7. (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh) translates the question asked in English.) The fundamental difference between the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat and other Islamic sects is that you accept Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani as Mahdi and Messiah. As far as we have heard about Islam and read about the prophecies of the one to come, we see no reason to believe in Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani, because there is a basic contradiction between those prophecies and his life. First: according to the prophecies, when the Mahdi comes he will fill the world with justice, justice will prevail everywhere and a wind of fairness will blow. Yet since Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani came, the world is just as full of oppression, tyranny and cruelty. Second: not only Muslims but also Christians and Jews believe that when the Messiah comes, the Day of Judgement (Qiyamat) will come along with him, as if joined to him, a short time after his coming – some say forty years, others mention another period. The Ahmadis themselves admit that almost a hundred years have passed since Mirza Sahib came and no Day of Judgement has come. In light of these two matters, what right do we have to consider Mirza Sahib truthful, or do you consider him truthful?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 March 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh) translates the question asked in English.) The fundamental difference between the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat and other Islamic sects is that you accept Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani as Mahdi and Messiah. As far as we have heard about Islam and read about the prophecies of the one to come, we see no reason to believe in Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani, because there is a basic contradiction between those prophecies and his life. First: according to the prophecies, when the Mahdi comes he will fill the world with justice, justice will prevail everywhere and a wind of fairness will blow. Yet since Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani came, the world is just as full of oppression, tyranny and cruelty. Second: not only Muslims but also Christians and Jews believe that when the Messiah comes, the Day of Judgement (Qiyamat) will come along with him, as if joined to him, a short time after his coming – some say forty years, others mention another period. The Ahmadis themselves admit that almost a hundred years have passed since Mirza Sahib came and no Day of Judgement has come. In light of these two matters, what right do we have to consider Mirza Sahib truthful, or do you consider him truthful?
This statement of theirs is entirely correct: the real difference is whether the Mahdi and Messiah promised to the Ummah have come and, if so, who he is. We say he has come, he was born in Qadian, his name was Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani, and he formed a community, which is us. The others say he was a liar, God did not send him. All other differences are offshoots of this one.
The answer is very extensive, but I will have to be brief, hint at some things and explain some in detail.
First: is it permissible to hold the belief that through the Messiah or Mahdi something will happen which God never enabled any prophet in the whole universe to do before? The one with the greatest power to establish justice was Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw); the Holy Qur’an was revealed to him, and we learned the meaning of justice from him. Despite this, more than fourteen hundred years have passed since his advent, and justice was not established in the way they attribute to the Mahdi. What then is the Mahdi, that he would suddenly come and establish justice in the world? In this sense, in our view, it is not possible, and it is disrespect towards the line of prophets and towards Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Hence there is a misunderstanding here. The fact is that nations remain deprived of recognising the truthful because they misunderstand their signs. If a man with a turban is to come and you are waiting for a bareheaded one, when the man with the turban comes you will say: you are not the one, we were told a bareheaded man would come. Likewise nations have always been deceived; they could not grasp the spiritual meaning of the signs, clung to the outward and were deceived. The whole history of the line of prophets bears witness to this. According to our Muslim belief the clearest signs concerned the Holy Prophet (saw); the Holy Qur’an says even his name had been recorded in earlier scriptures, and you read that name. Despite this they were deceived, because they had a different notion of how and from where he would come. They had made it a monopoly of the family of Hazrat Isaac; the idea of his coming from Ishmael did not even exist. So they were deceived. Therefore, try to understand the meaning of a prophecy against the background of religious history – not general history. If you expect something contrary to the practice of Allah and of the messengers, you will certainly fail.
