3. (Partly unintelligible) I am asking basically in general, but especially because an article I read claimed that Islam led to disintegration.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 February 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: (Partly unintelligible) I am asking basically in general, but especially because an article I read claimed that Islam led to disintegration.

When the Holy Prophet (saw) came, all of Arabia was divided; every tribe was fighting the other. Islam was the first thing to unite the Arabs upon one faith. Even when disputes arose among them after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw), the condition was still a hundredfold better than before. Compare the pre-Islamic period with the post-Islamic period, then you will know whether the claim is true or false. They paint a picture which I will not call fictitious, but one that leaves out the perspective, deliberately, to deceive. They start from the point where, after the Holy Prophet (saw), disputes and fighting began among the Muslims, and say: look, this is disintegration. One should begin from when Islam had not yet come. Had there been unity before Islam and had it been broken after Islam came, Islam would bear all the responsibility. But they do not begin where they should. When Islam came, Arabia was completely fragmented, every household divided. Islam united them, and after the Holy Prophet (saw) passed away, Islam did not remain quite as it was in his presence – that is the real picture. It means that Islam played the greatest role in integration, and the Holy Prophet (saw) played the most important role in sustaining that role; the difference between his presence and absence had to show. To bring those tribes that had been fighting for thousands of years, in the Arabian Peninsula where there had never been peace and never a stable government, under one strong hand within a few years – that was the extraordinary integrating force of Islam. But psychologically it is impossible for the nature of peoples to change all at once. When the Holy Prophet (saw) passed away, the old veins stirred again: feudalism, mutual fighting and so on had been suppressed, not killed. The later struggle of non-Islamic forces to re-emerge was a struggle against the integration created by the integrating force, and Islam prevailed over it. That is the true perspective. Against the integration Islam had established, the very forces that had earlier disintegrated Arabia tried again to create disintegration; all that feudalism reawakened. They themselves have to admit that this was not an Islamic force but an anti-Islamic one. Making a claim with closed eyes is not reasonable. Truth and good sense demand an analysis of who was responsible for integration and who for disintegration. Nowhere did Islam play the role of disintegration. The last sermon of the Holy Prophet (saw), the sermon of the Farewell Pilgrimage (Hajjatul-Wida), is Islam; that was the message to Arabia. If disintegration resulted from that message, Islam is responsible. If it resulted from ignoring it, Islam cannot be responsible; rather the opposition to it is. As for the rest of Islam’s spread, there are two parts: one where it spread through Tabligh, and one where not Islam but its political influence spread. Wherever that happened, integration came along with it. Even in the Christian countries that came under the rule of Islamic polity, the people were not forcibly made Muslims, but were united and their rights so secured that when hostile powers – for instance the Eastern Christian Empire of Constantinople – recaptured those places, whole cities wept because just, equitable rulers who made society one were departing from them, even though their own co-religionists were arriving and they were parting from their apparent religious opponents. So Islam played an integrating role everywhere. And in Spain their own histories tell it, for example Lane-Poole and many other writers. Whichever book you pick up, they begin by saying that when Islam came, Spanish society and politics were disintegrating, and that Islam integrated it, laid the foundation of a stable government, and that all civilisation and the growth of all sciences resulted from Islam’s stability. This integration was not limited to Muslims but extended to all communities – another aspect. Jews, Christians and Muslims were politically integrated in such a way that nobody was wronged because of religious difference and nobody was deprived of any right. Jointly they all took part in building the country; that is why the history of Spain became the cause of the revival of learning in Europe, what is called the Renaissance, which began from Spain. So it integrated where there was a government, and where there was none it brought integration through the Renaissance and played a great role in bringing societies together. Factually this allegation is so false and baseless that there is no truth in it. Without quoting Islamic historians, you can refute their allegation by quoting their own historians.

10 of 10 left today