6. The question has two parts: did all previous religions declare their teaching to be the last and final one? And, while believing in evolution themselves, did they foretell a point for spiritual progress at which mankind would gather and achieve the purpose of human creation?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 February 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The question has two parts: did all previous religions declare their teaching to be the last and final one? And, while believing in evolution themselves, did they foretell a point for spiritual progress at which mankind would gather and achieve the purpose of human creation?
Regarding the first part: apart from the Holy Qur’an, we do not find this claim in any other religion, in any spiritual or religious book, that it is the last book in which the Shariah has been completed. Followers of these religions today do claim that theirs is the last, but their book is silent. Therefore, in the magnificent service the Promised Messiah (as) rendered to Islam, this was a basic principle he presented. Before that no one had confronted other religions in this way; hence it had a great impact in that era on Muslims and Muslim scholars that this is an entirely new method of Jihad, of intellectual Jihad, which had not existed before. He first laid down principles, rationally proved their superiority, and compelled the opponent either first to prove these principles wrong or to accept them; so he had to take an inferior position against Islam. One of these principles was: we all make claims in praise of our religion, but the condition is that we should not be the ones saying it about the religion – the basic revealed book of the religion itself must say it; if the revealed book does not make the claim and we attribute it to it, then the saying applies: the Pir does not fly, the disciples make him fly – which is unreasonable. When this was said to the Aryas, Sanatan Dharmis, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians and others, their great claims shrank completely and their power to compete ended. For example, when the Aryas were told: you claim your religion is the standard-bearer of the Unity of God, and that it is a lie that there is idol worship in Hinduism, that Aryas are monotheists – very good, but first show it from your book, from the Vedas; if the claim is there we will listen, otherwise you steal from Islam and attribute it to your religion – what decency is this? On this they were utterly defeated. The Christians had big claims, for instance of being the last book and so on. He said: prove it; you say Christianity is a universal religion – first show the claim from the book: where is it written that Christianity, or Judaism, is a universal religion? Then the discussion will proceed. This was a very important service to Islam that the Promised Messiah (as) rendered by presenting this basic principle, whereby debates were narrowed and turned towards principles. On the second part (the questioner reads it again; Huzur asks in what sense evolution): every religion, at the time it was revealed, was the latest compared to the older one. The latest will consider itself good and will indeed be good. You never see a new model come and ignore the good things already invented and repeat old mistakes. This is always seen in human progress, including the world of religion: if a version is truly from God and the latest, it will be the best at its time, free of the old errors that some people introduced, and in some cases it will make new additions to the teaching that enhance its beauty. So every religion, compared to its predecessor, is the most beautiful, and compared to what comes after it, it automatically takes a lower rank. Now the basic question is: will this series continue till the Day of Judgement, must a better religion necessarily come after each one, or should the series have stopped somewhere? This is a rational question. The Holy Qur’an has answered it by drawing attention to certain basic matters. That is why the Holy Qur’an repeatedly points to the changing forms of the child in the womb and wants to show that there is evolution, but there is also a culmination of evolution, a point towards which evolution moves, and once it reaches it, it stops advancing. Everything has a blueprint and a design. From the light Allah has shed in various verses of the Holy Qur’an, this picture emerges: just as in the creation of the universe Allah established the principle that everything is moving towards the higher, but that higher had a predetermined design which was completed in man – that is why the Holy Qur’an repeatedly uses the word ‘sawwahu’: in man We perfected creation. When man came into being, the final purpose was fulfilled; after that there was no need to advance it further. In the world of religion too, the Holy Qur’an shows that in all ages, in every region of the earth, religions arose and began to advance in one direction, one better after another, until the Holy Qur’an says: today religion has been perfected – ‘Al-yauma akmaltu lakum dinakum wa atmamtu ‘alaikum ni‘mati wa raditu lakumul-Islama dina’. Exactly the same pattern was repeated in a short period which God had adopted over a long period for the development of life, or an even longer one for the development of the universe. The design is the same, the hand is the same. In this the unity of religion is also seen: there is one Creator, who creates the material world, takes life through various phases, and creates the religious world; it is the same design, and His indelible, recognisable