5. [Report/suggestion by a participant, partly unintelligible:] Many friends do not do Tabligh. In Tabligh sessions questions arise; usually only one person asks, the rest sit silently. I wrote to you about an incident … Secondly: about the Daʿwat ilallah movement you write again and again to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. My impression is that if all friends of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat act on this movement it can bring excellent results. But what happens is that on Tabligh days the same few friends always come. Especially in Europe the field is very wide, especially for those who speak good English, Norwegian or other languages. If this were introduced systematically … For our magazines there is no budget, whereas the opponents' local magazine is very detailed and has been running for a long time. And there are advertisements circulated to Muslims with objections to Persian verses of the Promised Messiah (as) – such as “I am the Messiah, I am Ahmad …”. This is put in advertisements, and these Muslims do not answer it. I mean that our magazine Al-Jihad should take this up more.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 26 August 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: [Report/suggestion by a participant, partly unintelligible:] Many friends do not do Tabligh. In Tabligh sessions questions arise; usually only one person asks, the rest sit silently. I wrote to you about an incident … Secondly: about the Daʿwat ilallah movement you write again and again to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. My impression is that if all friends of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat act on this movement it can bring excellent results. But what happens is that on Tabligh days the same few friends always come. Especially in Europe the field is very wide, especially for those who speak good English, Norwegian or other languages. If this were introduced systematically … For our magazines there is no budget, whereas the opponents' local magazine is very detailed and has been running for a long time. And there are advertisements circulated to Muslims with objections to Persian verses of the Promised Messiah (as) – such as “I am the Messiah, I am Ahmad …”. This is put in advertisements, and these Muslims do not answer it. I mean that our magazine Al-Jihad should take this up more.

No, no – not in Al-Jihad. Make small compendiums on each such objection and circulate them. Al-Jihad should not be given over entirely to this; it has its own purpose and will fulfil it as long as it is needed. This objection, however, is one that has been worn out for ninety years, and all the major, detailed answers to it exist.

There are prophecies about the Promised Messiah (as); even earlier there are prophecies about the Mahdi that when he comes he will say this. The Shia also have prophecies: he will say, I am Muhammad, I am Moses, I am the Holy Qur’an – whoever wants to see the Holy Qur’an, let him look at me. In Shia prophecies it says: whoever wants to see Ali, let him look at me. He will make all these claims. Whoever made this prophecy, these people have not condemned him, have issued no fatwa of disbelief against him. There are such great personages against whom they cannot say a single word. On what basis were these prophecies made? From their own words? And there are also very minor people who made such claims – there is a Chishti who said he saw himself reciting the Kalima: “Chishti Rasulullah”. Besides this there are many such groups in India whose people made tremendous claims about themselves, and the Deobandis cannot say a word against them even today – because we know this is mystical speech with many meanings. One must see: first, whether regarding the person who makes such claims there is any authority among the earlier saints that such a person will make such claims. If so, then he must make them; if the Imam Mahdi is to make them, he must make them – if he does not, he is a liar. Those who prophesied in the name of Muhammad (saw) that the true Imam would make these claims – when he makes them, they rise up against him. One must examine the fundamental issues.

Secondly: the meaning of a claim is to be learned from the one who made it, not from his opponent. Look at his other statements. He says: “All that we have, we received from him; You, O God, are witness; he who showed the truth – it is he. What am I, this is the whole verdict.” The entire literature of the Promised Messiah (as) is full of this explanation of what these claims mean: nothing other than that he has effaced his own self and has nothing in him but love for him [the Holy Prophet (saw)]. That is one point.

The third important point: if out of mischief one constructs such meanings from outward words, what will one do with the verses of the Holy Qur’an in which it is written: “You did not throw when you threw, but it was Allah Who threw”? You did not throw, but Allah. So [by that logic] is the Prophet (saw) claiming to be God? About those who pledged allegiance under the tree He said: “Verily, those who swear allegiance to you swear allegiance to Allah; the hand of Allah is over their hands.” They were pledging allegiance to Muhammad Rasulullah (saw) – and it says they are pledging allegiance to Allah, not by proxy. The hand over their hands was the hand of Muhammad Rasulullah (saw) – and it says this is Allah's hand. What meaning will they give to this? These meanings exist in the Holy Qur’an, they exist in every language; only for one whose soul is wicked are they closed. A person can easily understand this subject in the light of his claims, [namely] what rank he describes for himself. If they say there is no difficulty – why do they not start with the Holy Prophet (saw)? Read one passage of his in the light of his other passages, and then the matter becomes clear.

Answers already exist. If you want to write, then prepare new answers on the points and have pamphlets printed. A dedicated secretary should be appointed for this work – the Ishaat secretary or an assistant secretary – and do the work systematically. The answers that have come down as established currency for a long time, the references – all of it exists. These answers should be compiled; then it will not be said that after an objection a great attack was made and we could do nothing. Every Ahmadi should have the answer in hand so that when he learns of it he can respond. Likewise answer the others with a challenge. We have Radio Islam – repeat these answers there again and again. Then the matter will be settled. All right, Shahid Sahib.

10 of 10 left today