2. There are two questions from the Leicester group. My guests are not asking them themselves but have asked me to. The two questions do not concern our basic beliefs, the beliefs of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat; they are general questions. The first is: there are many other sects in Islam, and some have very strange beliefs. Why does everyone leave them all aside and no one looks at them? Why is only the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat persecuted, and all unite in opposition against it? What is your view and answer on this?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 February 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: There are two questions from the Leicester group. My guests are not asking them themselves but have asked me to. The two questions do not concern our basic beliefs, the beliefs of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat; they are general questions. The first is: there are many other sects in Islam, and some have very strange beliefs. Why does everyone leave them all aside and no one looks at them? Why is only the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat persecuted, and all unite in opposition against it? What is your view and answer on this?

As far as the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, that is our faith, is concerned, the short answer is that this strengthens our faith. For according to the history of religions preserved by the Holy Qur’an, whenever someone is sent by God, all unite in opposing him, even if they differ among themselves, and you will see no change in this history. Thus the Holy Qur’an says: “Tahsabuhum jami‘an wa qulubuhum shatta” – O Muhammad (saw), as far as opposition to you is concerned, they have all united; as far as their own state is concerned, their hearts are divided. Otherwise they have not united, can never unite and never have united, but in opposing you they have united. In this human custom you will never see any change. Therefore the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, seeing this state, gains further strength and sees in it a magnificent sign of its truthfulness: if ever until today the other sects of the Muslims have forgotten their mutual differences and agreed against one sect, it is against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat – despite the fact that far sharper differences, in belief and in practice, exist between various sects than those we have with individual sects or with them collectively. It is wrong to say there was no opposition against the others; probably the questioner is not aware of history. There certainly was opposition. In one era the Muslims of India were after the Wahhabis, and they were vehemently opposed. Sometimes they were after the Shias; where the Shias held power, they confronted the Sunnis. But generally the polarisation has been that certain sects went after certain others; that is the summary of history. But that there should be a universal consensus against one sect – this has never happened. This is such a distinguishing feature that our opponents themselves sensed it during the questioning in the National Assembly and presented it as an important question. Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh), the Khalifa before me, had been called to the National Assembly to answer questions; I was with him, he had included me. A Maulvi stood up and strongly stressed this point, or perhaps the Attorney General did, since most questions were put by the Attorney General, though at the end some clerics also asked; it is not clear to me now who raised this question, but it was raised forcefully and is on record. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat had argued: you have fundamental differences with the other sects too, yet you consider them Muslims and have turned against us; there are fatwas of disbelief against them and you ignore them; it is against righteousness to see disbelief in the others, leave them alone, and pick one sect for opposition. In reply they asked a counter-question: we know about our mutual oppositions, but until today there has never been a consensus in the Umma of Muhammad against one sect, and a consensus has formed against you that you are disbelievers and outside Islam. Otherwise some sects consider some others so, and vice versa; this has always gone on. But show us that such a consensus ever happened. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat affirmed: this historical fact is entirely true and exactly in accordance with this verse: “Tahsabuhum jami‘an” – a consensus has indeed formed; “wa qulubuhum shatta” – but among yourselves you are divided. A consensus has formed in opposition to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Regarding this consensus, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat presented this position: this consensus is mentioned in the Ahadith. You will not accept our words, but if you have true love and devotion for Hazrat Aqdas Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and truly claim to be his servants, then reflect in this light on this Hadith, what the reality of your consensus is. On one occasion the Holy Prophet (saw) mentioned