3. Is the primary purpose of inter-religious dialogue in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community to simply have a dialogue or to convert others?
Question-and-answer session, 9 June 1987
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Is the primary purpose of inter-religious dialogue in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community to simply have a dialogue or to convert others?
I would be very interested to hear your reflections about the problem of inter-religious dialogue and especially your comments about the intent of the Ahmadiyya Movement when engaging into inter-religious dialogue. There are many discussions going on, especially in the Christian churches, in the World Council of Churches and other major Christian institutions, about the problem of how to reconcile interreligious dialogue and proselytism. And I see, for instance, the Ahmadiyya Movement is coming to the West and proselytizing, but at the same time open to interreligious dialogue. So my concern, for instance, is to know, when the Ahmadiyya Movement is holding a seminar or is holding a lecture in some European centre, is the intent of the Ahmadiyya to use interreligious dialogue as a means toward converting people, or is the interreligious dialogue an end in itself? Thank you.
[The interpreter renders this in German.]
Very interesting question, asked with slightly wrong emphasis, I should say. The way you said, "Do you intend to convert people?" had a connotation of threat. No, not from you to me, but from me to you: If that is the purpose you hold these dialogues, then we should rather be away from them than attend them under the simple, innocent impression that perhaps you mean to hold the dialogues for the sake of dialogue and not with any other purpose. Now, this is the question as I understand.
I am a simple religious person and I am not a diplomat, so my answer will be straight and honest. I believe that a dialogue without the purpose of converting people to the viewpoints of the speakers or participants of the dialogue is a meaningless exercise, is an exercise in futility. If anybody claims that is the object, I consider this is simply hypocritical, because dialogue is meant to convert. In political dialogues, in scientific dialogues, in every other dialogue, this is the purpose and nobody minds.
So why should religious people mind if a dialogue is held with the purpose of converting others to your viewpoint? The only thing wrong about conversion is if you use underhand means, if you use oppression, if you use threats, the use of sword and things, then of course it is barbaric, it is inhuman, and every such attempt, which is accompanied by force and coercion, must be totally condemned and rejected. But if the dialogue is held in the spirit of humane attitude, and courteous and civil attempt to put yourself across, so that you win converts to your way of thinking, then it is not only essential, it proves the honesty of the person who holds a particular idea.
If I believe that Ahmadiyya view of life and Ahmadiyya way of life is good for the mankind, then I have a right to stick to it, and I have also not a right but obligation to put my ideas across, because I stick to it because I find it good. Why shouldn't I give opportunity to others to join a good way of life and a good idea? This is simply what I understand conversion to be. So my purpose in coming here as well is this: to convert you to my way of thinking. So if anybody is threatened, he should take note of it for the future invitations.
[The interpreter renders this in German.]