8. In our society, especially among young people, there are some who neglect prayer. Is there in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat – as with Chanda, where it is said that from someone who does not pay the obligatory contribution no other contribution is accepted – a similar measure for those who do not pray?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 26 August 1987
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: In our society, especially among young people, there are some who neglect prayer. Is there in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat – as with Chanda, where it is said that from someone who does not pay the obligatory contribution no other contribution is accepted – a similar measure for those who do not pray?
Whoever does not pay the obligatory contribution cannot give a voluntary one either; that has been laid down. The difference is that with Chanda you come to know it by itself; you do not have to spy. But with prayer, what yardstick do you have? Will you investigate in homes whether someone prays or not? That would be spying, and Islam gives no right to that. In matters of worship you have no right to go beyond what the Holy Prophet (saw) permitted. Even over one's own children he did not give full authority: between seven and ten years teach them with love and gentleness to pray and encourage them; from ten to twelve, only two years, strictness may be used, but do not strike the face and no unjust harshness; after twelve, hold back your hand – let him answer to God himself. That is the teaching. How then can we take measures that step beyond the permission of the Holy Prophet (saw)? Further, the Holy Prophet (saw) once said after the morning prayer about those who had not come and were resting: had goat trotters been cooked, they would have come running – such is the state of the self – but for so great a blessing as prayer they do not present themselves. He expressed great pain and said: I feel like having bundles of wood carried and setting them alight together with their houses – but I have no permission for that. Compulsion in prayer was not permitted even to the Holy Prophet (saw). This expression of feeling was to show that burning in this world is better than burning in the Fire; it was a warning. Yet you say one should investigate prayer, ask at homes and relatives – that is entirely impermissible. Admonish with sympathy and righteousness, knock on doors by all means; but if he does not pray, there are no punishments. Second: Wasiyyat is not granted to him. Wasiyyat is a different matter; it is not a punishment but a matter of status, of the front rank. If someone is not in religious terms a front‑rank Ahmadi, we are not obliged to prove it officially; here we go by reputation. If a person's reputation is bad, we can reject the Wasiyyat on that basis, because he has no right to it. Likewise, if someone's reputation is bad, he may be denied e.g. a vote/office; that is permissible. It is no one's right; it is at the discretion of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. It is not a punishment but a measure to protect others from harm, and no one is deprived of a right. That can be a means – not to harm him, but because of those known as non‑praying or whose character is publicly known. If the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat appoints them to office, it would have a very bad effect on others. Measures up to this extent may be allowed; beyond that we cannot go. Where is a worldly punishment for the non‑praying laid down? His punishment is that he will go to Hell and be called to account. If we say things like the non‑praying is such and such, then … Some people move from a state of not praying towards prayer, step by step. One who takes such a step will be judged by that step. I know some who resolve: well, I will offer the morning prayer. By the Shariah he is still one who leaves four prayers, but perhaps Allah looks with love that he has taken a step and will make the next easy for him. Hence no one has the right to interfere in matters between man and God. General admonition is allowed – do it in gatherings – but not personally and individually. No one has the right to reduce or increase the prayers. Whoever deliberately leaves a prayer commits rebellion. These are admonitions, and the Promised Messiah (as) and others have always said so, but not by singling someone out.