the division of his Umma and said with great pain: just as the Jews split into 72 sects, my Umma too will break apart and be divided into 72 sects. Then he said there will be one community, a seventy-third, and apart from that community, “kulluhum fi-n-nar” – all the other sects will be in the Fire. This does not mean, God forbid, that every Muslim belonging to other sects will go to Hell. It is an expression of the displeasure of the Holy Prophet (saw), to show that they did not remain true Muslims. In this two magnificent things were stated. First: against those who claim the great majority (Sawad-e-A‘zam) – that because the majority has decided, it must be true – there is a verdict of the Holy Prophet (saw) that there is no basis at all for the majority’s decision being true. Rather, of 73 he called one the community, the one to come later, and declared the 72 far from the truth, deviated from it. He put the 72 on one side, in one bag, and the one in another bag, and distinguished between them. Now the question arose: what is the standing of the 72 against the one? Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh), with great courtesy, requested and drew the attention of the members of the Assembly: do not, living under a Muslim government in a country obtained in the name of Islam, in your own Assembly, rebel against the verdict of the Holy Prophet (saw). God will not approve of this; you will be punished for it. You can say: these are the 72, and in our view those are the one. But you cannot say the one is false and the 72 true, because the verdict of the Messenger of Allah (saw) contrasts the 72 with the one and calls the 72 false and the one true. You can say: if you, being among the 72, want to call us false, then count us within the majority and call us false. You have no right to exclude us from the majority and call us false. In this matter your verdict will not prevail, even if all 72 gather to decide; the verdict of the Messenger of Allah (saw) will prevail. Yes, with your own hand you have written your destiny: that you are the 72 and these are the one. With this decision you are committing suicide. He repeatedly drew their attention: look, I advise you again, at least take a lesson from Shia Iran. Shia Iran did not decide that the 72 are true and the one false; they said the 72 are false and only the Shias are true, and thereby defined Muslims as those who are Shia. So in Iran there is only one Islam, Shia Islam; they do not recognise any other Islam; legally no one except a Shia can be considered a Muslim, whoever falls in the definition. He said: it may be wrong, you need not accept it, but it is not rebellion, because the verdict of the Messenger of Allah (saw) is precisely this: where 72 are on one side and one on the other, you cannot call the 72 true and the one false. Now let us develop this discussion further; there, after this much discussion, he had concluded the matter with a ruling. From whichever angle you look, ever new and delightful themes emerge in favour of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. One is this: about these 72, the Assembly announced, and newspapers carried headlines, that the 72 sects of Islam have unanimously thrown the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat out of the fold of Islam. These printed Pakistani newspapers exist; in our library they are with these headlines, the word “72” written on top. God’s decree caused it to be written. Later they regretted it and began asking us, saying there were not 72 at all. But Allah’s decree had come into effect; it had all been printed on that decision. Let us go further. Among the 72 there were people whose belief was to ask from graves, visit them, and believe that the souls of those buried there are present at the graves, respond and help with whatever is asked. People of this belief were among the 72, who believe that the Holy Prophet (saw) is omnipresent and all-seeing, a partner with God in this, also in knowledge of the unseen, and that whenever he is mentioned he comes and is present; hence the command to stand during the Maulud. And there were people of the belief that whoever holds this belief is an outright disbeliever, polytheist and outside Islam. And there were people of the belief that whoever does not hold this belief is an outright disbeliever, polytheist, outside Islam, disbeliever and Kharijite, and whatever else, has nothing to do with Islam. That day both together decided: we are Muslims, and the Ahmadis are liars and outside Islam. Where is righteousness left in this decision? With such fundamental difference, permitting the stamp of Islam means that now contradictory beliefs can be held at the same time within Islam: in Islam it is permitted to commit shirk; in Islam it is permitted to declare the polytheist a dweller of Hell and Fire; and it is permitted not to commit shirk and to declare one who does not a polytheist, of Hell and the Fire – all this is Islam. According to this decision, it also became Islam that Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra) was a usurper, God forbid, not only a usurper but a hypocrite, the chief of hypocrites, and that after the Holy Prophet (saw), apart from the ten given glad tidings