6. (The question is only fragmentarily preserved.) It is more of a statement: Islam has beautiful ideas about women, but theory and practice differ; in practice women are not treated as taught, and in Europe women are treated much better.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (The question is only fragmentarily preserved.) It is more of a statement: Islam has beautiful ideas about women, but theory and practice differ; in practice women are not treated as taught, and in Europe women are treated much better.
This matter has many aspects that must be considered separately, because during the question you briefly raised some other points which are very important questions. First, the basic question is that there is a difference between theory and practice; what is said about women is not happening in practice. Here you have forgotten one thing: having a difference between theory and practice is a characteristic of human beings, and not only in women’s matters but in every matter. So the issue of women should be considered separately from this. It is a basic human disease that is seen in the same way in every sphere of life. Islam has existed for fourteen hundred years, Christianity for two thousand years, and the gap between theory and practice is growing rather than diminishing. The more centuries pass, the more the gap will grow rather than shrink, because the further one moves from the source, the more impure it becomes. So if you forget Ahmadiyyat for a while, there is a law of nature: the longer the period you speak of, the more this result should appear, that the gap between theory and practice becomes even greater. You want to find the opposite result, which is contrary to reason. Do you understand? So the more you stress fourteen hundred years, the more certain it should be that – unless Allah initiates some new movement of revival – the Muslim who has moved away from the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) will move further away from Islam rather than closer to it. This is a rational conclusion, and the history of Islam tells us exactly this: the Muslim of every century remained comparatively further from the Islam of the time of the Holy Prophet (saw). Indeed, even the Muslim of the following ten years, born after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw), did not adhere to that moral code of life with the same grandeur as the Muslim of the time of the Holy Prophet (saw). That is why a difference arose between the Sahaba and the Tabi‘in. So firstly, your perspective should be correct: the further one goes from the source, the more it is to be expected that a contradiction between theory and practice will begin to arise. (…) If, regarding women, you compare the teaching of Islam and its practice in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) with today, you will see many faults, and it will seem as though this teaching shone for a short while and then gradually fell victim to the vicissitudes of time, became rusty and corrupted. But if you want to know what Islam nevertheless gave to women, go back a few more years: the condition in which the Holy Prophet (saw) found women and the work he did to secure their rights – despite fourteen hundred years of decline, women today are still a hundred times better off than they were just before the coming of the Holy Prophet (saw). We compare with the best, and so we forget that against the best everything appears inferior. But how had the best come about? Go back a few years in time, and you will learn that the best had been made from the worst, and despite deterioration it could not become the worst again. Thus, before the time of the Holy Prophet (saw), women were distributed as inheritance; women were buried alive; women were not deemed fit to converse with men on an equal footing; women lived a slave-like life in the home like a maidservant; she had no right to speak in opposition to her husband. Many such afflictions were attached to women – in the daily matters of life, in her rights over children, in her illnesses, in her ailments: in every matter women were victims of oppression. Through the teaching God gave to the Holy Prophet (saw), she who used to be distributed as inheritance became entitled to inheritance. And for the first time in the world, Islam is the religion that declared women entitled to inheritance. Fourteen hundred years have passed – look at this too: to this day there is not a single religion that has secured inheritance for women. English law to this day, Swedish law to this day, and the laws of other European countries to this day have not given her an inheritance right as a woman. It is the parents’ right to give first to the child to whom they wish to bequeath; legally, women are still not entitled to inheritance today. Islam has bestowed so many favours that if you look at just one, even through gradual erosion it could not be erased. Even today, in Muslim societies, in most places women are heirs. Sometimes brothers usurp her right, but she still certainly gets something, and in many places she receives it in full. So do not compare with the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) but with the time before Islam; then you will learn how much Islam has done for women. (…) The second point you raised is that the treatment of women in Europe is much better. This is not correct; it is the result of ignorance of the conditions. I do not know the conditions of this country here, but there is news from England broadcast on television and printed in newspapers, from which it is apparent that men beat women so much and commit so many cruelties that they are not even imaginable in Islamic countries. Such terrible abuses are taking place nowadays under the veil of this civilisation: cruelty upon cruelty to small children, cruelty to little girls, cruelty to women. A television programme was shown, presented by an organisation for the protection of women’s rights. After extensive surveys they reported that in the majority of our homes – and this is a very significant statement – cruelties are taking place in the majority of homes, but out of shame and modesty women do not even report them. The statistics of those who do report show a hundred percent increase every year. Now, civilisation is apparently advancing; religion is left behind in history. Civilisation is expected to progress and become refined. Yet the further mankind advances in civilisation nowadays, the more the cruelty against women in this civilisation increases rather than decreases. These are statistics published in book form. I also cited them in my last address to the women at the Jalsa Salana; when it is printed you will learn of it. They commit such cruelties that – most often alcoholism is a disease that goes with it – they bang the woman’s head against the wall again and again until she becomes unconscious, and when she regained consciousness it was because he had held her under a cold-water tap, and he revived her only to play the same game with her again; then he banged her against the wall again until she was unconscious. Such painful incidents are happening so frequently in this civilised society that one is left astonished. Therefore, to assume that women here are very happy and content and that their rights are being fulfilled is not correct. A grown woman can still defend herself, but against one’s own daughters, innocent girls before puberty made victims of lust, so many cruelties are committed that in just one region of England, the North East, the Midlands and the North East, according to statistics, in thirty-three percent of homes these cruelties are definitely taking place – such bestial cruelty to little girls, to one’s own daughters, not to strangers. And as for strangers, incidents occur every other day in which small innocent girls of three, four, five years were made victims of lust, killed so that they could not report it, and thrown away somewhere. To ignore so much suffering present in a society and, from watching television programmes, dancing and singing, or people in the streets in fine clothes or having shed their clothes, to assume that this society is a bed of roses is not correct. Deeper reflection shows that when religions disappear, the sufferings remain behind, and these sufferings then grow day by day. For who will ask when God no longer exists? No one asks the question, man is not accountable for crime – then the increase of crime is a natural process; no one can stop it.