5. Of the 73 sects in Islam, how does one identify the one that is the right one?

Question-and-answer session, 27 December 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Of the 73 sects in Islam, how does one identify the one that is the right one?

First question would be that before Mirza Sahab, say even birth, right, which of the Islamic or sects within Islam would you say was the true one according to your belief, thought?

You know, every sect of Islam has large elements of truth even today, because this truth cannot be considered to have abandoned Islam altogether at any time in history. If you study the Holy Qur’an, you'll be surprised to learn something which the present Ulema would not admit, but the Holy Qur’an says so categorically that even among the Jews there are very pious and righteous people, God-fearing people, and also among the Christians. And also the Holy Qur’an testifies to the truth of the all the old books despite the fact that they have been interpolated and changed materially and substantially. So it is impossible for an Ahmadi or any other Muslim to believe that there exists a sect of Islam which is totally wrong. The truth has been shared in many regions by many sects, and also falsehood gradually crept into them through a long process of historical decay. So this is why they can't agree with them. It is a simple logical question which you should understand. The fact is there are 72 sects at least and they differ with each other in fundamentals, so can't you see that some of them must be wrong somewhere?

Yeah, but if I can just relate to Huzoor-e-Akram (saw)'s Hadith, not exactly, but near me in essence, is that 72—there would be 73 sects altogether, one would be the right one and the rest, the rest would go to hell. Right?

And stay there.

And stay there. Okay, okay, up to there then. But, but my question was that which is the most nearest to the truth one? That's my question is, the way I said it.

All right, if that is the question, this question was asked at the time when Rasul-e-Akram (saw) made this statement, this question was asked of him by one of the companions. So why to waste time in answering that question differently, because when a correct answer has already been given by the founder of Islam, peace be upon him, that is the answer which still stands good for all of us to accept.

Okay, which is Sunni.

So one of the present during that at that time raised exactly this question, that: "Ya Rasulullah, man ha'ula'i? Who will be those fortunate ones who are exempt according to you? Who will be the right Jama'at?"

Which is called?

Jama'at. Just Jama'at. According to Rasul-e-Akram (saw), there would be 72 sects, but the 73rd he does not refer to as sect, but as Jama'at. So that is also one very important difference which should be kept in mind. You understand this point?

Now, when he said that just one Jama'at will be heavenly, the question was asked who that Jama'at would be, or who those people would be. The answer was, "Ma ana 'alaihi wa ashabi." You will find them to face exactly the same situation as I am facing, and my followers are facing. They will be found in the same condition as myself and my followers are found today. So that was the most illuminative answer that was given by Rasul-e-Akram (saw).

Now you can apply this answer to the modern situation and very clearly say, like the daylight which can never be confused with night, you can positively say which that Jama'at would be. What happened to Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) at that time? What was happening to him and his followers? Is that not clear to you?

Yeah, yeah.

What was happening to him? When he made the claim that there is no God but one, and Muhammad is His servant and His prophet, was he and his followers later on, were they permitted to make this claim publicly? Or were they beaten and punished for this?

Yeah, okay, but I think you are going away from the point. The answer I want...

You may think, but I am not going away at all, because I am directly on the point. "Ma ana 'alaihi wa ashabi" is a statement which can be verified from history. What was the condition of Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) and his followers vis-a-vis the rest? There are two parties involved: 72 on one side and one Jama'at on the other. At the time of Aan-Hazrat (saw) also there were several parties opposed to him, not only one party: Mushrikeen of all sorts, Ahl-e-Kitab of all sorts, old and the new Ahl-e-Kitab. And he was facing a situation along with his followers which is very clear from the study of history.

And there are no two opinions about it. It begins with the right to profess. Now, the most fundamental profession that is to be made by a Muslim was La ilaha illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah. And they were denied that. They were persecuted. They were dragged in the streets. They were nearly killed, tortured in such a beastly manner that even today, when you study that history, that most sad part of history, you feel like crying.

What happened to Bilal? Why it happened to him? He was saved from the fangs of death by Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra) when he was passing by the street and he saw him almost being murdered for the crime of professing Kalimah La ilaha illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah. Is that not happening today to Ahmadis and to Ahmadis alone? That is my question. And to none else. And who is responsible for treating Ahmadis like this? The rest of the 72 sects or not?