of Paradise, no Muslim remained, all Arabia became hypocritical and a hypocritical Khilafat was founded. That day it was decided that this too is a genuine Muslim belief. And it was also decided that whoever considers this belief false and accursed and thinks it is an injustice, the extreme, that a Siddiq should be declared a hypocrite, indeed the chief of hypocrites, a great injustice – he too is a genuine Muslim. It was also decided that today those are genuine Muslims who say that Hazrat Gabriel was to bring the Holy Qur’an to Hazrat Ali (ra), the revelation was to descend upon him, but he closely resembled the Holy Prophet (saw), so Gabriel made a mistake and the Holy Qur’an was delivered by mistake to the Messenger of Allah (saw); but since it had happened, it perforce continued. That day it was decided that these too are not outside Islam but entirely genuine and staunch Muslims; and that those too are genuine Muslims who think this is blasphemy against God, Gabriel and the Messenger of Allah (saw) and tantamount to disbelief; no one has the right to judge against them. If they go to get an identity card made, issue it at once; there is no disbelief involved. That day it was decided that those who hold that in the Kalima “La ilaha illallah” it is not enough to say “Muhammadur Rasulullah” but saying “Aliyyun Waliyyullah” is necessary are Muslims, and those too who consider this disbelief. What a magnificent consensus! Then that day it was decided that those who say the Holy Qur’an consists of the thirty parts that have reached us are genuine Muslims, and also those who say: no, there were forty parts, ten were lost, and in them the testament of Hazrat Ali, his Walayat and the Khilafat were mentioned and the state of the hypocrites described; a goat ate them or whatever happened, someone lost them. They say these too are genuine Muslims, perfectly fine: that there is no change in the Holy Qur’an is correct, and that there was change in the Holy Qur’an is also correct. On all of this the stamp was put that day, testimony was given to “wa qulubuhum shatta”, and it was declared that now in the bag of Islam all these contradictory things can live together at one time. And that day it was also decided that the Kalima revealed to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), which from the first day was an effective procedure and sufficient for becoming Muslim, was incomplete for making Muslims until the definitive denial of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad is included in this Kalima; until then no one can become a Muslim. So the definition was not completed when Islam was completed. It was decided that one part of Islam had remained incomplete, this Kalima, and today the clerics of Pakistan have completed it, adding to the definition, to the Kalima, that now to make a Muslim, the confession of servitude to Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), is not enough; the denial of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad must also necessarily be included. A new Kalima came, and all said: perfectly right. And they did not consider that a definition never changes; neither time nor geography can change it. Whatever definition of man you take, it will apply to the first man, whether he was African or wherever he was born, and to the last one dying, whether believer or disbeliever, whoever. (Interruption: What is happening? All right, switch it off.) So that day it was also decided that this Kalima was incomplete and has now become complete. And these definers did not consider: if this is a false prophet who made a false claim, and therefore this became necessary – then in the lifetime of the Holy Prophet (saw) there was a false prophet, a false claimant, not one but two, and even three are mentioned, Aswad Ansi and another, and after his demise many arose. Yet neither he, nor Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra), nor any other Khalifa, nor any Sunni, nor any Shia ever touched the definition of the Kalima and added that you will be Muslim only if you deny so-and-so, otherwise not. Nowhere was a denial included. So the Islam that in their view was incomplete remained incomplete even in the time of the Messenger of Allah (saw), God forbid, because if the fundamental is incomplete, its foundation is incomplete too – and it was given completion. The consensus is purely on denial; apart from that there is no consensus. “Qulubuhum shatta” remains in place; they reached an accord on this and agreed on denying one person. What more definitive proof of the truth of Ahmadiyyat could anyone want? This happens to the truthful. Had they been truthful, they would never have compromised on matters that were their fundamental differences. Righteousness demanded that if yesterday they called the holders of that belief non-Muslims and disbelievers, they should have kept doing so and said that one more had been added. Had anyone said this, he would have had the right to differ, and no one could have declared him a rebel against the Messenger of Allah or against Islam. But now, by saying this, they have become rebels. On that very occasion, when the Holy Prophet (saw) prophesied a gathering – that 72 would be on one side, as it