4. Huzur, the clerics in Iran permit mut‘ah (temporary marriage) and prove that it is permissible. – Has it been proven to you? – No, not to me. – Why then do you say ‘prove’? – They try to prove it. These people say that Hazrat Ali declared it permissible, although it had been prohibited before; in Islam at one time it was probably also permitted, then it was prohibited. If mut‘ah were declared permissible today, what form would it take in Islamic society?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 March 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: Huzur, the clerics in Iran permit mut‘ah (temporary marriage) and prove that it is permissible. – Has it been proven to you? – No, not to me. – Why then do you say ‘prove’? – They try to prove it. These people say that Hazrat Ali declared it permissible, although it had been prohibited before; in Islam at one time it was probably also permitted, then it was prohibited. If mut‘ah were declared permissible today, what form would it take in Islamic society?
You tell us something yourself. – I know nothing about it, Huzur. – You stayed in Iran so long; from their arguments, if you have not been convinced, you have certainly been impressed. Don’t you know what mut‘ah is? – Yes, I know. – Then tell us. If their mut‘ah were accepted, in our Islamic society today, where our mothers and daughters live, what form would mut‘ah take there? How will you distinguish between fornication and mut‘ah? He went, paid money, a five-minute marriage was performed. Such a sinful and depraved society would come into being that the very thought makes one’s hair stand on end. The greatest injustice to Islam has been committed by the Muslims themselves; they have made every good teaching frightful. The teaching of jihad was so magnificent; they presented it in such a repulsive way that to this day the whole world curses it. It was a teaching of purity of the soul; they turned it into mut‘ah. It was a teaching of truthfulness; they turned it into taqiyya, telling lies. Which place in Islam is there where the Muslim clerics themselves have not inflicted wounds? This is one of them, a very frightful wound. What is there to ask? Just draw the picture and say: let people stand up and tell whether they like this picture. The honour of no household would remain protected any more. Fine, sit down.