8. Some friends who are not members of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat ask: it is the agreed belief of all Muslims, and also the belief of the Ahmadis, that Islam is a perfect and complete religion, that the Holy Qur’an is also a perfect teaching and is preserved exactly as it was in its original form; it is spiritually preserved and we can obtain guidance from it. What new thing did Hazrat Mirza Sahib bring after that, for which you ask people to accept him?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 February 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Some friends who are not members of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat ask: it is the agreed belief of all Muslims, and also the belief of the Ahmadis, that Islam is a perfect and complete religion, that the Holy Qur’an is also a perfect teaching and is preserved exactly as it was in its original form; it is spiritually preserved and we can obtain guidance from it. What new thing did Hazrat Mirza Sahib bring after that, for which you ask people to accept him?
If he had brought something new, he would not have been worthy of acceptance. They have not understood the point at all. When a religion is complete, nothing new can come, and whoever brings something new is a liar. So in effect they are saying: if he is a liar, then we will accept him. That is exactly what they say: show us something new and we will believe. But whoever brings something new after completion is certainly a liar. So they would accept him as a liar; as a truthful one they do not accept him. The fact is: the Holy Qur’an is complete. But it is the same Qur’an that existed in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw). The changes this Qur’an was producing then, it is not producing today. Why? Why, despite the same Qur’an, has the Muslim world outwardly split into seventy-two sects? Why today, in the presence of the same Qur’an, have so much oppression, dishonesty, immorality and godlessness spread? Why are they fighting one another today, declaring one another disbelievers, Muslims seizing Muslims alive and throwing them into fires, and all have fallen prey to hatred? Is it not the Holy Qur’an? The Holy Qur’an says that the servants of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), are such that they are firmly bound together like a wall. Have these statements – God forbid – become false? So it is not necessary that prophets or messengers from God bring a new law; rather, they come when laws are altered, when distortions are introduced into them, in order to bring them back. Thus the purpose of the coming of the Promised Messiah and Mahdi (as) is not to add to the Holy Qur’an – God forbid; if he added, he would necessarily be a liar. The purpose is to remove the false things attributed to the Holy Qur’an, or the additions that have entered the religion. He comes not to add but to remove additions. And we will show you the additions; if we cannot show them, then there is no need for him. The additions in the religion are so many that they strike the eye: they do not look like part of this building – why does it protrude so much? Look: despite the Holy Qur’an, grave-worship was declared permissible, and grave-worship was also declared shirk. Is that not a fundamental addition? If one is true Islam, the other is an addition. Despite the Holy Qur’an, the Holy Prophet (saw) was declared to be light (Nur) – that he had no body but was embodied light – and from the same Qur’an it is proven that whoever says this is an outright polytheist with no connection to Islam. And the other side says that whoever says he had a body and was not light is an outright disbeliever and heretic with no connection to Islam. Both at once cannot be Islam; both at once cannot be the teaching of the Holy Qur’an. Is this not a contradiction? Whichever you declare to be Islam, the other becomes an addition. So there are such fundamental differences that, in their light, countless additions have entered the perfect religion. To erase these additions, one was to come from God; his name is the Messiah. Another answer is this: the prophecies about the Messiah and Mahdi were not made up by the Ahmadis; they are prophecies of the Holy Prophet (saw). So if you do not want to accept Hazrat Mirza Sahib, then don't – but do you believe in the prophecies or not? And if you do, we put the same question to you: the Holy Qur’an was complete, so why did the Holy Prophet (saw) make prophecies about the Messiah and Mahdi? The one on whom the Holy Qur’an was revealed and completed is prophesying that despite this perfect religion one will come. And people coming fourteen hundred years later consider themselves wiser and say: no, there is no need for anyone to come, the religion is complete.