were, and one on the other; this was a prophecy of consensus – immediately after this statement a questioner asked: O Messenger of Allah, this is a great trial, what will happen, how shall we recognise who that one is? A very important question: out of 72, indeed now 73 were to be – in the time of the Jews there were 72 – one is true and the rest false; this verdict is given by the leader of the Umma (saw), and the command is to accept the true one, otherwise you too will become false. How difficult! Had the Holy Prophet (saw) dragged it into arguments and said: study the Holy Qur’an, study Hadith, look at this and that, then most of the poor ignorant and weak ones, whom in Punjabi they call “mattar sattar”, these ordinary folk, would have been lost. How difficult a question! Ask any scholar today and he will be bewildered. But see the prophetic grandeur of Hazrat Aqdas Muhammad Mustafa (saw), what a clear mind God had given him; he made the most difficult matter easy. He replied: what is difficult about it? “Ma ana ‘alaihi wa ashabi” – the way to recognise the true one is: the state I and my Companions are in, that will be the state of the true sect that comes in that age. Seeing a state is not difficult. Deriving arguments and understanding logical intricacies is difficult, but the outward states that peoples pass through are not difficult to recognise. What the state of the Holy Prophet (saw) and his servants was, no Muslim has any room for doubt. Educated or uneducated, he knows that those who recited the Kalima were dragged through the streets, punished, deprived of the right to recite the Kalima. Only then were Bilals born, only then were those magnificent women born who were made to stand in the sun, made to wear coats of mail, tormented in the heat and killed; dragged through the streets like dogs – this is how Muslims were treated for the crime of reciting the Kalima. Was this their state or not? It was entirely manifest. They were stopped from building mosques; mosques were demolished even inside homes. Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra), since it was not permitted outside, built a mosque in the courtyard of his house. People stormed in: what right do you have to worship God, you filthy impure ones! and wiped out that mosque. He (saw) was stopped from Hajj, from his official duties of worship, to such an extent that the Holy Qur’an mentions it: what darkness, what injustice – “yanha ‘abdan idha salla” – there are wretched people who stop others from worship; a servant says, I am worshipping my Lord, and he says: what right do you have? We will stop you. All this treatment was meted out to the Holy Prophet (saw) and his servants. And it was declared that their wives had become unlawful to them, they had been divorced; whoever becomes Muslim, his marriage is automatically annulled; their children are deprived of inheriting from their parents; loot their houses, expel them from their homes, declare: now there is no room for you among us, we will annihilate you; either change your religion and come back to us, or you have no right to live in this land. From which Muslim is this fact hidden? Tell me today; educated or uneducated, everyone knows this was the treatment. And who has inflicted this treatment on the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat? One sect? Two sects? There was a consensus. As a result of this consensus, the Maulvis roam all over Pakistan with great pride, and come here and tell people here too: join us as well, what are you sitting here doing? It is such a meritorious, such a virtuous deed that we are stopping these wretched, impure ones from the Kalima, and you let them recite it! You too kill them, you too loot them! What right do they have to offer prayers? The right is ours, God is ours, not theirs. What right do they have to praise the Messenger of Allah (saw)? None; they are impure and filthy people. All the crimes that the enemies of Islam committed against the Holy Prophet (saw) and his servants are today committed by this assembly of the 72. And they have testified in courts that they know what they are doing; it is not that they are unaware. In the court in Quetta, when a mosque was demolished and Ahmadis were jailed for the crime of reciting the Kalima, the provincial president of their association, the association for the protection of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat, was giving a statement. The lawyer asked him: tell me, in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw), who used to do all this that you are now doing to the Ahmadis? The answer was: the polytheists used to do exactly this to Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), and his companions. This is recorded in court. So what room for doubt remains? In my view, this event, which they consider the most splendid event for refuting Ahmadiyyat, is the clearest and brightest proof of the truth of Ahmadiyyat that could be presented. For the truthfulness of the Messenger of Allah (saw) has also become linked with it: his prophecy has been fulfilled, fulfilled in every respect, in every aspect. There is now no dispute about it, scholar or not; the matter has become plain before everyone.

10 of 10 left today