4. (Partly unintelligible) Yes, please. … Regarding Islamic ijtihad … Ijtihad causes harm, but if the one exercising ijtihad is upright … (question whether ijtihad is needed when Islam is complete).

Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 February 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: (Partly unintelligible) Yes, please. … Regarding Islamic ijtihad … Ijtihad causes harm, but if the one exercising ijtihad is upright … (question whether ijtihad is needed when Islam is complete).

Ijtihad is extremely necessary for the growth of intellect and the development of the mind. Without it thoughts would become rigid, man would be mentally imprisoned and all paths of progress would be blocked. It is ijtihad that keeps taking man forward step by step with time. But if the mujtahid himself becomes dishonest and begins to exercise ijtihad for his own selfish ends, then Islam has nothing to do with it – whether he does so in science, in politics, in Hinduism or in the same religion, he will cause harm. Not ijtihad, but crooked thinking and dishonest intentions cause harm. (On whether ijtihad is needed only when something is incomplete:) A complete thing is a different matter. When every complete thing operates in its time, the time changes; the complete thing itself does not change. Islam came 1400 years ago, but man is not at the same stage as when the Holy Prophet (saw) came. The complete thing, with the mould of each age, accepts a challenge to solve new problems, and that is what is called ijtihad.

10 of 10 left today