As far as I understand, the rest of the 72 sects do not help each other. I don't think they are together in that sense.

All the sects in Pakistan, without exception, are at one in this attitude. Show me the statement of one sect, published in any Pakistani paper or anywhere, condemning roundly and clearly the treatment of Ahmadis with regarding this. In the Shariat Court and in all the councils which decide about the laws of Shariah, etc., all the important sects of Pakistan are represented: Shias and Sunnis, Wahhabis, Deobandis and Ahl-e-Hadith and Barelvis—everybody is represented there. And that council has unanimously declared that this should be the treatment of Ahmadis if they declare Kalimah La ilaha illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah. So, how can you say that some sects should be exempted from this?

Yeah. The reason being that, as we know, that all the sects are different from each other and they will not agree with each other. That's why they're different, right? So I'm not surprised that they are not helping Ahmadis or anybody else.

No, no, no. I'm not saying that. They agree on this emphatically, that this is the treatment which should be meted out to Ahmadis for professing the ever-eternal truth, that there is no God but one and Muhammad is His Prophet.

That is understandable, you see, because they differ.

If it is understandable, then already you have decided your fate. Then you want to join that party which has always been opposed to truth like this.

No, but I am also trying to say that I belong to one sect, right?

How can you belong to that sect while you are not in the position in which Rasulullah (saw) was found?

If there are to be 73 sects, I have to be part of one.

Let me first proceed further. The criterion for that truth was further clarified in other respects. They were not permitted to build mosques. They were not permitted to preach to others. They were not permitted to worship God as they thought fit. Is that not right?

Probably.

Probably? Be honest enough, please, to admit it.

If I can't locate it, I will not admit anything.

You don't admit; the Holy Qur’an does.

No, if I can't—yeah, okay, if the Holy Qur’an says, it's fair enough.

The Holy Qur’an says: alladhi yanha 'abdan idha salla. It says, who is worse than the person, than the one who stops people from saying prayer, from my servant, that is Muhammadur Rasulullah (saw), when he does that. And you say you're not sure.

So, first of all, be sure of your history of Islam and the facts of your own sect. All the treatments which were meted out to Aan-Hazrat (saw) and his followers in the name of religion are exactly being repeated to Ahmadis. And in that, all the 72, the rest of the 72 sects have joined hands. History is being created right under your noses, and you don't want to take note of that. And still you claim you are the sect? How could you be the sect? Show me one similarity from what passed, what happened to Rasul-e-Karim (saw). Have you ever been bodily prevented from declaring La ilaha illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah? Have you ever served a sentence in prison for doing that?

I haven't been in the situation.

Any member of your community? Show me one.

Yes.

Who? Where? Just about La ilaha illallah?

Yes.

Yes? Show me. Tell me one.

Okay, I'll give you an example of Maulana Abdul Latif.

Which Maulana Abdul Latif?

Jhelmi Sahab.

He was imprisoned for the fact that he said La ilaha illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah?

Well, if you are defending Islam, all the aspects would come into it.

For God's sake! Just a moment. I am talking of one particular thing, the fundamental thing. So this is what you mean, you have not come for debate but for inquiry? This is what you call honest inquiry? You raise a question and you have not the patience to listen to the answer to the full?

To be honest, I'll say that again. Well, you ask me a question, I'll give you an answer. That's what I'm doing.

No, no, no. When I make a statement, you interfere.

Oh, sorry.

When I ask a question, you don't answer. For that, I have to press on for an answer, and you don't. You hesitate. And when I'm making a statement, you interfere. This is no decent way of coming and asking questions. This is why I knew the moment I set eyes on you, what sort of questioner has come. So be patient. Be patient with me. Once you have asked your question, have courage and patience to listen to the answer.

Okay, sorry.

So the most important thing—no, no, don't touch him now. Now he's asked the question, let me answer.

