4. Are boys and girls permitted to participate in out-of-school excursions if the atmosphere is similar to the one in school?

Question-and-answer session, 5 May 1991

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Are boys and girls permitted to participate in out-of-school excursions if the atmosphere is similar to the one in school?

My English is not that good, but I try to explain. I'm a teacher for children about 11 years old, and two months ago we went on some kind of working week together, the boys and the girls. And I've got a girl in my class, she's about 11 years old, and she's from Pakistan, and she couldn't come with us. And I went to home to ask, why is that? And then, yes, he couldn't explain it. And I asked, but is it because the boys and the girls together? Yes, it was not, and it wasn't that, particularly—how do you call it? And well, then I wondered: she's in the class with me with boys, she's sporting with boys, she's dressing herself where boys are, but then a week like that, she can't come. And I wondered, what's the difference between being at school and doing all those things together, and then being at a week like that and sleeping separate? But not possible.

Yes. You see, there is no difference if what you tell me happens exactly like that. Then there is no reason why such a girl should be prevented from going out if the atmosphere is as safe or as unsafe as in school during the expedition. If there is no difference, it is not wise on the part of the parents to stop their girls from participating in holiday excursions.

But one has to be realistic if what you tell me is exactly right or there is some difference. I believe that when you go out on excursions, there is every likelihood that boys and girls walk alone without being in the sight of other people, teachers and others, and the atmosphere is such that they are more likely to go astray than in the atmosphere of the school. So, perhaps these were the fears of the parents. Not that they thought they were absolutely equal, and yet they stopped them.

Moreover, in the modern society, in the schools, evils are penetrating so rapidly and so widely now that even the pupils are not safe from their own teachers. And I know as facts of life, published by authorities, investigators, etc., that these are now the problems of at least schools in England, where vice is practiced in the school between pupil-teacher relationship.

Boys are not even safe from masters, the girls are not safe, and so on and so forth. So there is a compulsion for the parents, there is a question of choices for the parents. Either they can decide to completely boycott the education system and let their children grow totally ignorant, or to take maximum precautions and yet permit them to go, practicing safety, caution, etc.

So this is the limited choice available to those Muslim parents who want to retain their moral values. But beyond that, they don't want to take risks. Here is something as a must, there is something is optional. So for the must you can take some risks, but for the optional you don't have to take risks. Right? Thank you.

10 of 10 left today