4. When we do Tabligh, Muslims who have long lived here, e.g. from Iran or Egypt, say: we believe in the five pillars of Islam, why must you always argue that we should become Ahmadi and believe in the Messiah (as)? And regarding Christians and Jews they say: if they do good deeds and are better human beings, God Himself will forgive them – why must you disturb them?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 February 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: When we do Tabligh, Muslims who have long lived here, e.g. from Iran or Egypt, say: we believe in the five pillars of Islam, why must you always argue that we should become Ahmadi and believe in the Messiah (as)? And regarding Christians and Jews they say: if they do good deeds and are better human beings, God Himself will forgive them – why must you disturb them?
You should discuss whether one should act on what the Holy Prophet (saw) said. Start from there and ask: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that when the Imam Mahdi comes, accept him, and when the Messiah comes, accept him. (Questioner: they say when he comes there will be a great upheaval in the world, so it will become known.) Then the foundation is established; they accept that. We are only saying he has come – so discuss whether he has come or not. If he has come, tell them: you yourselves believe that then accepting him becomes necessary. Tell them: you do not only believe he is to come, you believe it is such a great event that the life and death of Islam will be bound to this question. He will come because the Muslims will be corrupted; he will come to give new life, grant a new organisation, and prepare for the dominance of Islam in the world; he is not coming to put on a show. When you settle these points with them, this issue takes priority even in their own view. Tell them: this is your belief, and we believe he has come; is it not our duty to tell you? And if his coming is as meaningless as you present it to me, why did the Holy Prophet (saw) need to make such a great prophecy and give it such importance? So the discussion should begin from the fundamentals. As for the second point: it is not only a question of their forgiveness; this approach is very selfish. Religion comes to rectify a system, and when the system is right, it is not an individual accident that a few people are good; rather better means are created for the vast majority to be good. That is why revolutions are needed in the religious world. Individually a person can be good anywhere – in Russia there are good people, in America too, in various places. So why is there a need to change the system? Because if a good system comes, the majority are provided better opportunities to be good. Therefore the religious system must either be changed or revived. You can also put it this way: a few people pray, a few do good, but by temperament has not the vast majority of the Islamic world become unrighteous? Is it not stepping further into decline day by day? Is corruption not penetrating ever more deeply into our economic, social and moral condition? One should not argue about individuals. The Holy Qur’an itself says there are good people among the Jews and among the Christians; when we discuss with them, this is part of our fundamentals; we already accept it as the word of the Holy Qur’an. You will have to tell them: when the Holy Qur’an began fourteen hundred years ago, when your condition was better than today, it said even then that there are good people among you, yet you still needed reform. Today you have become worse; today there is an even greater need for your reform, collective reform. Secondly, ideological corruption cannot be removed by a few individual good deeds. Some ideologies become the cause of corruption and have no power of reform within them. So ideological reform is necessary; without it no guarantee of a better future can be given for mankind generally. All present-day modern reform movements are based first on ideologies: ideological reform comes first, then those ideas are moulded into action, and then a better, new nation grows. This is a very vast subject; it cannot be pursued at the individual level.