imprint is on it. Seen in this way, the question necessarily arises: which, then, is the last religion? One must accept a last one, otherwise there is no design. Rationally two basic questions arise: has the last religion come or is the series still continuing? And if it has come, how do we know that a particular religion is the last? On the first, we begin to examine the books of religions: if a last religion had come, it would be such a great event that it should have said that it is the last. For the last religion to come secretly, with nobody, not even its followers, knowing, would be foolish; it cannot be attributed to God. In this enquiry the Promised Messiah (as) presented to the world this magnificent principle: examine all the books of the world – not a single one claims to be the last and perfect. When the claim itself does not exist, it is clear that apart from Islam none of the existing religions is the last. In the Holy Qur’an the claim exists, and not only that, there are arguments which no one in the world can refute. For instance, one argument the Holy Qur’an gives: if it is the last religion, the book of the last religion must be protected; otherwise, if it is the last and begins to be corrupted and altered, everything would be ruined. It says: look at all past books; they were corrupted and abandoned – like roads that were repaired for a while, then repairs stopped and they fell apart; the original of those books did not survive. The Holy Qur’an claimed at that time: I am the last, and I tell you right now one proof of this: this book is protected; it will remain till the Day of Judgement and will not change. The claim of a religion for whose protection God made this arrangement, and announced at the outset that it would continue, acquires extraordinary importance. So it was proved from one aspect. The second aspect is: what should be the relationship between the last religion and the earlier ones? Man should investigate this rationally: if human progress continues in every other field – civilisation, culture, science, politics, society – why should we, in religion, consider a religion revealed 1400 years ago to be the last? There must be a principle that satisfies the heart that a final teaching can come which time cannot change. Until we answer this basic question, the Holy Qur’an’s claim I mentioned and its being protected are not sufficient. Whoever believes in the Holy Qur’an will be pleased, but whoever does not will not be satisfied: perhaps it was preserved; even today books get preserved; the Holy Qur’an happened to come in such an age. For finality, further arguments satisfying reason are needed; if you do not give them, you will have to listen to Bahaism and the voices of other emerging religions. For this too the Holy Qur’an presented principles and kept presenting arguments in their support. One basic principle the Holy Qur’an presented is: ‘Ma nansakh min ayatin au nunsiha na’ti bi-khairin minha au mithliha’ – whatever verse We abrogate – here verse means divine commandments, as in ‘yatlu ‘alaihim ayatihi’, i.e. the revelation of Shariah, of teaching. It says: We have made a principle, and no better principle can be presented: when We bring a new religion in place of one, a new teaching in place of one, there are two motives behind it. First, that people have forgotten that teaching and it has been erased from memory; then the least right man has is that We bring it to light again and restore it. Second, if a teaching is imperfect with regard to the age, then We bring a better teaching to complete it. Apart from these two there is no justification for changing religion: either its followers changed the religion themselves, or God decided that man has moved ahead and religion therefore needs to be changed. This is an unchangeable principle against which we shall test the teaching of the Holy Qur’an. As for the first, forgetting (nunsiha), I have already said that by making the Holy Qur’an unchangeable, God ended that reason; there is no room for it. As for a better teaching, the Holy Qur’an answers: We have perfected the teaching; examine it from this viewpoint; nothing can be added to the perfect. Progress is a step towards perfection, but once perfection is attained, there can be no further perfection above it. In what sense perfection has been attained is still a wide-open question, not easy to answer or understand, because someone can still say: the Holy Qur’an claims perfection, but how can we accept it, man has moved ahead. The Holy Qur’an has answered this not in direct relation but in separate places, from which an overall picture emerges: it says this religion is connected with human nature (Fitrah). If a religion’s foundations lie in human nature and nature does not change, the religion cannot change; if the requirements of nature change, it will necessarily have to change. So this is perfection in relation to nature, and nature is timeless. If nature does not change, the basic principles by which man proposes various paths for nature cannot change. I will explain this further. First I raise an objection myself: every religion will claim, oh, so that was it – then our religion too was in accordance with nature, just like the Holy Qur’an; so why were earlier religions changed if they too were natural? And if they were not natural, why did Allah give man an unnatural religion? Then you would shake faith in God Himself while trying to bring people to Islam. Hence this claim needs to be examined more broadly, until the truth of the Holy Qur’an is rooted within nature; then we will be safe. Without doubt every