5. Is it possible to integrate the Islamic economic system with the Western economic system?

Question-and-answer session, 9 June 1987

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording. · Automatic transcript of the audio recording, language smoothed with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it possible to integrate the Islamic economic system with the Western economic system?

I can ask my question in French, or do I do it in German?

If you could speak German, I think it would be better. Can you get a translation? Shana, Rafiq, can you work as a makeshift?

Non, mais je peux parler en allemand, oui, oui. Je voudrais poser une question dans le domaine de l'économie. L'islam est une religion qui est très pratique. L'économie occidentale domine de plus en plus le monde. Et l'islam considère l'intérêt de l'argent comme illégitime. And then I would like to know if you maintain this option of Islam, and how do you see a conciliation possible in our current world between the économie occidentale and Islam? I was not very long in Tunisia, and I saw that some Arab banks try to find a way to get rid of the whole problem of the interest of the money. Well, the problem is there, and I would be very grateful to know what is your position in this area.

I would like to ask a question about economy and Islam. Islam being a very practical religion, and we can see in today's world that the Western style of economy is coming to be the dominant system of economy. So the problem is, what is the view of the Ahmadi movement about this problem? Is it possible to find some way to reconcile Islamic ideals and Western-style economy? For instance, I went recently to some Arabic countries and saw that there are some economic institutions attempting at creating a way which can reconcile more or less Islamic ideals and Western-style economy. Could you please give us some information about the views of Ahmadiyya?

I will, if after you have translated this into German as well. Because there are many here who don't understand either English or French.

So, there are some possibilities, maybe a way to find, where at the same time the Islamic ideas about the economy and the West economy, which can find a way to find out. I saw in some Arab countries that there are economic institutions who want to find a way to find, as much as possible, view of the economy. [The interpreter renders this in German.]

Sorry for that. [In German:] Yes, of course. The problem is with interest on money, interest rates, and so on, of course. I understand that fully. No, no, I think the best thing now would be that either you translate into German directly, which he would understand well, I understand, and the questioner cannot speak German fluently, but he can understand German all right. Is that not right?

Ja. [The interpreter renders this in German.]

So that just the German rendering of what I say would be enough. [The interpreter renders this in German.]

I see. All right.

That this problem of the clash of two economic systems has to be understood at the roots first before we talk of compromises. There are certain principles governing every economy which have to be understood, and in principles there can be no compromise. In other areas of conflict or contact between two economies, compromises can be sought, sometimes effectively and sometimes cannot, but in principles there are no compromises.

As far as the Islamic economic system is concerned, in principle it is closer in one way to communist system than to the Western system. Islam can never recognize any economic system based on usury and interest. According to Islam, all economies based on banking systems, where money apparently multiplies, but a huge fraud is played on the people in the name of banking system, and the entire world is totally kept ignorant as to what is happening to their money and what havoc is being played with them by the capitalists, where the money is flowing, who are the forces fluctuating the prices of dollar against pound, pound against dollar and mark, and so on and so forth, and what is happening to their wealth, where they are being ultimately led to—all this is an area where there is no compromise as far as Islam goes.

In certain other areas of individual enterprise, Islam is closer to the Western approach than the communist approach. So it's a system of via media which has to be which has to be studied in detail from section to section.

As far as the modern attempts of some Muslim countries are concerned to compromise certain economic aspects of Islamic system with Western values, I personally believe it is either a fraud or an expression of total ignorance about the economic system. You know what happens? They deposit their money in Western banks and earn all the interest they can, yet when they distribute that money to the people who deposited originally, for instance, they would call it profit rather than interest. So what manner of approach is that? That, what manner of compromise is this? You change the nomenclature, while in reality, the objectionable parts of a deal, economic deal remain the same. So I call it either utter ignorance or conscious fraud.

As far as the usury and and this capitalist system based on interest is concerned, Islam would never recognize it. What alternative system does Islam have? That is the question. In short, I can tell it is a vast, it requires a vast answer. But to be very brief, I point out that as against interest, Islam devises a system of tax called Zakat. Now, those who understand economy will immediately understand the point which I am trying to make.

In usury, to move the wheel of economy, interest becomes the force which attracts you to deposit your money and put it into rotation in some economic production, productive system. In Islam, it is the negative approach. If you do not employ your capital into an economic wheel or economic productive system, you are fined. Your capital as such does not gain anything if you deposit it, but if you do not put it to usage, then you are considered to either have no right to retain that money or you must be fined so that gradually that capital returns to the people. This is how the Islamic economic wheel keeps on moving, for fear of fine rather than for avarice of increasing one's money through usury system.

A detailed comparison of these two motive forces can render beyond a shadow of doubt that Islamic system is more simple, more understandable, and less potent with dangers, and there is no possibility of using it fraudulently. On the contrary, as I said earlier, in the Western system of economy where interest is used as a motive force for moving the wheel of economy, it is the people who suffer in the first place.

You know, today I deposit a sum of 100 francs in the bank with the promise that in 10 years it will more than double, and I am so happy that my money is increasing, I don't have to employ it directly under my own capabilities. The result is that it more than doubles in 10 years, but its buying power decreases to less than one third or more by that time. So who is the gainer? The gainer is the capitalist. The public depositor is always the loser, because in the Western system of economy, the rate of inflation is always coupled with the rate of interest. And all the economists employed by the governments and big banking systems see to it that it is the public which always loses in the end and never gains. This is my experience after my study of the Western economy and how things are carried out. And there are so many other things, but as I said, many people would be tired and the subject is very vast, so let us stop here. And if another question in this region is to be asked, I'll answer that.

[The interpreter renders this in German.]

[Interpreter, in German:] But in my understanding, capitalism commits a huge fraud against the masses. If we see how many people know how the pound is against the dollar and the dollar is against the mark, that is a certain system that is not available to the small man.

[The interpreter renders this in German.]

[The interpreter renders this in German.]

If there is still a question which can be asked in this context, then I can go further into it, but otherwise I will leave it at that. In Islamic system of economy, inflation is inconceivable.

10 of 10 left today