Second: reflect for a minute. The Holy Qur’an says: “Whoever wishes, let him believe, and whoever wishes, let him disbelieve.” The Holy Qur’an shows repeatedly that man has been given free will; that is why he has the right to deny or not, and that is why there is reward and punishment. Without free will there is no question of reward and punishment. Now how will the Mahdi compel oppressors to justice? There are only two ways: either the Mahdi suddenly gains such great political power that he enforces justice by the sword, or he stuffs justice into hearts, which earlier prophets could not do. When the Holy Prophet (saw) desired that the whole world become Muslim, Allah addressed him in the Holy Qur’an: you wish it, fine, but Allah will not make anyone Muslim by force. How can the meaning of any Hadith be taken against this verse in the Holy Qur’an? How then will Allah force oppressors to justice, when the Holy Qur’an says that despite the wish of the Holy Prophet (saw) We will not guide those who do not want guidance? How will those so steeped in cruelty suddenly become just? Consider: even in the smallest state in the world there is so much injustice and cruelty today that to say the Imam Mahdi will come, say something and all will be put right is impossible without divine intervention – and God says He will not intervene in such matters, and the Holy Qur’an says so. Hence the principle: every Hadith that clearly appears to clash with the Holy Qur’an is either not the word of the Holy Prophet (saw) at all, or you have misunderstood its meaning; reflect again and derive a meaning that agrees with the Holy Qur’an.
Another aspect – I am not explaining it in much detail: the Imam Mahdi filling the world with justice can have two meanings. The one by force, as I said, is utterly impossible. The other: after the appearance of the Imam Mahdi, God will set a spirit of justice blowing in that age. Those who previously behaved oppressively in matters of human justice or did not know the value of justice – such a wind will blow from God that nations will turn to justice, questions will arise, human rights issues will arise, and fair treatment of man will gain ever greater intensity. Oppressed and enslaved nations will begin to gain freedom, because the concept of justice will rise and spread over the world. This gradual event is possible in the prophecy, and exactly this is happening. When Hazrat Mirza Sahib came and made his claim, look at the state of that time: apart from the Western colonial powers, the rest of the world was enslaved, every inch of it. Then a movement for justice arose, first among the blacks, first among the yellow races, among other peoples; then it gradually spread, then entered the ruling nations themselves, until today white nations have risen against the white regime of South Africa: who are you to act against justice? This wind is visibly blowing and spreading day by day. Hundreds of nations have become free as a result of this concept of justice, the United Nations and other institutions are coming into being, Amnesty International is being formed, other things are in motion. Thus God’s decree makes decisions gradually. What must be seen is whether this wind has begun to blow and whether it is advancing with greater strength, intensity and perceptibility than before. If this is the consistent direction, no one has the right to expect from Mirza Sahib what God never did before and to tell him that in this sense too you are not truthful, that no wind of justice blew in the world.
The other aspect is the notion about Jesus (as) that the Day of Judgement is joined to him. First: if, whether after the Imam Mahdi or Jesus, God is to roll up the world after thirty or forty years of reform – this is the belief, said to be based on Hadith – what meaning will you then give to the Hadith in which the Holy Prophet (saw) says that the Hour will come upon the worst of people (ashrar an-nas), that God will roll up those who are most wicked? And what will you make of the verses of the Holy Qur’an in which Allah says that He preserves goodness and the good and wipes out the bad? He even named righteous deeds “the enduring”: “wal-baqiyat as-salihat” – a good deed has the power to live. Whatever is beneficial in God’s sight is continued, not effaced. How would God suddenly forget all these sayings and the teaching of the Holy Qur’an He gave, and decide: when the world is filled with justice, when after long wickedness man has finally been reformed, when the Imam Mahdi and the Messiah together have brought about a mighty spiritual revolution such as no prophet before was enabled to, then wipe them out? And you will hear the protest of the Holy Prophet (saw) too: God has told me the Hour will come upon the worst of people – and he explained this subject in detail. Strange that the scholars forget this and keep the Muslim masses in darkness, speaking against reason and against the Sunnah.
Consider: the Holy Prophet (saw) says that after my passing people will remain upright for three centuries, then darkness will begin to spread, the night will deepen, a very long dark night will come, the era of Fayj-e-A’waj (the crooked group) will come. Then Allah will send the Messiah, and these events will occur. Then he said: when Allah gives victory to the Messiah, He will give it through prayers, not through fighting; rather He will Himself restrain him from fighting and reveal to him to give up the very intention of fighting the great powerful nations that have emerged in the world, to take refuge on the mountain and pray; through prayer Allah will grant him victory. Then, he says, God will make the Messiah prevail over the world, and for a long period cool winds will blow, there will be an era of peace. Then the wind will turn bad, evil will begin to spread, gradually the cool winds will end and the bad wind will again dominate the world, until the whole world is filled again not with justice but with tyranny and oppression. At that time, he said, God will bring down the Hour, and it will come upon the worst of people. This is the exact opposite of the belief the scholars have popularised among the masses.
