10. In countries where sunset and sunrise are unusual, where the sun does set and rise – can the times of Fajr and Maghrib prayers there be set at one's own discretion?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 26 August 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: In countries where sunset and sunrise are unusual, where the sun does set and rise – can the times of Fajr and Maghrib prayers there be set at one's own discretion?

Which conditions determine Maghrib and Fajr? If those conditions are not fulfilled, a person gains the right to intervene by estimation. For example, Maghrib is prayed after sunset – until when? [Exchange with attendees] Tell me which conditions mark the end of Maghrib time: until darkness falls, i.e. the evening twilight disappears. But if the evening twilight does not disappear and the morning twilight begins with no gap, when will you end Maghrib and begin Isha? Where none of the clear conditions is met, the Holy Prophet (saw) himself permitted estimation. In a tradition it is said that in the time of the Dajjal there will be days or nights of six months – this could hardly be understood then; I also read that entire northern regions are meant. Someone asked: O Messenger of Allah, will we then offer only five prayers in six months? He said no, estimate the span of a day and offer the full five prayers within it – as many days as make up six months. This solved the problem forever. It seems that in Allah's decree this question was specially prompted so that later people would not say Islam is incomplete. Hence wherever the conditions are not clear, one has this right. Otherwise one might say: if you do not intervene in Maghrib time, then do not pray Isha either since night does not come, nor Fajr, and do not fast, because the condition is that the black thread becomes distinct from the white – what will you say where that does not happen? So it is clearly proven that in these regions, while this condition lasts, the right to intervene exists. But not individually; it should be done through the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Therefore I had a full investigation done of which parts of the year in Norway are abnormal and in what respect; data was obtained through scientists showing from which month to which month the twilight persists or night disappears and the problem arises, and the further north one goes, the longer this period becomes.

10 of 10 left today