What happened to Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) was that he was prevented from professing the fundamental article of Muslim faith. This has happened to Ahmadis and Ahmadis alone in the entire world after that time, and it has not happened to any other sect. There is no sect in Islam which has been prevented by the rest of the sects to say their prayers. Ahmadis are. For that, they are suffering in jails even today. They have been beaten almost to death. They have been treated most heinously and cruelly for the crime of saying Kalimah La ilaha illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah and for worshipping God.

Which other sect has been prevented legally, by legal action, to profess what they believe and to preach what they believe? Show me one sect. Ahmadis—I can prove it from the Ordinance, if from nothing else, from the Ordinance of—the notorious Ordinance of 26th of April, 1984—that Ahmadis have been deprived of their fundamental right of preaching what they believe to be the truth.

This was exactly what was done to Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) and his followers: “Don’t preach to us!” It is a known fact of history that not only Huzoor-e-Akram (saw), but all the previous prophets also were treated like this, and about Aan-Hazrat (saw) it was said and this is recorded that, “Either you cease from believing such things and propagating your faith, or either we will kill you or we will turn you out of this land and confiscate your properties and dispossess you of everything.” Is that not right?

Up to that extent, yes.

Exactly! And this is exactly what is being done to Ahmadis in Pakistan. Is it being done to your sect? Show me where a law was passed, in any manner of speaking, which prevented your sect, that is Deobandi, from preaching their faith, at the pain of punishment that they would be confiscated their properties and they would be externed from their land and even they would be killed. About whom a law is being passed that their faith is like being a renegade to Islam, their faith is just apostasy, so they should be murdered en masse? This was the verdict against Aan-Hazrat (saw) and his followers.

So all the difficult things which are the bitterest are being fulfilled by us. And you, the treaders of easy path, you claim that you are exactly like Rasul-e-Akram (saw) and his followers? The liars, the false people can imitate the easy things, the comfortable ways and habits, not the difficult things, not things for which they are bitterly punished. This is only a sign of truth.

So whatever difficult paths were tread by Aan-Hazrat (saw) and his holy followers, they are being treaded today by us in the open broad daylight. The history is being recorded and stamped permanently, indelibly on the pages of age, and yet you don't see them.

So this is what he meant when he said, Ma ana 'alaihi wa ashabi, you can see easily what I am, on what I am, and what is my condition and my followers’ condition. Now some non-Ahmadi scholars insist that what he said was not what was happening to him, but what he meant, his Sunnah and his faith. That could not be the answer, because at that time Islam was one united Islam.

There was absolutely no difference in doctrine, in doctrines or in even partial difference in views; the whole Islam was one Islam. So the question never arose. The question arose regarding his position and his followers' position vis-à-vis the opponents. So he must be referring to that, and that is the only logical thing which can infer from this.

So Ahmadiyya Jama'at is treading that difficult path which is not easy, which no false people can tread with such courage, with such perseverance, and generation after generation. And yet you, along with all your might, the united might of the rest of the sects, have failed to arrest the path of our progress. Show me one place in the earth, even in Pakistan, where even for one single day or one single night, the progress of Ahmadiyyat was arrested because of all these stringent measures taken against Ahmadiyyat.

This is exactly, again, the position of Aan-Hazrat (saw) and his followers. Despite everything their opponents did, he continued to progress. So if you want to apply your mind honestly and in a detached manner, not in an involved way, it's not difficult to find the truth, to recognize the truth. It's so obvious.

If I can just say that it still doesn't answer what I asked, really, not into the depth I expected. I'll go back to it again. As you said that we joined forces, I can assure you that especially my school of thought, Deobandi, Sunni Mazhab—and I'm talking about the side which is in Pakistan—that they have not joined forces with anybody else, by saying this.

Are you a Deobandi or a Barelvi?

Deobandi.

Deobandi. They are the leading ones in Pakistan, without a shadow of doubt, who are foremost in persecution of Ahmadis, and in demanding the most heinous punishment ever meted out to anyone in the history of mankind. And yet, you don't know.

No, that I can understand, yes, but when you say that joining forces with the others, I cannot accept that.

