3. Following what Huzur said last night: the present religion reflects the teachings of earlier religions; we cannot categorically call any religion, or its foundation, wrong, only say that some parts of its teaching have become obsolete with time. But in friendly talks with other religions they ask: is our religion wrong?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 February 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Following what Huzur said last night: the present religion reflects the teachings of earlier religions; we cannot categorically call any religion, or its foundation, wrong, only say that some parts of its teaching have become obsolete with time. But in friendly talks with other religions they ask: is our religion wrong?
What was stated in the Dars implies that the fundamentals of all religions are basically the same – just as the framework of life is one, whether human or animal, at whatever stage: DNA, RNA and similar things are common to all, the style is the same, the design similar. The Holy Qur’an says the fundamentals of all religions are one. Yet there is a great difference between the form of a monkey and of a man. If you said the monkey’s anatomy and design closely resemble man’s, so what difference does it make, let us become monkeys again – that would be absurd. Once the next stage of development has taken shape, the earlier stage becomes obsolete at once. Your own case is that you prefer the latest car model, though basically the difference is very small; in the model of religion there are far greater changes compared to the car, and you get them free, yet you do not take them – I mean man in general, not the doctor sahib. You must explain to them, and probably repeatedly, that despite religion being fundamentally one, two kinds of differences have brought errors into it. First, part of the teaching of earlier religions was temporary. Just as in man’s social development the cart played a major role – in its time you cannot call it wrong; it was the most advanced form, with wooden wheels, the most advanced means of carriage. But when faster vehicles like chariots and more modern means of conveyance were invented, up to freight trains and lorries, if the cart owner then argued that he wants to keep his cart because you say it was perfect for its time, that would be unreasonable. So the answer is: we do not call it wrong, because when that teaching came it was right; but it related to its era, so its time-bound part has become wrong in today’s context, not in its own. The basic enduring religion (Din al-Qayyimah) which the Holy Qur’an speaks of continues, and no one can make it wrong: worship, care for the rights of people, spend of your wealth on the poor and on good works – no age can make that wrong; these are the fundamentals. The second part is what they changed themselves – seeking mischief and seeking their own interpretation, mentioned in yesterday’s verse: some part was left behind in the process of evolution, some they shaped to their own liking, to create mischief, for personal gain, taking money to suit someone’s wishes, removing things, and thus corrupted religion, until the majority took it as part of religion. The later religion acted as Furqan and showed that these parts are not of God but of man; hence that part is wrong. When errors have occurred and are proven to be errors, it is your duty to leave them and accept the most modern, latest model of religion. If this was confusing last night, you should have asked then; that is why there was an opportunity for questions.