11. Hudhur, a short question: some people offer the Nawafil sitting after the prayer. To what extent is this correct? … One case is that a person is ill and cannot pray standing, but some people are fit and healthy and offer Nawafil sitting after the prayer; there are Ahmadi friends too. … Hudhur, the Fard they offer standing, the Sunnah too they offer standing, but the Nawafil they offer sitting.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 March 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Hudhur, a short question: some people offer the Nawafil sitting after the prayer. To what extent is this correct? … One case is that a person is ill and cannot pray standing, but some people are fit and healthy and offer Nawafil sitting after the prayer; there are Ahmadi friends too. … Hudhur, the Fard they offer standing, the Sunnah too they offer standing, but the Nawafil they offer sitting.
Perhaps their legs are weak, poor things. – One who offers Nawafil sitting after the prayer cannot be fit and healthy. – It is wrong, entirely contrary to the Sunnah. What you say is right, I know; I am saying they should not be called fit and healthy, something must be wrong with them. I do not know why this custom has needlessly been adopted. The Sunnah of the Holy Prophet (saw) was to offer Nawafil standing; it is even reported that his feet would swell. If sitting had been permitted even for slight discomfort, or had he liked it, what need was there to stand until his feet swelled? About his pure wives it is reported that once, in the chamber of Hazrat Zainab (ra), he saw a rope hung across the chamber. He asked: why is this rope hung? She said: O Messenger of Allah, I worship all night and become so tired that I cannot stand, so I take the support of the rope. Upon this the Holy Prophet (saw) did not say: do it sitting; he said: do not worship so much that you have no strength for it. That was voluntary worship, not obligatory worship. After that, what justification is there for anyone to simply start worshipping sitting? It seems that some elders who were ill perhaps managed with effort to stand in the obligatory prayer, and afterwards when the body did not cooperate, began the Nawafil sitting. No one asked them why they did so; people began imitating with closed eyes. I think this custom must have spread this way, but it has no basis in the Sunnah. – That is exactly what I am telling you as the answer; why they do it, I am only surmising. I myself do not do so.