4. Is hypnosis or hypnotherapy a plausible and acceptable method of treatment?

Question-and-answer session, 29 June 1990

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is hypnosis or hypnotherapy a plausible and acceptable method of treatment?

Huzoor, currently one sees many advertisements in newspapers or magazines of sorts advertising services of hypnotherapists who claim that they can, in effect, improve people's characters by helping them to rid them of habits that they themselves have no control over. What, in your opinion—

How do they claim they can help?

Well, they say that they can improve people's, I suppose, motivation—

There is no objection against it?

—through the use of hypnotism in control, for instance, smoking or overeating or other.

You see, everything is possible by strong suggestion, and also it is possible that without the use of word media ideas can be conveyed and transferred to other people. So, all this is possible, and it is possible on the authority of the Holy Qur’an that sometimes people can be so influenced by the power of mind that they begin to see things which are not there. So, the Holy Qur’an tells us that when the magicians who confronted Hazrat Moses made the ropes appear to be snakes, they did not actually change them into snakes. Saharu a'yun-an-naas. They had only put their spell on the sights of the people. So, this is sheer and pure hypnotism. So, when the Holy Qur’an recognizes hypnotism in so many clear words, then how could we object against it and its practices? So, it is possible, it is logical, and now it has also become scientifically accepted.

Of course. Could I just continue on from that? In this sort of field of self-improvement, in religion much emphasis is given on the use of willpower to control bad habits, for instance. What I am wondering is, what part of the human psyche does hypnotism act upon? And does it act at a deeper level or a lesser level?

You see, nobody knows the centre of psychic phenomenon. In fact, as far as I believe, I think it relates to the soul. And this would again start a controversy which has been raging in the world of scientists for many years regarding the separate entity of mind and brain. So, if it is a phenomenon which is related to brain, then you have to find a centre.

And as such, scientists have not discovered any centre which can be described as the psychic centre. But many scientists of high respectability and established fame also openly claim, and have written books in support of their claim, that there has to be no psychic centre, because mind is different from brain and the entire brain is the seat of mind. So, in other words, they believe in soul, and they believe in a soul which is the master of mind and mind is not the master of soul. So, this is exactly the religious understanding. So, there does not have to be a centre for that.

Let me explain: the subject he has raised is somewhat difficult. The first point he makes is a simple one. Nowadays many people claim that through hypnotism... what is hypnotism called? No, mesmerism is something else. Hypnotism is just hypnotism. That is, they claim that by influencing the minds of others through mental powers, they can, to some extent, also free them from illnesses. By assuring someone again and again, with great confidence, that 'you will give up this disease, you will overcome this disease', they can create a power of defence within him, and as a result he can be healed of the illness. The questioner asked whether this is correct and acceptable, that is, what standing such a claim has from a religious point of view. My answer to this was that the Holy Qur’an clearly accepts these things. As far as mental powers influencing another mind are concerned, it very clearly and definitively declares that the events which took place during the contest between Hazrat Moses (as) and the sorcerers were the result of mental powers. Thus it says that when the sorcerers threw their ropes and these appeared to be snakes, they had not become snakes. Rather, the sorcerers had cast a spell on the eyes: they appeared so to the eyes, but in reality nothing had changed, and they remained ropes just as before. This shows that the Holy Qur’an clearly accepts such mental powers, which influence another person’s mind without being put into words and without the use of outward, known scientific forces. So this is possible, and if it is done for healing or for the benefit of mankind, there is no harm or objection in it.

10 of 10 left today