4. Question about the tradition that Muslims will resemble the Jews and that the Jews split into 72 and the Muslims into 73 sects; the book “Al-Milal wan-Nihal” is mentioned. Since sects are counted differently at different times (72, 73, 74, 76 and so on), how is the statement of this tradition to be understood? Also: the Ahl-e-Sunnat wal-Jamaat and the Ahl-e-Hadith – did the Ahl-e-Sunnat use the word “Jamaat” to present themselves as the promised Jamaat?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 February 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: Question about the tradition that Muslims will resemble the Jews and that the Jews split into 72 and the Muslims into 73 sects; the book “Al-Milal wan-Nihal” is mentioned. Since sects are counted differently at different times (72, 73, 74, 76 and so on), how is the statement of this tradition to be understood? Also: the Ahl-e-Sunnat wal-Jamaat and the Ahl-e-Hadith – did the Ahl-e-Sunnat use the word “Jamaat” to present themselves as the promised Jamaat?

[Opening of the answer not intelligibly transcribed.] … Sometimes in Arabic the words seventy, seventy-two, eighty and similar words were used to indicate a multitude, and it was not meant that exactly eighty, seventy-two or seventy years would be counted. The number is also used apart from years: it is said Allah will send down mercy seventy times, will forgive seventy times. That does not mean Allah forgives exactly seventy times by count; these are merely idioms that in reality point to multitude. You cannot prove it by exact counting. Another aspect, as I indicated: if sects increase, some also disappear; it is a constant process. So it is quite possible that at one time seventy-two exist, actually seventy-two exist, but we do not have the ability to count them and demonstrate it, since some are arising and some are vanishing. Therefore this debate is futile; one should not get into it. What matters is whether there has been a multitude of sects and whether it has split as it did with the Jews. If this multitude is not enough for someone to see that the time for the fulfilment of the hadith has come, and he insists on seventy-two, then that Jamaat can never come into the world, because it has already gone beyond seventy-two; there may even be more than eighty. When things have reached this point, you should ask the one counting: has your Jamaat come then? If it is to come only after seventy-two, and you put the burden on us to count out seventy-two, then count for yourselves – the matter has gone far beyond seventy-two, and that Jamaat has not come. And if it has not come by now, when will it come? Whenever someone then comes and forms a Jamaat, you will ask him the same question: count out seventy-two. So you will never be able to find guidance. Therefore the word seventy-two is not important. The important part is: when there is disagreement and more than one sect, the sect whose conditions match those of the Holy Prophet (saw) and his Companions is the true one. That is its lesson. And what those conditions are, I have already explained to you; they are recognisable, it is not difficult for anyone. As for the Ahl-e-Sunnat wal-Jamaat: they may have used the word to be seen as the coming Jamaat, but at the same time they also claim that they have existed from the beginning and did not arise after the seventy-two. The glad tidings of the Holy Prophet (saw) are for the Jamaat that arises after the seventy-two. So even if they attach the word Jamaat, they do not fall under this hadith. The glad tidings are that after the seventy-two have formed, a Jamaat will certainly arise, and that Jamaat will be true. But they say they have existed from the beginning in the form of a Jamaat. Then there is the definition of Jamaat: if someone calls himself a Jamaat, that does not make him one. What does Jamaat mean in Islamic terminology? The word Jamaat derives from jamiyyat (union), and for union, unity is necessary: one centre, one Imam. If someone does not have that, how will it become a Jamaat? Imamat or Khilafat is necessary for a Jamaat; without it a Jamaat can never come into being. So if a group calls itself a Jamaat but the imams of its mosques are independent, everyone states and imposes his own view, they are scattered and dispersed, and there is no collectivity, no unity, no single direction, no one Imam in whom they have full faith that he is God’s representative for them – how can a Jamaat exist without these signs? Therefore, those who call themselves Ahl-e-Sunnat wal-Jamaat – go and ask them: they are at odds with one another’s scholars, they have disagreements among themselves, and on fundamental issues, disagreements so fundamental that if one is true the other cannot possibly be. How then can they call themselves a Jamaat?

10 of 10 left today