3. What is the religious concept of free will and how can it be reconciled with genetic and environmental factors?

Question-and-answer session, 30 June 1990

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What is the religious concept of free will and how can it be reconciled with genetic and environmental factors?

As-salāmu ʿalaykum, Huzoor. I would like you, Huzoor, to kindly explain the concept of free will in religion, you know, in relation to the psychologists' view on man's behavior, determined by genes and his environment, and so on and so forth.

On this subject also, I have spoken quite a lot, but I know it's difficult to dig out for all the old cassettes in which you'll find this subject discussed. So, I'll briefly answer this.

The fact is that whatever the background one has inherited from genes, or from one's social order, or family, or schooling, still he has a free will. So, that free will keeps on rising on the platform of his background, but that free will is never adversely influenced; he still exerts some free will.

So, the question which you have raised has been long discussed between philosophers and theology and etc., and I know what it ultimately leads to. So, I can give you a short example of a Sindhi professor who once came to meet me in Hyderabad. And he introduced himself to be a very well-talented, educated person—as he was, of course—and he told me that he has a simple question to ask, which he put to all the great scholars whom he met, but none could satisfy him: "So please, if you permit me, I would like to ask that question to you." This was the same question he asked.

And I knew his background, of course; I knew the background of this controversy. So I said, "Instead of my answering you, I can ask you a few questions and you will answer yourself your question to your own satisfaction." He was surprised. I said, "No, there is no question of being surprised; I'll demonstrate it to you." I said, "Since this morning, when you got up, how many decisions have you made?" He said, "Many." I said, "Don't you remember that at each decision-making, you were offered two choices, and you knew better than anyone else that one choice was wrong and the other choice was right? Despite your background, despite everything you can put behind your making, still you enjoy a free will, and that free will is exerted with the full knowledge—mostly, not always, but mostly with the full knowledge—of what is right and what is wrong."

"So you go on taking your decisions, and for each decision you are responsible, or are you not?" So he nodded his head, and I was surprised to find him, you know, a man that who will immediately understand. I was surprised how he could not understand it before. So he shook his head and said, "Yes, that's enough."

So this is the answer: Whatever your background, still your free will remains free. And the choice you make is the choice which either will condemn you or, or will stand you in good stead on the Day of Reckoning.

Now as far as the background is concerned, that is irrelevant here, because the inner truth always remains the inner truth. It remains the inner truth, and the light can never be extinguished permanently unless you constantly ignore the call of your conscience and deaden yourself. That death is not caused by any genetical defect, but that death is caused by your persistent wrong decisions until the voice of conscience is stilled forever. So, from then on, whatever you do, even if you don't understand it, you're responsible for that.

If that is the question you wanted to ask, then I have answered. If you had something else in mind, because I see some doubts on your face, then clarify your question, please.

No, no... you see, the background of this question is, of course, tabligh. When I get the chance to talk about religion and, you know, say man has the will, the free will, the choice to choose the right religion, first of all they use this, you know, about the genes and the environment as an excuse for the people, that you don't know, they...

But you see, already I have explained... explained to you, you can build this topic like I have, and tell them that despite all the genes, every day you make decisions about right and wrong, and you know at that time. So whatever the background of your upbringing or your inherent characters, you still are capable of taking decisions knowing them to be either right or wrong. So, because otherwise man cannot take decisions; this is a psychological question. When you do not know this, whether this is right or that is right, then you are always in two minds.

You don't know what decision to take. So the decision means your knowledge about the goodness of one aspect and the bad aspect of the other aspect—the bad character of the other aspect. So, decision-making in itself is a proof that man is responsible for his choices. Thank you, Huzoor.

Yes, please. Yes, yes, this is an important discussion. The point is that this question has come down from very old, ancient times: does man truly have a choice between right and wrong or not? It is a very ancient question, and philosophers have debated it endlessly. These questions have kept arising from religious as well as non-religious points of view, and as a result the Qadari people appeared, those who say that we have no choice at all, that is, who believe in compulsion. Therefore it is a very detailed discussion, and I do not want to go into it at this time, because then the subject will go down paths that cannot be managed.

In response to this question, I briefly gave him the following answer. There was a professor in Sindh who came to meet me in Hyderabad. Before asking me his question, he gave an introduction and said: 'I have met great saints and great scholars, and I have always asked them this question: do we have a choice regarding the decisions we make or not? No one has ever given me a satisfactory answer. And if we are helpless because of our environment, and make our decisions coloured by our environment, then why has Allah made us accountable? Why does He call us to account?' This was what he meant. 'And then, are we all helpless?' This is the same theme that Mir Taqi Mir has expressed in one of his verses:

In the black and white of this world, our
Share, such as it is, is only this much:
We wept through the night till morning,
And somehow got through the morning till evening.

'The black and white of this world' is an idiom. It means the destiny of this world, its good and evil, its good and bad. Our share is only this much: we wept through the night till morning and somehow got through the day till evening. After that he says:

[What You wish You do Yourself...] No, I knew it... its first line is:

Unjustly is this charge of free will laid upon us helpless ones;
Unjustly is this charge of free will laid upon us helpless ones;
You do whatever You wish, and You have defamed us in vain.

That is, in Your destiny You alone have power over everything; we are helpless people and have no choice whatsoever. And in the first verse he has raised the subject to a very high level, because night and day keep coming and going on their own. They do not change because someone weeps or somehow gets by. So he says that our only share in Your destiny is that we either spend it weeping or spend it laughing; we have no share beyond that. So this is the question that philosophers and religious people have debated since very ancient times. What they want to show is that if man is helpless, then why will he be called to account for his sins, and why will he be punished?

You will find light on this from various angles in my conversations that have been recorded. But as for this professor, I knew he must certainly have engaged in long debates, so I thought there was no benefit in entangling him in debates. I said to him that, instead of me, you yourself will answer your question. He asked, how so? I said, I will ask you, and you tell me; you will understand the point. I said, since you got up this morning, have you made any decisions or not? He said, yes, I have made several. I said, at the time of each decision, did you know or not that there were two paths, one wrong and one right, and did you consider yourself to have free choice at that time or not? If you wished, you could make the right decision, and if you wished, you could make the wrong one, and your background, your society, your genes had not compelled you at that time. Is this correct or incorrect? He said it is correct, and the matter ended there. He understood the issue.
What this means is that whatever the background may be, the faculty of expression that Allah the Almighty has granted to man, about which He says in the Holy Qur’an, ‘He created man and taught him plain speech’, always remains alive, except when people without conscience crush that voice, crushing and crushing and crushing it, until they finally strangle it. It probably still rises, suppressed, somewhere in the subconscious, but then it is no longer heard.
So for this too, man himself is responsible. Otherwise, whatever environment he may be passing through, at the time of every decision he knows that there is a good path and there is a bad path. If I wish, I can adopt the good path, and if I wish, I can adopt the bad path.

10 of 10 left today