9. The first question concerns the enforcement of Sharia in Pakistan. When an oppressed woman is raped and states in court that this injustice was done to her, but cannot produce four witnesses, the court has declared her guilty and punished her as guilty of adultery. Such a case happened in Pakistan; a magazine published in Germany writes that this law will further worsen the condition of Muslim women … What is the Islamic concept regarding this?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 11 May 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The first question concerns the enforcement of Sharia in Pakistan. When an oppressed woman is raped and states in court that this injustice was done to her, but cannot produce four witnesses, the court has declared her guilty and punished her as guilty of adultery. Such a case happened in Pakistan; a magazine published in Germany writes that this law will further worsen the condition of Muslim women … What is the Islamic concept regarding this?
I understand the matter; there is no need for details. What do you want to ask? In Pakistan, this is among the actions of those who are defaming Islam. It is an entirely unlawful verdict, that is correct. [Questioner: And what is the Islamic concept if a Muslim woman approaches a court like this?] The court will decide according to the circumstances. As long as the circumstances are not clear, how can I answer? Islam commands the court: judge with justice, use reason, examine the matters, search out the truth and give judgement accordingly. So there can be no blanket verdict; in each case the decision will be made after examining the circumstances.