Yes, this is what they are doing. They are inviting everybody to this and they say the whole Muslim Ummah is behind them. If you have never read such claims by your own scholars, I can provide you with the references to them. This is their claim: that although we speak as Deobandis, but we don't speak as Deobandis in this regard; as far as the Ahmadiyya issue is concerned, the whole Ummah is behind us.

This is all through the history of their claim. It has never been challenged by anybody.

People, I would just say this: the people who do join forces with the others, as far as I'm concerned, would not belong to Sunni Mazhab.

What do you mean by that?

They would not belong to the Sunni Mazhab anymore. They might say it, some of them who have joined forces, and they say on this platform, "Let's get together," I don't agree with them at all.

I'm surprised at that. If you don't agree with them, then you don't belong to the whole mass of the Muslim world, because they agree with each other in this. So then you should belong to us, then. There's no other way left for you.

Yeah, but I still belong to the Sunni sect, and if somebody goes astray up to a certain extent, it doesn't mean a thing to me.

If you have the courage to say that in Pakistan, even if you want to belong to them, you'll be disowned, you'll be excommunicated, because they'll say the whole Ummah is behind this idea of persecution of Ahmadis and prosecution and, you know, beastly treatment of Ahmadis. And who is this odd man out? Chuck him out or punish him exactly in the same manner. So willy-nilly, you have to belong to us—if not in faith, in punishment at least.

Can I just talk about just Tehreek-e-Khuddam-e-Ahl-e-Sunnat?

What?

Tehreek-e-Khuddam-e-Ahl-e-Sunnat Wal-Jamaat Pakistan.

I know them very well.

As far as I know, they haven't joined forces with anybody else.

For God's sake, please listen to this.

I haven't even heard—

Just a moment, please. They publish their papers from Gujranwala, and they have repeatedly raised their voice exactly in favour of what is happening in Pakistan at the hands of other Ulama to Ahmadis, repeatedly. And yet you say they have not joined forces.

And also, joining forces can be established beyond doubt from what happened in 1974 in the National Assembly of Pakistan. The reporting that covered the final decision declared in headlines that all the 72 sects of Islam have joined forces in excommunicating Ahmadiyyat from Islam, and only Ahmadiyyat. Now that is so obvious, so obviously an irrefutable argument in favour of Ahmadiyyat's truth. Why? Because—

Previously, like you said, every sect used to claim that we are the one as against the rest of the 72. On that fatal day in the National Assembly of Pakistan, it was so decided that we are 72 and that is one, whom we are chucking out.

Would you kind enough please to name that paper?

On the 6th of September, Khuddam-ud-Din is the name of the paper. I have been reading it, the cuttings come to me. So you think I am a liar, I am a false man, I am making misstatements?

Well, as I said, I've just come to ask questions, you know, not for debate at all.

Please. When I say that, I mean it. I know what I'm saying.

The fact is, now referring to the 6th of September 1974, what happened was all the united might of the Muslim sects declared a definition. According to that definition, only Ahmadis could be chucked out of Islam and all the rest of the sects remained Muslims, despite the fact that they had not reformed their views.

Now, what manner of honesty that was on the part of Khuddam-ud-Din to accept those as true Muslims whom they had categorically mentioned previously to be outside the pale of Islam, because they fundamentally differed with their own sect on doctrines which they considered were essential doctrines of Islam?

For instance, Khuddam-ud-Din still have the belief that those who pray to the dead saints, who expect things from them, who visit the graves of dead people and expect blessings from these things, they are mushrikin. Am I right or am I wrong in this statement?

Yeah, in that sense, okay, you should be right.

All right, I'm right. And yet all the Barelvis from 6th September 1974 onwards were declared and accepted to be true Muslims. The Khuddam-ud-Din consider those who believe that the prophecy was meant for Hazrat Ali and not for Rasul-e-Akram (saw) as positively deviating from the fundamentals of Islam so that they are outside the pale of Islam—those who believe among the Shias that because Aan-Hazrat (saw) was very similar in features to Hazrat Ali (ra), so Hazrat Jibra'il (as) misdelivered the revelation and instead of delivering it to Hazrat Ali, he delivered it to Rasulullah (saw).

