14. How does Islam permit Muslims to buy and eat meat/food from Christian markets?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 26 August 1987

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: How does Islam permit Muslims to buy and eat meat/food from Christian markets?

Islam permits it, explicitly; the Holy Qur’an says: their food is lawful for you and your food is lawful for them. If only Muslim halal were meant, why this discussion? It does not mean their pork is lawful for you, but that it is permissible to take your food, which you consider halal, from Christians or eat it at their homes, and that Christians may eat at yours what they consider halal. This creates bonds in society. The next part is meat, which is its own issue. Christian, Muslim or Jewish market makes no difference. If the meat is halal it stays halal whether a Christian or a Jew sells it. If a Muslim sells in the market – in Karachi it happened that … – it becomes haram; they slaughter dogs and sell them as halal. It is not who sells, but what it is in itself. One command: that over which a name other than Allah's was invoked, sacrificed in idolatry to other than God, is wholly haram; there is no way for it to become halal. Another: if Bismillah is not recited it is haram. Here the command of the Holy Prophet (saw) is known: if slaughtered without Bismillah, it becomes halal if the eater recites it beforehand. Whoever claims to be more pious than the Holy Prophet (saw) lies; he on whom the Shariah was revealed knows best and is the most pious. Bukhari narrates that sometimes meat came from outside and one did not know what kind it was or whether it was slaughtered; the Companions were in doubt. He said: recite Bismillah [and eat]. In short: what Islam clearly declared haram must not be present. A chicken killed by wringing its neck, or stunned without blood flowing, is haram – even if you recite Bismillah ten million times it will not become halal. Likewise an animal killed by stunning and cut only after death. But if it is stunned and then slaughtered while blood flows, the heart is beating and blood spurts out as the heartbeat makes it, then if Bismillah was not recited the eater may recite it, and according to the Hadith of the Holy Prophet (saw) it becomes halal for him. Keep these conditions in mind: killed for human consumption, not killed by a predator, not suffocated, and killed with blood shed; then it is permissible to eat with Bismillah, in whatever market it is sold. Kosher meat, over which they take the name of their God, is entirely halal; it falls under the Holy Qur’an's teaching about the People of the Book. There it does not say 'Christians' but 'People of the Book'.

10 of 10 left today