10. Assalamu alaikum. Huzur, kindly shed light on the following subject: freedom of conscience and freedom of expression of opinion and thought is a basic human right which Allah the Exalted has granted to man. But just as there are certain rules regarding every act – for example, a person, while carrying out the commandments of the Shariah, is bound not to do anything that creates disorder in the nation or country and violates the rights of the general public – please guide us as to what principles Allah has laid down regarding freedom of conscience, i.e. under which rules and regulations a person has freedom of conscience.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 5 April 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Assalamu alaikum. Huzur, kindly shed light on the following subject: freedom of conscience and freedom of expression of opinion and thought is a basic human right which Allah the Exalted has granted to man. But just as there are certain rules regarding every act – for example, a person, while carrying out the commandments of the Shariah, is bound not to do anything that creates disorder in the nation or country and violates the rights of the general public – please guide us as to what principles Allah has laid down regarding freedom of conscience, i.e. under which rules and regulations a person has freedom of conscience.

The Holy Qur’an has stated all the principles in one short verse. It says: La ikraha fid-din – there is no compulsion in religion. And this verse works equally both ways: neither can you change someone’s religion by force, nor does anyone have the right to change your religion by force. You can neither change anyone’s religion by force ideologically, nor practically compel anyone to abandon his religion and adopt another. And in the name of religion you have no right of compulsion over anyone else either. If one reflects on it, this verse is so comprehensive in meaning that it covers every sphere of life, and it also tells where it is permitted to take a step in the name of religion and where it is not. For example, if one considers the teaching of certain Hindu sects: if a Shudra hears the sound of the Gita or the Vedas, it is said that molten lead should be poured into his ears. They can say that this is our religion. [gap in recording] We cannot permit compulsion on any human being even in the name of that religion. La ikraha fid-din means this too. Therefore: your religion is blessed in its place. Society will tolerate your religion as long as your religion does not compel you to … anyone else [gap] … He replied: we live in a free country, it is my right, I will do as I please. He also swung his arm with great force. The other said: all right, it is your right, but the limit of swinging your arm ends where … [gap] … it gives rights to living beings as well and also takes that (right of encroachment) away from everyone. Therefore it is a teaching of complete peace. After this there remains no need to look anywhere else.

10 of 10 left today