7. Assalamu alaikum, Hudhur. A few days ago, a friend mentioned the following question in the presence of other friends. I too expressed my opinion on this matter, but since I do not have much knowledge about it, I respectfully request Hudhur to benefit us with your blessed words. Further, I should mention that after writing this question I learnt that it has been asked before. If Hudhur permits, I will read the question. The question is: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that if a person falls ill, the suffering he undergoes because of the illness causes his sins to be forgiven. It is observed that small children sometimes face severe illnesses. Since small children are sinless, the question is why they have to face such illnesses, and which of their sins are forgiven as a result of the illnesses?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 March 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Assalamu alaikum, Hudhur. A few days ago, a friend mentioned the following question in the presence of other friends. I too expressed my opinion on this matter, but since I do not have much knowledge about it, I respectfully request Hudhur to benefit us with your blessed words. Further, I should mention that after writing this question I learnt that it has been asked before. If Hudhur permits, I will read the question. The question is: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that if a person falls ill, the suffering he undergoes because of the illness causes his sins to be forgiven. It is observed that small children sometimes face severe illnesses. Since small children are sinless, the question is why they have to face such illnesses, and which of their sins are forgiven as a result of the illnesses?

(Hudhur first remarks that the questioner is one of two questioners whom people miss if they do not ask – as Ghalib said –; and after the long preamble: when you have read out so much, why should the question not come too?) It would have been better if you had read the actual words of the Hadith for this question. When a questioner prepares a question, there is no difficulty for him in looking up the actual Hadith and its words. I do not recall the word 'person'; in this Hadith the words are Mu'min or Muslim, meaning a servant of God who is a believing Muslim. And the content of the Hadith shows that it refers to one who is obligated by the Shariah, and a child is not obligated at all. Therefore it cannot apply to a child. It speaks here of one who is obligated by the Shariah, a believer and Muslim who is adult. About him it was said: one who lives his life with righteousness, Allah the Exalted will deal with him so mercifully that if he suffers any hardship in this world, in exchange He will later reward him for the sins and lapses committed by him, through their forgiveness. That is the matter; children do not come into it at all. As for the philosophy – why some children are born ill, why they suffer, why their parents and relatives suffer grief because of them – I have already said a lot about it in a separate session. Please look at the cassettes.

10 of 10 left today