5. The question is: in the Holy Qur’an, probably in Surah Al-Imran, where slaughtering and eating what is lawful (halal) is mentioned, it is stated that we should not eat that over which a name other than Allah’s has been invoked. Further on, probably in Surah Al-An‘am, Allah says in the Holy Qur’an that we should also not eat that over which the name of Allah has not been invoked. The question, Huzur, is: is meat over which no name other than Allah’s was invoked, but over which Allah’s name was also not invoked when it was slaughtered, lawful or unlawful to eat?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: The question is: in the Holy Qur’an, probably in Surah Al-Imran, where slaughtering and eating what is lawful (halal) is mentioned, it is stated that we should not eat that over which a name other than Allah’s has been invoked. Further on, probably in Surah Al-An‘am, Allah says in the Holy Qur’an that we should also not eat that over which the name of Allah has not been invoked. The question, Huzur, is: is meat over which no name other than Allah’s was invoked, but over which Allah’s name was also not invoked when it was slaughtered, lawful or unlawful to eat?

(After interpretation:) These two verses do not contradict each other; rather, in the light of each other a comparatively broader meaning is understood. From the first verse you referred to, it appears that if something is slaughtered in the name of someone other than Allah, those who believe in God should not touch it. And it is not the case that if you recite Bismillah it becomes permissible to eat. It is wholly unlawful. Such things are like carrion, unlawful; it cannot become lawful by reciting Bismillah. Or an animal that dies from a blow becomes unlawful; swine is unlawful – it falls in that category. Other things are neutral: for example, the meat was slaughtered for human use, the blood was drained, it is not carrion, but the slaughterer did not take the name of Allah. This is “lam yudhkar-ismullahi ‘alaiha”; it falls into this category. Concerning it the Holy Prophet (saw) said that if the one eating recites Bismillah himself before eating, then Bismillah can be recited over it even afterwards, because no wrong intention was involved beforehand; hence it has a neutral status. Thus there is the narration of Hazrat Aisha Siddiqa (ra), recorded in Bukhari, that meat would come about which we could not say whether it had been slaughtered in the Islamic manner or not, whether anyone had recited Bismillah or not. The instruction of the Holy Prophet (saw) was: recite Bismillah and the meat will become permissible. So when the Holy Prophet (saw), upon whom the Holy Qur’an was revealed, has himself explained it, no question of any further debate or dispute remains.

10 of 10 left today