Why do some people accept it silently? I will tell you the reason. Some Ahadith mention that the Hour (Sa’a) will come after it, and soon; and the Holy Qur’an says about Hazrat Jesus: “wa innahu la-’ilmun lis-sa’a” – he will come as a sign of the Hour. After this definitive testimony of the Holy Qur’an, supported also by Ahadith, the Muslim scholars must have been deceived, or they told the masses this and they quickly accepted it: yes, with the coming of the Messiah and Mahdi the Day of Judgement will come. They did not reflect to first learn from the Holy Qur’an itself what Sa’a means. Had they asked the Holy Qur’an, they would be astonished to find that God has not attached the word Sa’a to anyone except two prophets: first to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), then to the Messiah. That is in the verse “iqtarabatis-sa’atu wanshaqqal-qamar” – see, the moon was split, which proved definitively, indeed became a witness: the Hour has drawn near. Fourteen hundred years have passed – where is the Hour that drew near? Yet the Holy Qur’an is true. Then He said about the Messiah that when he comes he will be a sign of the Hour. Obviously, when the same word is used for two prophets – one the first, and one the last, who is to come as his devoted servant – it has one meaning, and that is spiritual revolution. Scholars have written in definitions of Sa’a, in commentaries of the Holy Qur’an and in lexicons that Sa’a does not only mean outward change but the bringing about of a spiritual revolution. The king of the spiritual world who comes will bring about a spiritual Hour, and through a spiritual Hour the dead of centuries come to life. Thus our concept of the Day of Judgement is ultimately this: on one side it proclaims death, on the other life; it does not proclaim death only, it proclaims: come, now become alive too – the trumpet is blown. When prophets come, especially the magnificent ones, both these decrees are attached to them. According to our belief the greatest Hour came with the advent of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw); hence the Holy Qur’an testified: “iqtarabatis-sa’atu wanshaqqal-qamar” – the Hour has drawn near, i.e. the time of revolution has come, the other nations had died and the Holy Prophet (saw) came to give them life. Further proof is in the Holy Qur’an: he came at a time when land and sea were filled with corruption: “zaharal-fasadu fil-barri wal-bahr”. “Zahara” means it prevailed, completely overwhelmed. Muhammad (saw) came when the land and the sea – i.e. the religious and the non-religious world, that is the meaning of this term in the Holy Qur’an – were filled with corruption and overwhelmed. And what did he proclaim? “yad’ukum lima yuhyikum” – he calls you so that he may give you life again. This was the Qiyamat that came, and today’s scholars looking with outward eyes did not even see it. The Qiyamat they await did not come, the world did not perish. The Holy Prophet (saw) says, God says “iqtarabat”, and they say fourteen hundred years have passed and it has not come yet. They say: no, it was said about the Messiah that the Qiyamat will be joined to him like two fingers. We say: why do you forget the Hadith in which the Holy Prophet (saw) says “ana was-sa’a” – I and the Hour are joined like these two fingers? Is there room left for further explanation? Only righteousness is needed, purity of soul. Every noble-minded Muslim will at once accept that when Muhammad (saw) says about himself that I and the Hour are joined like this, then when he says the same about the Messiah we have no right to bring in another meaning. And this Qiyamat has certainly already come, because it was joined with the Holy Prophet (saw), and it was a spiritual revolution. Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as), the Founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, mentions this Qiyamat and says: this wondrous event you saw in the deserts of Arabia, that the dead of centuries came alive and those corrupted for generations took on a divine hue – what was it? It was the prayers of one lost in God (fani fillah) that brought about this revolution. So neither can the Messiah bring about any other Qiyamat nor any other human in the world, and it is this Qiyamat that has value. Otherwise, if outward destruction were meant, it is in any case against reason that God makes people good and then kills them, when He Himself says: I warn people before punishment to become good; that is why I send prophets, to warn that if you do not become good you will be destroyed. He does not say: if you become good I will destroy you. What did Hazrat Noah do, what did earlier prophets do? The Holy Qur’an has opened the subject so clearly that no Muslim should even for a moment imagine that an outward doomsday is meant by Sa’a there – here the Messiah and the Mahdi make people good, and there Allah runs the sword over everyone’s jugular vein and destroys them. This is against reason and also against religion.