should be, courtesy should be extended to those who come to you, knock at your door, and to tell you that perhaps you don't know the truth; you think you are you have got everything, but we are going to convince you that you have not got everything.

Well, I’ve come here tonight to convince you of the same. So, again, it's the same concept. I've come here to say to you that I know a distinct peace with God through Jesus. And you're saying to me, you know it through your religion.

No, no, this not not same. What I'm saying is a different thing. I said, historically, Jesus is lies at a time, at an in an era, which has been superseded by a new revelation, like Jesus superseded some earlier eras of prophets before him. He changed the emphasis of teachings from revenge to forgiveness, yeah, so that is what I mean by superseding an era, changing it in revolutionary manner to completely thing, different thing. But that was not enough; that was not all. This process continued into the final culmination of religion, and as God had promised that He would lead man ultimately to a summit where the revelation of God would be complete as if God had come Himself. We believe that that has happened. We believe that this era has been ushered by the coming of Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him.

So, as you look with pity at Jews, who fail to understand the truth of Christianity, so we look at you with pity. In the same manner, we look back and say, well, you were brave enough to accept the truth, offering so much sacrifice for hundreds of years, and detaching and dissociating yourself from the past. Now when the truth has come again, further purified and more enlarged, you are left behind in the same age as the Jews were left behind in their older age prior to the coming of Christ. So our relationship to you is exactly the same, so you better listen to us, find out.

Yes, well, I'm I'm quite I've listened.

If this is not, you know, then you are you're missing a lot. But but if I'm if I'm right, then you're missing a lot as well.

No, no, because you are in perspective, historical perspective, you are behind me. We believe in Jesus; we're not missing. You don't believe in in Prophet Muhammad, so you are missing. We believe we've we've got the greatest prophet that ever lived in Jesus. I have the same, if on sitting on a table, I share a bowl of bowl of of of soup with you, and also I have a a piece of roasted joint. You are missing that roasted joint; I'm not missing your soup. So when I believe in Jesus Christ and understand him from an angle which I believe is much more logical, much more realistic, then I share him more than you do according to my belief. So you should give me a chance to make you understand this perspective.

I will do, as long as I can present the truth as I see it.

All the chance should not be provided to me tonight.

Oh no, no, that's fair enough, yeah.

You see, already we are past an hour from the time when we generally disperse.

Oh, sorry.

What I tell you, when I say "me", I mean Ahmadis in general, not always me alone, because I'm busy elsewhere too, you know. Being head of the community, I have great occupation, preoccupations and occupations, things like that. I've looked to look after the affairs of 10 million people all over the world, and also those who are not Ahmadis. So, I have a limited time. But when I say "me", I mean give a chance to him or to others who can also speak for Islam in a manner that I hope, insha'Allah, they'll be able to deliver the goods to you.

Yes. As long as you keep what what you said to me earlier, that if you come and you want to share goodness with me, and I think I've got a goodness, as long as you listen to me, yeah?

Yes, of course. It has to be both ways. But it should be the the method of exchange of views and dialogue should not be a parochial method, a limited method; it should be a universal method. You know, if you start trying to convey to me things in the language which only Christians understand, which other human beings cannot understand, then you will not be doing service either to the cause of Christianity or to my cause. So, that then you should the platform should be common. Although the views may be divergent.

Yes, I'm a very common person.

So we will we will discuss things to begin with, we'll agree to the fact that we'll discuss things from the dialectical angle, from the common sense angle. We'll speak a language which human beings should normally understand, and will not be dictated to by an understanding of any testament of yours, which is your understanding and which is not mine. Nor shall I impose the understanding of the Holy Qur’an on you, because you don't believe in the Holy Qur’an.

So the ideal way would be to find a via media which is common to both, and that is only the human level: common sense, ordinary logic. So if you are ready to understand Islam from that point of view, and if you are ready to make us understand Christianity from that point of view, then we have something in common. Otherwise, it will be a sheer waste of time.

Yeah. Well, you arrange the date and I'll be there.

Oh, not perhaps you, perhaps... Imam Sahib, you better come into contact with him. And I find him a very, very sensible and very noble gentleman. And he, I I believe he is after truth. And he believes in Christianity and will believe in Christianity only as long as he believes it to be the entire truth. So come into dialogue with him, and I hope, insha'Allah, Allah will lead you to the right path.

You better continue praying to God. Don't insist that I must pray through Jesus Christ. God is, you know, available to every man everywhere. Why can't you pray simply to Him, not through anything?

If you pray to Him, and in I'll I'll tell you a way of compromise: you speak to Allah, address Him directly and say, "Look here, God, I don't know whether You are to be met only through Jesus Christ or through other doors as well. Some people claim this and some that. But so far, I believe honestly that You are only available through Jesus Christ. I want You whichever way You are available, so I request You, I beg You that You lead me to the right path, and I promise in return that even if You lead me to a path which is at present not acceptable to me, which is horrifying to me, but if I'm convinced that that is Your path, I'll follow it." With that pledge made with God, if you pray, I assure you that the things will be made very easy for you.

Yeah, you see, for the last four months now, I've been reading the Holy Qur’an on on Jesus, because it all centers for me around Jesus. You understand? Jesus is everything to me. And the picture that the Holy Qur’an gives of Jesus is a distinct one, separate from what the Bible gives. That is... Now we've got to find out the real Jesus.

No, don't say what the Bible gives, but only say what you understand that Bible gives. Because we don't reject Bible. No. We read Bible from the angle in the Holy Qur’an, and we find both at one with each other, in total concord with each other.

Well, I'm having a distinct problem with that at the moment.

So so what I mean to say is, when you read such passages where you find the biblical concept to be fundamentally different with the concept in the Holy Qur’an of Jesus, those are the areas where you should hold dialogue with him or some other Ahmadi scholar.

Yes, I would love to.

So, that will make things easier for us, to come to one conclusion, you know. Then it will be up to him to convince you that the concept in the Holy Qur’an of Jesus is actually the true concept of the Bible itself.

Yes, I'm willing to listen.

All right, very good.

As long as I can have my little twopence.

So, let's call it a day now.

Yes, okay then.

Let's start saying prayer. I mean, we'll say our prayer. And thank you so much for coming and asking so many interesting questions, because you have been a means of enlargement of knowledge of everybody who participated.

Yeah, and thank you everybody for being patient, okay? Thank you very much.

Thank you.

You want a statement to be made? All right. Okay. But I hope that will not start a new debate.

No, not at all. I hope so, I hope to. You know, I used to ask Christians this question, that when my friend, he just mentioned about the cross, that he has to use cross to go to the God, I would ask them, and I've usually asked them that what if Jesus was killed by a dagger or by a pistol? Would you use that also as a mean to go to God? I mean, it's just a material thing which was used to kill kill Jesus.

No, no, please. I must you're not making a statement, you're asking a question which will start a debate. Don't do it.

But, you know, what he wants to convey to you is an angle which you should also be aware of. And, in essence, he is not far from truth. In fact, it's a very vital point he's raising in a different way. What he says is that cross is the enemy of cross, of Jesus Christ. Why should you love cross? You should hate it, because it killed Jesus Christ. So the weapon which kills your beloved is always the weapon who draws your hatred rather than your love. Now, I'm not starting a debate. I'm conveying to you what I'm doing is, I'm conveying to you his idea. This is what he wanted to tell you. That's right. You agree, or you may not agree. But if you want to hold a debate with him, he can give you time for this, right?

10 of 10 left today