This sect still exists, and according to the definition of the 6th September 1974, they are Muslims, and the Khuddam-ud-Din have also to agree to this fact that nobody can declare them outside the pale of Islam, because the definition accepted by all the sects considers them to be within the pale of Islam. So they are Muslims.

Fair enough.

And what is this compromise? In fundamental truth, can there be compromise? Can you honestly say that?

No, there should be no compromise.

All the seventy-two sects of Islam differ with each other more glaringly in fundamentals than Ahmadis can ever think of differing with you. The only difference between Ahmadis and the other sects, fundamental difference, is that we believe that the status of the Promised Messiah and the Mahdi would be that of a subordinate Prophet. But we agree with you on the unity of God; we agree with you on the sanctity of Khilafat-e-Rashida; we agree with you that the revelation was meant for Rasul-e-Akram (saw) and not for Hazrat Ali; we agree with you about the Sunnah, about the traditions, about the position of the Holy Qur’an, inviolable position of the Holy Qur’an and the Sunnah, and so on. And yet, you honestly think we are outside the pale of Islam, and all the rest who do not agree with you on these fundamentals, they still enjoy the canopy of Islam over their heads; they are not turned out of the pale. What sort of honesty that is!

So you, seventy-two, have joined forces without shame on that point, that we are together one, we are Muslims, as against one which is chucked out of Islam. Which means that you have declared that the seventy-two are heavenly people and one is hellish. Now, this is exactly a rebellion against the decision of Aan-Hazrat (saw). What he said was, he also divided the Ummah in two parts: seventy-two on one side and one on the other. According to his verdict, the one which was different and distinct from the seventy-two, that one sect was to be a heavenly sect, and the seventy-two together would be hellish. And your statement and your agreement on that fatal day—this is why I call it a fatal day—was a rebellion in spirit and in letter against the verdict of Aan-Hazrat (saw). That day it was declared from the minarets of Pakistan and from the National Assembly building, etc., that no, Rasul-e-Karim (saw) was wrong in his statement; seventy-two were to be declared as people of heaven because they are Muslims; only one was to be declared as people belonging to hell.

And still you can compromise with this position? I'm surprised.

I can just if I just go back to the point of Khuddam-ud-Din—

No, you promised not to indulge into a debate. You asked repeated questions and I tolerated them. This is not a forum for such debates, and I can see immediately that your personal knowledge about your own faith and the faith of the rest of the Muslims is very limited.

So first of all, do some more study work, read more about the Ahmadiyyat and the differences. And all these things which you want me to say now, repeat, they have been already said by me in my previous addresses, question and answer sessions, in the tapes. We can provide you with a catalogue of cassettes in English and Urdu. So if you are meaningful in your research, I advise you to be patient. All the differences cannot be solved in one night, in one sitting. I have given you more time than many a questioner who has come here from far and wide to ask questions, etc. That should be enough for the time being.

Fair enough.

Study more, listen to more tapes, cassettes, and jot down the questions first. If you tell those to your friends, they will send them to me. If I have available literature or cassettes, I'll point out, or may appoint somebody to meet you. So, if there are some odd questions which I think cannot be properly tackled by ordinary Ahmadi scholars, then I will give you another chance, Insha'Allah.

Can I just say, lastly, that it still hasn't answered my questions anywhere at all?

Then only Allah can answer that question. No, to be honest, I have answered the question much more than I thought I should, much more than sufficient.

This is the way I feel, that's all.

So still, if you are not satisfied, then I cannot satisfy you. I am not God. I never claim to be God, or I mean something else, I'm not even a prophet. I'm a very humble servant of prophets of God. So how can I have control over your mental faculties and your faculties of your heart?

These things which I have said have been understood perfectly by all the present ones. Even by a non-Ahmadi friend who is present here. I should ask you, please: you are not an Ahmadi, you listened to his question, you listened to my answer, tell me honestly whether I answered that question sufficiently and amply or not.

And he says no! So what can I do about it?

Fair enough. To him it might be clear, that's what I said exactly. Okay, thanks a lot.

So I was right in my judgment. The moment I set eyes on your face, I knew what sort of questioner is present, see? So you have proved me right. At least in this much.

10 of 10 left today