religion is in accordance with nature, but there can be a complete teaching in accordance with nature and an incomplete teaching in accordance with nature – both are possible. The Holy Qur’an’s claim is not merely that it is natural, but that it is the complete teaching according to nature. To understand this we must look at the evolution of teachings in historical perspective, and on reaching Islam see whether any room remains, whether Islam has fulfilled all the requirements of nature, whereas earlier only some were fulfilled. No teaching was unnatural; you cannot claim earlier teachings were unnatural. The only difference is that the Holy Qur’an claims it too is natural, but completely natural; Judaism and Christianity were teachings related to nature but incomplete, not unnatural. I will give an illustration, one the Promised Messiah (as) also stressed greatly, which makes it understood very quickly: Allah commanded Moses (as) to emphasise retribution; his people could not be revived until they were given the teaching of retribution with great zeal. Why? Historically, the people of Moses had for centuries been the target of the Pharaohs’ oppression, until they became utterly devoid of honour and shame and so cowardly – just as when the English had subjugated our country for only a hundred years, people in the villages would start trembling at the sight of an Englishman, their hearts would sink; an English Deputy Commissioner would walk alone and the masses dared not raise a hand – such was the awe. Hindu rulers oppressed the Kashmiris for some time; the same Kashmiri who outside becomes the bravest and most combative, became so humiliated in his own country that he became the image of cowardice. That was the state of Moses’ people. Had God told them to forgive, that forgiveness is better, out of cowardice they would just have kept forgiving; the thought of claiming their right did not exist in their hearts. There is an anecdote about a Kashmiri of that era of rulers: someone asked him why he was so fearful. He said: you don’t understand, I am not a coward; when I see a strong person I feel great pity, and when I see a weak person I become very angry; so I am brave, but against the weak, and against the strong I feel pity. That is unnatural; to make it natural it needed reversing, to arouse anger at the sight of the strong. So God gave Moses the teaching to emphasise retribution; he stressed it so much that he took away from them the right to forgive. Now they were compelled by God to reclaim their rights and return to the lost human value of which they had long been deprived. Who can call this teaching unnatural? In historical perspective it is natural, relative to that age, but not a complete natural teaching. It continued for a period in which reform progressed; they became brave and hard, and then like a pendulum swung past the middle; the momentum grew so strong that they became so hard-hearted that they decided to put on the cross an innocent prophet whose very teaching was love. Their cruelty and harshness had reached this point. The Holy Qur’an says repeatedly: ‘Thumma qasat qulubukum’ – then your hearts hardened, became like stone; they committed extreme cruelties on their own and on others. Had they then been taught: you may take revenge, but also forgive, they would never have turned towards forgiveness. Their direction towards revenge had set so firmly, like grooves on a road into which tyres run by themselves; such grooves of cruelty were on their hearts. At that time the natural teaching was the one the Messiah gave: he took away from them the right of revenge, for God knew that if given it they would take revenge. So for their reform they were put in quarantine for a while: you must only forgive, and that the utmost forgiveness – if slapped on one cheek, turn the other too. Thus they were rectified. Meanwhile man progressed and reached a particular stage, maturity. The last religion, which was to gather the whole world under one banner, appeared. What new thing did it bring into this teaching so that we can say the natural teaching was completed? It said: everyone has the right of retribution, but no right of transgression; take only as much revenge as the wrong done to you, not a particle more. But forgiveness is better – and not only that, it said: ‘Fa-man ‘afa wa aslaha fa-ajruhu ‘alallah’ – whoever forgives on the condition that his forgiveness brings about reform and does not embolden the offender, only he is permitted to forgive, and for him forgiveness is better. This is called the completion of natural teaching. Place this teaching before all the intellectuals of today’s world and say: make a slight improvement in it; times have changed, this teaching is 1400 years old; reform it a little for the modern age. I raised this question especially before Christians, in America with some very prominent clergymen who were also held in great esteem; I spoke with them and put this very simple question: try hard, if not today then tomorrow or the day after, consult as much as you like, show some addition or amendment to this teaching of Islam, so that if it has remained in the old age it may conform to the new. No one ever answered, nor can anyone today. A claim whose proof is so decisive that it shines like the sun, and no one dares change it, and wherever someone changes it he suffers. If you apply this principle to every path of teaching and compare with past religions until you reach the Holy Qur’an, exactly this picture will emerge: no change is possible; wherever someone changes it, experience will show that he has suffered loss.