9. There are rules for prayer, fasting and other acts of worship. Huzur, please guide us whether there are also such fixed rules for supplication (Dua) which must be observed, or whether, even if these rules are not in the mind of the one praying, a supplication that comes from the heart can be effective. Please also explain: sometimes the purpose for which one prays is not soon fulfilled, or apparently no result appears. Should the one praying continue the supplication or exercise patience?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 22 February 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: There are rules for prayer, fasting and other acts of worship. Huzur, please guide us whether there are also such fixed rules for supplication (Dua) which must be observed, or whether, even if these rules are not in the mind of the one praying, a supplication that comes from the heart can be effective. Please also explain: sometimes the purpose for which one prays is not soon fulfilled, or apparently no result appears. Should the one praying continue the supplication or exercise patience?

This is a very short question about the nature of supplication. If there were rules for supplication of the kind you want to hear, life would become a torment; living would become difficult. The Holy Prophet (saw) taught a supplication for every circumstance: sleeping, waking, rising, sitting, before eating, after eating, during eating, putting on new clothes, morning and evening, entering the toilet, leaving it, entering the mosque, leaving it, putting on shoes. Is there a moment in life for which no supplication is prescribed? If on top of that there were rules without which the supplication would not be valid, man would be done for. Understand: how did you come to think there are rules for supplication? Supplication is a relationship between God and His servant, such as exists between master and servant, and it concerns the cry of the heart, which need not necessarily be put into words. There are many supplications in which some prophets ask only by way of hint and leave the rest to God, that He Himself give without being asked. The subject of supplication is so vast, as vast as life itself, and its kinds are so countless that rules cannot be made for them. What supplication did Moses (as) make? 'Rabbi inni lima anzalta ilayya min khairin faqir' – O Allah, I am a beggar; I do not ask with my mouth for what I want; whatever falls into my bag, pour in. What a wonderful prayer! Even a beggar who is sensible does not say 'give only money, nothing else', but rather: 'I am a petitioner; whatever you want to put in, put it in.' Then as alms one woman brings some flour, another a leftover piece of bread, another a whole leftover bread, another gives money. If even a human being is so affected by the plea of such a beggar when it is left to him – imagine what effect this prayer had on the One who owns the entire universe. Therefore God preserved this prayer with great love in the Holy Qur’an, so that the rest of the world might also benefit from it. He left it to Allah: what shall I tell You I need? You know my state, You see what state I am in; whatever is in Your power, in Your hand, and what You deem fit for me, grant it. So supplications have very wonderful hues; learn them from the Holy Qur’an and from Hadith. There is only one rule: the supplication must come from the truthfulness of the heart; beyond that there is no rule. What comes from the truthfulness of the heart and contains restlessness, that is supplication. And what comes from the lips out of habit, or what people recite from memory, is nothing; it has no reality in itself. Allah the Exalted says: 'Amman yujibul mudtarra' – I accept the plea of the distressed, I answer his prayer. Who is it that answers the prayer of the restless? Allah the Exalted attaches such importance to the prayer of the restless, and supplication is so deeply connected with restlessness, that we learn from the Holy Qur’an that even idolaters who spend their lives committing shirk, if once in distress they call on God with sincerity, Allah hears them too, because of their distress – and He knows that when they come back safe they will again do the same [shirk]. The Holy Qur’an has described this theme thus: sometimes people are travelling on the sea with a good wind, in a boat; suddenly the weather changes and a storm breaks out. Then some pray: O God, we call on You sincerely, save us. Allah does save them, but knows that when they reach dry land they will again commit shirk. So it is a matter of distress: the more intense the restlessness grows, the closer the mercy of Allah comes. This is the central point of supplication. As for the other details, there are no rules; they can neither be fixed nor can man be bound by them.

10 of 10 left today