9. Hudhur, a question has been received from the ladies. They write: the subject of the existence of God the Exalted is very important and vast, but if there is an occasion when an atheist is to be introduced in five or ten minutes to some proof of the existence of God, which proof should be given first and how should it be presented?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 March 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Hudhur, a question has been received from the ladies. They write: the subject of the existence of God the Exalted is very important and vast, but if there is an occasion when an atheist is to be introduced in five or ten minutes to some proof of the existence of God, which proof should be given first and how should it be presented?

Thank God they have given five minutes; had they said one minute, then… This is strange: they themselves say it is such an important subject, and at the same time say convince someone in five minutes. This is not possible. How can you convince someone in five minutes of such a serious subject on which the foundation rests? One could say that the subject of the existence of God is very vast, very deep, and atheists are of different kinds, therefore it cannot be dealt with in a few minutes. The fact is that I have said several times before that you cannot measure every atheist with one yardstick, because he has no religion; we do not even know what belief an atheist holds, what idea he has about God. Each one is an individual. Therefore with whomever you are to converse, reason demands that you first find out from him what his view is. There are many agnostics, and of them too there are many kinds; there are many atheists, and of them too there are different kinds. Some say: we simply do not know whether He exists or not; He may, we do not know. Others say: we can prove that it is a lie, that it is your fraud; no such Being can exist, nor does it. They are different people. When they are asked – the man of the first kind – unless you first ask him what evidence would be needed for him to accept, what proof will you give until then? You are giving a proof from the East while he may want to accept something from the West. Therefore such matters are settled with mature insight. It is not that I tell someone a quick trick, you apply it in five minutes and the atheist accepts at once. That cannot happen. Ask such a person: my friend, if you deny the existence of God, then tell me some proof, some reason; and if it is the absence of proof, with what kind of proof would you accept? Then each person will state his own point. Whatever he says, start from there; that door has opened for him, you will enter from there. In five minutes I can only say this.

10 of 10 left today