8. Another question: a few days ago, after a meeting of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in Cambridge, a friend mentioned that since Ahmadi Muslims believe that the second descent of Jesus (as) upon the white minaret does not mean literally descending upon a minaret, the question is asked: if Jesus (as) was not to descend upon a minaret, why then did the Promised Messiah (as) have the Minarat-ul-Masih built in Qadian? Hudhur, kindly guide us on this subject.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 March 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Another question: a few days ago, after a meeting of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in Cambridge, a friend mentioned that since Ahmadi Muslims believe that the second descent of Jesus (as) upon the white minaret does not mean literally descending upon a minaret, the question is asked: if Jesus (as) was not to descend upon a minaret, why then did the Promised Messiah (as) have the Minarat-ul-Masih built in Qadian? Hudhur, kindly guide us on this subject.
The Promised Messiah (as) did not have the minaret built in his lifetime at all for descending upon it. It was built in a later construction phase – anyone who knows the history of Ahmadiyyat [knows]: he only had the foundation laid, and it was built perhaps in the second Khilafat. (On enquiry:) Yes, in the second, in 1916. This is actually a Sunnah. It points to something that had already happened before in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw). The Holy Prophet (saw), during the Mi'raj and Isra, led prayers in a mosque in Bait-ul-Maqdis whose name is given as Masjid Aqsa, and in that mosque all the prophets prayed behind him. Nowadays people think there actually was a mosque named Masjid Aqsa there in his time. There was no mosque. The Temple of Solomon had been destroyed; there was a heap of filth, rubbish and dirt. And this is the very place about which the Messiah had said that he would not rebuild it. A mosque was built there only later, in the time of Abdul Malik. In the time of Hazrat Umar (ra) the area was conquered; before that it was in the possession of others. Then the place was cleaned, and after that the mosque was built later under the name Masjid Aqsa. So what the Holy Prophet (saw) saw in a vision, that he went there, God did not fulfil outwardly. What standing does the Messiah then have that God should necessarily fulfil such things for him outwardly? The station of the master is in any case higher. The point is that outwardly there is no reality to it; these are visionary matters. As a blessing of that vision – just as a name is given after a holy person, or as a person in interpreting a dream himself starts fulfilling it for blessing – those who came later built Masjid Aqsa in order to fulfil this vision of the Holy Prophet (saw) outwardly. So if after the demise of the Promised Messiah (as) the Khulafa built a minaret, how is that against the Sunnah or contrary to Islamic teaching? It is entirely in accordance with it.