3. Hudhur, if a second question is permitted: the Banu Umayya introduced kingship in Islam. Hudhur is requested to guide us: after the Banu Umayya, did anyone, whether called caliph or ruler, in any way restore the era of the Rightly Guided Khilafat?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 February 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Hudhur, if a second question is permitted: the Banu Umayya introduced kingship in Islam. Hudhur is requested to guide us: after the Banu Umayya, did anyone, whether called caliph or ruler, in any way restore the era of the Rightly Guided Khilafat?
What is the definition of the Rightly Guided Khilafat? Tell me that first, then I will tell you whether it was restored or not. [Questioner: The definition, Hudhur: after the Holy Prophet (saw), the era of the four caliphs up to Hazrat Ali is called the Rightly Guided Khilafat.] How can anyone restore that after them? How can anyone restore an era, that is, a similar era? How can anyone establish a Khilafat that was granted through the Holy Prophet (saw)? [Questioner: In a spiritual manner, Hudhur, not exactly the same – in the spirit, in the spirit of that.] That is not within man’s power at all. Unless there is prophethood, there can be no Khilafat. And if the Khilafat after prophethood breaks, Allah can bring it about directly; man has no right at all to make a caliph. God makes the caliph. And when He establishes a system, the caliph who comes about through that system is made by God. When it breaks, is cut off, no human has the authority to restore it – just as when the soul has left a person, no one can put it back in. Breathing in the spirit is Allah’s work. And when He made Adam caliph, God laid this subject open: when We made Adam caliph, We breathed Our spirit into him; then he became caliph; and until He breathed the spirit, He commanded no one to obey him. Read the Holy Qur’an: everywhere it is mentioned, the breathing of the spirit is mentioned before the command of obedience. Unless the spirit is breathed in by Allah, the first caliph, who is called a prophet, cannot come into being, and unless the spirit comes, the progeny does not continue. Khilafat is a spiritual progeny, which must be preceded by the act of Allah breathing His spirit. When it is cut off, that Khilafat cannot continue until God breathes the spirit again. That is why kingship came about; a caliph in that sense could not come then. But figuratively – if you ask figuratively – all the Mujaddids (reformers) were caliphs in a figurative sense, i.e. they worked to some extent as God’s deputies, in the light of Allah’s guidance; theirs was a reflective (zilli) Khilafat. That can be said.