1. Why are certain punishments in Shariah Law so severe, such as the cutting of a hand for stealing?
Question-and-answer session, 9 June 1987
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording. · Automatic transcript of the audio recording, language smoothed with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why are certain punishments in Shariah Law so severe, such as the cutting of a hand for stealing?
Yes, now I am at your disposal. Yes, please. Would you like to ask anything?
I have a question if you understand the problem. There are two participants have different کاqu justify the body provar. Fernand Q aside, one of the primary policies have the casualties of each and other forms of action. For prior time the process is believed in the hostile from Mohammed Sheikh. So they lead the legitimacy from the Holy Qur’an. Now, how is your opinion about the problem? renizhi, enlightened professionally, didn't you speak to that?
Do you speak in English?
No, but those who will listen to this cassette later on wouldn't understand it. The question is, yes, I'm from the juristic side of society, and you will understand my question, you know, that in so-called fundamentalistic states of Islam, like in Libya, the punishment of bodily chastisement has been introduced according to the Sharia, according to the Islamic law. And in Libya even a machine has been constructed which is cutting the hand off without giving any kind of infection to the hand. And what is your view? They say that the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw) has introduced this punishment. What is your view about it?
I have the honor of having written an article on Islamic punishments sometimes ago which was published and which was well taken by many jurists of the world, in which I explained in detail the Islamic jurisprudence, the system of of of penal code concerning certain ordinary crimes, and the philosophy behind, and the effect of deterrence which they held. But that is not all the story. Before the implementation of the Islamic penal code, it is essential, according to Islam, to raise the moral standard of that society where that penal code is to be implemented and applied.
So this question of yours is a very deep question of a wider application which cannot be answered in a few words in such a gathering as this, because you, being a very, I mean, a very well renowned jurist, jurist yourself, you understand the implications of law and the philosophy behind it.
One thing I can say, and I think that should suffice, that if Islamic system of punishments is implemented, truly speaking, according to fulfilling all the conditions which Islam requires, then in majority of cases, the crime would disappear from our society.
In answer to a similar question in America once, I pointed out that you object to severing of a few hands, maybe once in a blue moon in a year, but at the hands of the thieves and the muggers, in New York alone, the hands which are severed amount to many scores, and you do not object to that.
The philosophy of law is to protect the innocent, and if any law fails to protect the innocent for the sake of showing mercy to the criminal, that law must be considered inadequate. On the contrary, if a law appears to be barbaric, but in implementation the possibility of executions are so few and far between on the one hand, and on the other, as the effect of law, the innocent public of the country is saved daily harassments of sometimes immense order at the hands of the criminals, then I personally would much rather go for a barbaric law with very few applications than daily sufferings of the innocent public. So these are the issues involved which have to be weighed before an answer from Islamic point of view is well understood.
Secondly, the system of evidence as proposed by Islam is so strict and so deeply bonded with the sense of morality that a witness is required to hold certain moral values. In any immoral society, like, for instance, in Libya today where witnesses can be bought or influenced, or in Pakistan or other Muslim countries where the moral standard, unfortunately to our detriment, is very low, Islamic laws cannot be implemented. It is wrong to implement any law in the name of Islam before preparing that atmosphere. It would be like trying to plant a tree of cherry in the in the heart of the desert. The atmosphere in the desert is not promoting the growth of cherries, is not promotive to the growth of cherries.
So Islam not only speaks of laws, it's a religion. So it speaks of the preparation for the implementation of laws as well. This is why, according to Islam, the prophets first attend to the moral values of the country. They transform the society, raise the standard to a high degree, then to maintain that standard and to safeguard its values, some stern measures are taken which are very seldom applied in reality, but the society in bargain is much happier and safe.
[The interpreter renders this in German.]
The Voraussetzungen for an Islamism is because of that the moral standard of the population is already set to be established in any way. If this is not the case, then can also be done by this legislation. I think that the West is the view of a barbaric legislation students.
where only a few cases come, because if the Islamic legislation was implemented—and this is a sign of the Praxis—then there would be very few cases, because the people don't have the need to behave, this so to behave. [The interpreter renders this in German.]
Secondly, I must say that in a state like Libya, the legislation cannot be implemented, and this is because of the following reason: The moral behavior of a witness against a law in Islam is very high. In a country where some witnesses can be bought and bought and bought, and that moral behavior is very low, it would be totally senseless to introduce such a law, because it would achieve nothing. It would be like planting a cherry tree in the desert. [The interpreter renders this in German.]
[The interpreter renders this in German.]
I would like to mention that in the middle there is a microphone on the floor, the person who wants to give his voice to the microphone.