5. In economics and the social system: a Muslim, whether living in Britain or Pakistan, pays income tax. In addition it is his religious duty to give charity and Zakat; that too is a form of tax. So why this double taxation, this burden on the person who [already] pays tax? [Follow-ups: If in Islam there is the concept of Bait-ul-Mal, would the concept of income tax end? And: so you mean Zakat should be adjusted according to indexation?]
Urdu question-and-answer session, 5 April 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: In economics and the social system: a Muslim, whether living in Britain or Pakistan, pays income tax. In addition it is his religious duty to give charity and Zakat; that too is a form of tax. So why this double taxation, this burden on the person who [already] pays tax? [Follow-ups: If in Islam there is the concept of Bait-ul-Mal, would the concept of income tax end? And: so you mean Zakat should be adjusted according to indexation?]
The tax one pays to the world relates to the matters on which it is spent. If the Islamic ‘tax’, which you call tax, related to the same needs, then there would be no need. But the ‘tax’ which Islam has prescribed, namely Zakat – its purposes the Holy Qur’an has described, that it is to be spent on those very purposes. If the government of the time fulfils all those needs from your tax, then it would be absorbed in it. But if some needs remain, how can the tax in the Holy Qur’an be waived to that government? The needs mentioned in the Holy Qur’an will be fulfilled only by those who believe in the Holy Qur’an, and they need money for it. And equating it with other taxes is a mistake anyway; it is a necessity to call it so, because no other good term exists for it. If you reflect on the subject of Zakat as described in the Holy Qur’an from different angles, you will realise that one meaning of Zakat is that when you spend in the way of Allah, your money does not diminish; rather Allah fills it up and increases it. What kind of tax is it that increases by giving? There is no such tax in the world. If for any reason you consider Zakat a tax and do not give it, you will harm yourself, because Allah says He is the guarantor of it. Indeed He says: you think interest increases [your wealth] ... [gap] ... Allah will increase your wealth. Secondly, Zakat means purification (Tazkiya); from the same root comes the word Zakat. One meaning is to increase; Zakat is said when someone is raised high. And secondly it also contains the sense of purity. So when you ... [gap] ... give for Allah, purity arises in you as a result. When you spend for a noble purity, a person immediately experiences that he considers himself better than before. Here in England, whenever ... [gap] ... I have never met a taxpayer who felt noble after paying tax; he comes cursing, saying: what a calamity, I had to pay tax. Further, Zakat is connected with love and tax with coercion. Allah says in the Holy Qur’an: ‘Lan tanalul-birra hatta tunfiqu mimma tuhibbun’ – no virtue of yours will be accepted until you spend with love and spend of that which you love. The Companions used to present their best possessions, and when the tax collector comes, you try to present the worst. There is a difference of heaven and earth in its motivation. Therefore Zakat is necessary for the life of the Umma, to maintain the relationship with God within the Umma, for the purity of its soul, for blessing in its wealth; there are countless benefits, I have listed only a few. You can never consider it a substitute for other taxes. [On the Bait-ul-Mal follow-up:] ... [gap] ... [they say]: just give it so we can put it in our pocket; give it to us mullahs so we use it for special purposes. As far as the state is concerned, Zakat cannot suffice; for state needs we will have to pay tax. That is wrong. [That would mean] the Holy Qur’an is an incomplete [book] ... [gap] ... [the Holy Prophet (saw) had] fixed [the rates], and they were changing needs, and the rates too are changeable. For example, the Zakat rate fixed at that time on gold and silver yielded roughly equal Zakat; later the values changed. If you now give Zakat on silver ... [gap] ... for example, he (saw) was leading an army on a campaign, and provisions became scarce. At that time the soldiers all carried their own rations and were responsible for themselves. The Holy Prophet (saw) ... [gap] ... [if provisions are pooled] and the yield becomes so small that there is danger some needs will not be met, then this is the way of Zakat. He (saw) ordered it in wisdom; he had not made a [voluntary] appeal, and the Companions acted on it, and as a result there was blessing: the needs of the whole army were met, but everyone also shared a little in the hardship. So sometimes this becomes the standard of Zakat. Sometimes, according to the principles of the Holy Qur’an, different economic systems in different countries will have different standards of Zakat. He says: ‘Wa fi amwalihim haqqun lis-sa’ili wal-mahrum’ – in the wealth of the affluent of the nation there is a right. He did not say charity is to be given; He said it is a right, for the one who asks and the deprived. This means that if after Zakat there still remain askers and deprived in the nation – ‘deprived’ meaning those whose minimum needs of life are not being met – then the Holy Qur’an would be saying that their right has remained in the wealth of your rich, and the mullah would be saying: no, we have fulfilled the Zakat obligation ... [gap] ... If in a nation someone is starving, or his minimum standard of living is not met, he has no blanket to cover himself, no bedding, no clothes to wear, no roof over his head, the basic educational needs are not met – children capable of higher education, with good minds, remain deprived of education due to poverty – then with the word ‘deprived’ the mind will immediately also turn to ‘the one who asks’ ... [gap] ... in some places a fixed Zakat is mentioned, as the Messenger (saw) fixed it, in some places it is not fixed. In view of this principle the hands of an Islamic government become very wide. And no system of Zakat is such that it is fixed to one time or one nation. In England the definition of the asker and the deprived will be different and their number different, in Pakistan different, in India different. This verse will show its effect everywhere equally and demand different standards. [On indexation:] We must collect Zakat to fulfil the needs the Holy Qur’an has stated – that is my point. The Holy Qur’an has stated the needs. How can it be that a rate is fixed which does not meet the needs and yet the right of Zakat is fulfilled? By stating the needs, the Holy Qur’an has made a decision in principle: as long as these needs remain, Zakat must be collected, the standard of Zakat must be raised; when these needs are met, after that you have no right to collect Zakat from the nation – that is, compulsorily in the name of God. Until then the government has the right to collect it.